I just went through the process of jointing 88" boards with my router & a 1/2" x 96" piece of aluminum for a fence. They turned out OK but I would still like to get it better on the next job. What have y'all used for a straight edge with a router?
I'm thinking about buying a piece of 96" steel or aluminum 4 to 6" wide so there's no chance of it bending?
I use a 100" straight edge made from extruded aluminum. It joins in the center with a steel fitting that slides into each piece about 5". You'll probable find one at the Borg in the tool section sold as "saw guide" or such.
Had mine for a good 25 years and still straight. Used it with a router but mostly with the circ saw when breaking down sheet goods.
Its probably not the straightness of the metal that causes the deviation, more likely its our inability to keep the edge of the router against the metal with uniform snugness over the distance.
You can buy a long track from Festool that has a raised area that is captured in a mating groove in the base of the router. Its snugged up with a variable diameter nut to eliminate slop. It will cut dead straight.
I would imagine that it wouldn't be too hard to make something like that in the shop. Maybe buy some 1/2 metal bar, attach it to a long flat board. Then cut a 1/2 groove into some wood, fit in a couple of set screws and attach to the bottom of the router.
Haven't done this myself. I was lazy and just bought the track. But it sounds doable...
... using a hand plane to final-joint the edges. A sharp #6 or #7 plane should give you invisible joints in a few well-controlled passes.
Your question is a good one, as we all are limited by circumstance, tooling and skill levels. If you have a well-tuned motorized jointer with sharp blades, you should get excellent joints with no further attention required. Absent a jointer, routers and fences are time-honored and highly controlled ways of creating a desired pattern, straight or curved; but, as someone mentioned, technique can still be an issue. The captive-rail type straightedge gizmos make a lot of sense to me.
If your straightedges are the problem, you can have a machine shop straighten them out for you, and/or use a hand plane to shave the high spots. Offer the edges up to each other and see where the high spots are, and practicing your planing technique to bring them into perfect collusion, or slightly sprung as many woodworkers advocate.
If it's bending you are concerned about, steel is less flexible than aluminum - but the added weight may make it too awkward to use comfortably.
I think I would look at the aluminum guide rails that Festool and other companies sell, the tool or sled indexes on a raised part of the extrusion so that you don't need to use it as an edge guide, so it can be made very thin and wide. You don't necessarily need to purchase a matching router to go with it if you can come up with a wooden sled to mate your current router to the guide.
The other thing that occurs to me is that I've very rarely needed to joint a full 8' or more. I rough cut all my parts a bit long - say 1/4" to 1/2" - before flattening and squaring. This makes all the following operations easier - but if you're not flattening the lumber with a jointer/planer set up, this may not be part of your cutting process. It would make your edge jointing routine a lot easier though.
A local guy invented this thing and sold it to Hawk. It's based on the idea of complimentary curves match. It's not that the rig is dead straight (although his were pretty good), but if you rout on one side of the straightedge for one piece, and the other side for the second piece, the two match perfectly. They use a light gauge steel square tube, with a piece of particleboard screwed to the bottom. Your router base plate rubs against the steel tube but is supported by the particle board. The particleboard is wide to start with, then machined on both sides before you make your first cuts. That leaves you with a perfect locating edge for where the router will cut. Very easy to make yourself. It really works well!
If you set the two boards side by side, so there is a gap less than your bit diameter, and you set the fence to the left, and plow through the gap, you will get complimentary surfaces.
You need to be sure that the fence to the left, and the piece on the left will always have at least as much cut as the side on the right, or you will get a climb cut.
The jointer plane is the better way, but it leads to stones, and ponds, and benches, and endless discussions.