Re: Krenov engineering
TomD
"I have built two Krenov cabinets and I would not have been successful without some guidance from a Krenov student. Someone needs to do a book on Krenov engineering, that is to say his techniques for assembling these things. They are not obvious, yet essential to achieving a structurally sound piece in his style. After building one I became impressed that Krenov was a skilled engineer to figure out how to make what he envisioned."
I doubt that, and I don't know what these complexities are, plus his books detail his methods at till the mid-70s.
I would welcome a more modern book.
"To give one example, the sides are dovetailed into the top and bottom."
Dowelled right?
"There is a jig for aligning the holes to a precise fit. But why use such an inferior joint and not mortise and tenon?"
Of course today one could leap ahead and use Dominos. Well people with the machines could. I think one of his students Janofsky might have used tenons, though I also think he used dowels.
I think Krenov used dowels mainly because it is in the European tradition to do so, and because the scantlings he used were very heavy and would easily hold his projects together. I have seen chairs where the frame or legs were held with a couple of small dowels, huge loads, and I know this because they eventually failed. But he is using a ton of beefy dowels, on a project that is barely loaded at all. Also, they just had their own way of doing things. I called the College of the Redwoods when the plane video cam out, and asked them why they pared the dowels on the crosspiece, rather than use a lathe, and why they drilled the cheeks on a horizontal drill machine rather than a drill press. And they just said it was better practice that way, which has some truth to it if you like practicing bad techniques, and not learning good ones. But that isn't to say they were wrong.
" The door is made first and the cabinet fit to the door. The case will be dry fit, disassembled, adjusted and reassembled countless times to get the fit and reveals perfect. M&T would be toast by the end of it all (been there and done that on round 1). But only two dowels are used for dry fitting. When all is well they are tossed and the full complement installed."
Good point. Pretty basic stuff. I learned the hard way to figure what parts where the variable, and to build around them. I have built several tables where I made the base first according to plan, then foung the top was not coming together to size. If I have really nice boards for the top I will do what is right for them not worry about the exact dimensions, but if the base is made first (makes a good place to build the top), it can get hairy.
"The tight fitting plywood back is glued in place to provide structural rigidity."
Never saw him use a plywood back, but then the books stopped coming out about 45 years ago. He used to use a frame and panel, and had distinctive ways of cutting the edge treatments and raising the panel.