Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

straightening a bowe

Posts

straightening a bowe

#1

straightening a bowe

mike mcnerney

I am planning some already skipped dressed 1 3/16" x 9" x 84" walnut.

Since I don't have a wide jointer, I have built a sled for my thickness planer.

I am taking off a little under 1/8" from the best side of the board to get it closer to flat & then removing it from the sled & finishing it to about 1" .

However the boards are turning out a little bowed, down the 7 ft. length. I am willing to plane some more off if necessary (in a few days) and here is my question.

Are they more likely to straighten out if I plane the concave or convex side?

cheers

MM

Re: straightening a bowe

#2

Describe Your Sled


Re: straightening a bowe

#3

Re: Describe Your Sled

mike mcnerney

Why? It's the same as the American woodworker video.

1.5 x 10 mdf. Screw the boards down with shims at the appropriate places

mm

Re: straightening a bowe

#4

Because

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If the sled's not straight and stiff enough and/or you don't use enough blocks under the workpiece the pressure rollers on the planer will cause it to just replicate the bow.

Re: straightening a bowe

#5

Re: straightening a bowe

Hank Knight

It is my understanding that a board loses moisture from a freshly planed surface in order to regain equilibrium with the unplaned surface. If you plane the convex side of the bow (the outside of the curve) the newly planed surface will lose moisture and "shrink" while the inside of the curve (the concave surface) will remain relatively stable. Theoretically, this should help counteract the bow.

As a practical tip, if you're going to plane the bow out of the board, cut the long board to the approximate lengths you will use in your project before you plane it. You would nreed to remove a lot more material to get rid of a bow along the length of an eleven foot board than you would a five foot board. The shorter the board, the less you need to remove to get it flat along its length.

Re: straightening a bowe

#6

Re: Because

mike mcnerney

OK I think I'm getting your point. I looked at his video again & his sled is about 6 ft & he's flattening a 5 ft. piece. Even though my sled is built the same way it is 8 ft. & my pieces are 7 ft. I guess it may not be ridged enough? Also I put shims every 12 inches & he put them about 7,8 inches. So with all those factors that may have been the issue of 'producing' a bowed board.

Thanks for your feedback.

How about my original question. Or do you think it won't matter which side (concave or convex) I continue thicknessing from?

mm

Re: straightening a bowe

#7

Run It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

with the bow up and the two ends touching. Be careful that the two ends are touching across the full width lest you plane a twist into your workpiece. I shim every 6", put pencil marks on the board to monitor the cut, and take very light cuts. Make sure that your sled and everything is well supported on both the infeed and outfeed. I use 2 roller stands on each side.

Re: straightening a bowe

#8

Re: Run It

Barry Irby

I agree with Mark. I "think" your sled is too flexible. My experience is that MDF is pretty flexible.

As far as the effect of planing.....If the lumber is at equilibrium internally and you take a cut off one side.....If it is dryer than the surroundings and acquires moisture it will become more convex, If it is wetter and it drys it will become more concave. I think.