Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

Posts

White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#1

White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

Barry Irby

I have a rental house with a room of very high quality snow white carpet that came with the house. I know white carpet is stupid in a rental, but it came with the house and I thought I would see if I could get some use out of it. The tenant just moved out and I was left with some Magic Marker stains. I have tried various commercial spray can products and about every thing else I can think of. Bleach got the red. Amazing. Dab on a little bleach and Poof, the red is gone. Also helped on the rust colored or brown. Now I am left with the blue. Bleach did not touch it. Neither did any of the others until I got to Acetone. Dissolved and blotted up a lot of it. Still have a much fainter scribble.

I am thinking of trying to scrub in a lot of baking soda and then flooding the line with acetone. I'm thinking the baking soda will be more absorbent than paper towels and in better contact with the fibers and ink. Any reason not to combine baking soda and acetone? Is this a "Hold my beer!" moment? Any body really know how to do this?

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#2

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

John in NM

Have you tried hand sanitizer? Its basically alcohol in some kind of jelly carrier - might work to wick the ink out of the carpet fibers - assuming the ink is soluble in alcohol.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#3

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

John K Jordan

I've used lighter fluid to remove Sharpie marks.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#4

Fiber?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'd determine what the carpet fiber is before going at it with solvents. Doubt you want a melted spot where the ink was.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#5

Re: Fiber?

Barry Irby

I don't know what the fiber is. (I'm guessing nylon) I did not buy the carpet, it came with the house. This has become a "mission". My cheap/packrat gene has kicked in and I am determined to fix this problem.

I have reached the devil may care point and I will either fix it or dispose of it.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#6

Re: Fiber?

Stuart Johnson

If a closet has some of the carpet that would be a good place to try the solvents.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#7

Re: Fiber?

William Duffield

Or swap the stained carpet with some unstained carpet from the closet.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#8

Re: Fiber?

Barry Irby

If I had a closet I would have traded it out. The room is about 12' by 24' so if I buy new carpet I am looking at about $400 for "disposable" carpet.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#9

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

walta

If the carpet is in good condition other than the spot you can have it dyed in place for about 1/3 the cost of replacement.

http://dyeritecarpet.com/about.html

Walta

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#10

Re: Fiber?

William Duffield

Sorry. I hope I didn't come across as insulting. I figured there was only an outside chance it would help, but sometimes, I get wound up so tight in trying to solve a problem that I miss the obvious solutions.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#11

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

don stephan

What has the manufacturers of Magic Marker and Sharpie suggested?

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#12

Before you hand Bubba your beer,

Keith Newton

And say hey Bubba, watch thisear, oh please please please, make sure he has you phone set on video, so all your friends here on WC can see you with that Wilie Coyote look, as you stare out from the cloud of smoke with singed hair. Ha

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#13

Re: Before you hand Bubba your beer,

Barry Irby

I may be on verge of Cold Fusion. I have tried pretty much everything. The carpet may end up stained, but it will have demonstrated it can take a beating. I'm off to get rubbing alcohol and a steam iron. Next I'm going for a very powerful UV light and Ozone Generator.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#14

Re: Before you hand Bubba your beer,

Keith Newton

Barry, I don't have much experience here, but it seems like there are some products sold in the grocery, like Resolve that might be worth trying. Tide also makes a spot remover that looks like a felt tip marker.

Back in the late sixties, weren't there some better products with enzymes that were removed from the market by the EPA? That was the good stuff. Your buddy that is like mr Haney on Green Acres probably can get you some. ;>)

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#15

I understand you're struggling

Gary Smyth

with the problem. I get how it can be you against it. Hoping to relieve a bit of the frustration. If all else fails there are other ways to make the marks disappear. Work a different mindset. Do what the street artists do. Flat fuzzy surface to three D. That rental could be famous.


Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#17

Analyzing the requirement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are only two choices. Bleach it colorless, or dissolve and transfer the colored solution to some surface the dye likes better than Nylon. Considering the surface area of Nylon and it's chemical nature I am not optimistic about option #2.

Neither dilute acetic acid (vinegar)or alcohol (sanitizer) can bleach the color(vinegar might change the hue). The alcohol might dissolve the color but lacking some surface to transfer the color to it is not going to leave the high surface of the fibers. It will simply spread.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#18

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

Stuart Hough

Barry, have you tried a strong Oxyclean solution? I have used it on my carpet for all sorts of problems, and it has never let me down. (Disclaimer: I have never used it on magic marker). One thing I have found is that magic marker is designed to be VERY durable, and you might have a hint of color for a very long time.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#19

This has been interesting.....

Barry Irby

Thank you all...Bill especially spurred to the really think about the problem.

Bleach it colorless or dissolve it and float it out? I have started to think about the chemistry of the problem. Bleaches like Clorox, peroxide, Oxiclean are one approach and solvents like acetone and alcohol are another. Should have paid more attention in college chemistry 45 years ago.

Where does steam come in?

Today I am trying cellulose in the form of stuffing out of an adult diaper and solvent.

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#20

Hairspray *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

It sounds like oil free hairspray might do the trick.


Magic Marker Removal

Re: White carpet Vs. Blue marker question

#22

Re: steam will drive the dye into the fiber

Barry Irby

That's what I was thinking. In spite of the "Internet science" it seems to me this is no place for heat or steam. Seems like it would set the stain if anything.

The use of acetone and cellulose got about 95% of the stain. Good enough for a rental. My OCD side would like to get 100% but I am going to settle for what I got. This will get me another cycle out of the carpet. I am considering telling the tenant the if she signs up for a second year I will buy new carpet to replace it for her. Cheaper than moving her out and somebody else in.