Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

Posts

Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#1

Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

tom

As I get ready to re-stain my house and Pole barn I am going to solid hide stain. On my barn I use Board & Batten cedar. Thanks to the woodpeckers and bees I have some damage but I don't want to replace the whole length,10', of vertical cedar. So I was considering making a "patch" to inlay.

I would need a pattern to route the damage out and that pattern would need to match the quantity of pre-made patches.

So how would you guys proceed?

Thanks!

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#2

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

John McGaw

Should be quite doable -- it is the same thing as a 'dutchman' in any piece of wood. I'd use a standard inlaying collar set and matching upcut spiral bit on a router. I've been doing that on my dining room table project to cover a couple of ugly knots in the stretcher and the results can be quite good. Having an irregular amorphous template can help in work like this since it somewhat masks the patch and doesn't stand out like straight edges would and doesn't call for any chisel work as a square or rectangular inlay would.

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#3

Another way

David Yoho

My first thought would be to use the inlay kit for your router that John mentioned.

Another way to go about it would be with a forstner bit and band saw. This works if your plugs are round. To plug a spot just use a large (your choice) size forstner bit to cut around the affected spot. Now you have a round hole you need to plug. With the same forstner bit in a drill press, place your patch material on the drill table and just bring the bit down onto it until the outer edge makes a mark. This is the exact circular plug you'll need to fill the hole. Carefully cut it out at the band saw and check it for fit. Adjust if needed with a file or sanding block. Use a little glue and pop in your plug.

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#4

Especially for the bee holes

Dick Coers

The bees make an almost perfect circle. David's idea is perfect for those. Woodpeckers, not so much.

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#5

Re: Another way

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A 1-3/8" hole saw will cut an almost perfect plug for a hole drilled by a 1-1/4" forstner bit. You can cut the plugs on a drill press with the center guide bit removed from the hole saw and the work piece clamped down.

Since solid-hide stain is being used, Bondo in the bee holes is quick and easy; for pecker woods as well. Using a thin blade held at 90° to the surface, the pattern in rough-cut boards can be replicated in the wet Bondo surface, and the putty can be tinted with Tints-all pigment to further blend the patch. Living in a eastern cedar sided house for 25 years. . . .

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#6

Re: Another way

C. John Hebert

That's a nice fantasy but...you need to have enough meat for the point, or pilot bit in order to create that perfect hole. Not a good idea and neither is putting a repair plate. Jeez........just buy a damned 1x and repalce it.

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#7

Some of each method... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I'd make round hole plugs with a router and a jig, then use a forstner bit to prepare the bad spot for the plug.

As has been pointed out it can be dangerous to use a forstner bit without a place for the center spur to bite. The solution is a piece of scrap with a hole created by the same bit. simply screw it to the wall where the patch will be made and drill out your bad spot.

If you have many to do, it might make sense to buy a large hole plug cutter.

Know also that lee Valley also offers large plug cutters for use in the drill press. This would make quick work of making your plugs. See link.

Plugging such flaws is a wise way to go about the work for several reasons. Economy is #1, Ease is #2, and #3 is the fact that it is tough to get new boards of the same size as the one in place. Many of these were random width, and as such it makes sense to save them if possible.

Further, second or newer growth lumber is known to not have the same lifespan as the old growth that may already be in place.

Then there's being green, which while not popular with everyone, makes sense to a lot of people.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa


Big hole plug cutters at Lee Valley

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#8

Small Correction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I did not suggest drilling holes with a forstner with the center spur removed. I did suggest using a hole saw in a drill press to cut plugs to match a forstner-drilled hole, essentially the same tool as pictured in the Lee Valley link, with the guide drill bit removed. This can be done safely but only in a drill press with the stock securely clamped to the press table. Living in a cedar sided home with siding that is anything but knot free and prone to woodpeckers and carpenter bees, I've used this technique to repair an easy 20 such holes.

Re: Inlaying Cedar patches in siding?

#9

Re: Some of each method...

AZ in Colorado Springs

I repaired some maple boards with knots last Tuesday using the technique that mark described. I used a predrilled piece of 3/4" plywood to guide the forster bit (looking through the hole allows you easily see how to position the hole, then cut the plugs using the drill press. Did this in two different sizes. Cut down about 3/8" using the hole saw then cut the plugs free at the band saw. (I only needed plugs about 1/4" thick. You'd probably make them thicker.) I used a disc sander to size the plugs perfectly. Tilted the bed of the sander slightly to put a taper on the plugs.