Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

Posts

Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#1

Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

GolfSteve in Calgary

I screwed up (I think). I'm making some moldings out of vertical grain fir. I love the linear calm look of VGF, and kind of detest flat sawn cathedral grain.

I bought a pile of 8/4 VGF and made my first trial piece...the way the grain was oriented I ended up with flat sawn grain on the face of the molding :-( The opposite of what I wanted.

I guess I need to turn the grain 90 degrees (as shown in the sketch) so that I end up with vertical grain on the face.

Maybe I should have bought flat sawn boards so that I would end up with vertical grain on the face of the molding.

Anyone have any experience with or comments?



Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#2

correction of terms

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The correct description is either quarter sawn or rift cut depending on the details of the growth ring orientation. For fir the two are equivalent in appearance so I would just call it rift.

You can look at the end of a board, draw on the molding profile and see what the result of the growth ring orientation may be.

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#3

Re: correction of terms

GolfSteve in Calgary

Around here it's sold as vertical grain fir "VGF" - and is a mixture of quartersawn and rift sawn boards that have vertical grain on at least one face.

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#4

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir molding

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Your drawing shows the correct grain orientation, but you didn't cut your piece that way. In order to get your "quarter grain" set at 90° to your routed surface, you're going to need 3-1/2 - 4" thick stock and you'll have a lot of waste after milling all four sides of the workpiece.

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#5

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir molding

Keith Newton

I think he can use what he has. He just chose the wrong face, or edge to shape.

If he had cut the pattern in the bottom back, or top outside, this would have oriented the edge grain properly.

Just look at the end before cutting, and have the annual ring running out the top back corner, for a crown.

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#6

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir molding

TomD

Keith nailed it. If the board was restored to square, and swapped end for end to so the top surface remained nearest the ceiling, bingo.

Re: Grain direction for vertical grain fir moldings

#7

Re: correction of terms

TomD

Quarter sawn is not a grain direction it is a program for cutting a log. When you quarter saw you get some vertical and some rift. But the intention is to maximize the vertical. Though this problem illustrates a case where rift wood might be speced, none of the mills around here offer it as on their price lists. Ther isn't a lot of demand for a complex cutting program that wastes a lot of wood, minimizes dimensions and maximized rift cut wood.

More people seem to use the term "quarter sawn" when they mean vertical, but it is imprecise and incorrect as Bill illustrated. Most people don't know what rift is, but it is grain lines that run from corner to corner.