Butternut?
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
a/k/a "White Walnut"
Anyone with experience? Like/dislike/??
Have the opportunity to snag a tree on a take down. Worth schlepping to the sawyer?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Butternut?
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
a/k/a "White Walnut"
Anyone with experience? Like/dislike/??
Have the opportunity to snag a tree on a take down. Worth schlepping to the sawyer?
Re: Butternut?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I made a hutch from solid butternut about 25 years ago. It's a bit soft, softer than walnut anyway, but planes beautifully. It has stayed flat, stable, finishes very nicely. I'd definitely do it again.
Re: Butternut?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Disease has made the wood uncommon and hence valuable to some. Personally I never found a use for it but if I had easy access to some logs I would saw and sell the lumber.
It is lightweight, about like basswood. Grain like walnut but lighter in color. My cousin who built canoes used it in places.
Grain
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
My picture source shows it with rather nice grain when quarter-sawn.
Thanks
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Will inspect the tree this w-e to see likely yield.
My favorite butternut picture
Dick Coers
My friend James Pearce picked up this once in a lifetime lumber a few years ago. Butternut grafted to walnut. This case was about 7' tall, with barrister style doors for storage of a Native American blanket collection.

Re: My favorite butternut picture
Yonak
That's really fascinating, Dick. Can you post a larger picture ?
Here's a link to his website *LINK*
http://pearcepearce.com/port-2/
Re: Butternut?
don stephan
Long time professional architectural wood carver I know prefers butternut.
He's got some spiffy stuff
Yonak
Thanks for the reference.
Re: Butternut?
AZ in Colorado Springs
I've used butternut for bottom boards, tongue and groove construction, in a few joiners chests and toy boxes. I like it.
I don't know about milling a tree, but cutting the dried lumber made the shop smell like a tack room. Smells like leather when sawing it.
Re: Butternut?
Don Orr
I think is a lovely wood for most any type of woodworking. Turns very well, carves easily, planes well, finishes beautifully. One of my favorites. Tends to have worm holes on standing dead trees. Most Butternuts are on the way out due to a canker disease. The nuts when dried are fantastic.
Thanks for the thread Mark
Kevin French
I have 4 Butternuts coming down this summer. Most of it WAS headed for firewood, I think I'll look into have some sawn.
I'd go for it
Ellis Walentine
I've always liked butternut. It has a tannish brown color that is unique and not fugitive like black walnut. It's also quite soft, so I don't use it in places where it will get dented in use. The grain is very understated and not usually dramatic or figured.
My old pal in New Hampshire, Dave Mather, ran a business called Tuckaway Timber, and butternut and burls were his specialty. Birch burls mosty. But his butternut inventory was second to none. He had clear boards up to 16" wide and 10' long in his drying barn. I had a nice stockpile of his wide butternut that burned up in my shop fire in '99.
Your question reminded me of a collection of Dave's newsletter excerpts, "Splendid Splinters," that I published many years ago right here on WoodCentral. I had almost forgotten them. You can find the link in the navigation box on this page under Articles. I thought he had done one on butternut, but I couldn't find it. Anyway, thanks for the nostalgia.
Ellis