Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Butcher block top

Posts

Butcher block top

#1

Butcher block top

Joe Pack

My daughter-in-law wants a butcher block topped rolling kitchen cart/island. I plan to use 2" hard maple. Any better choices? Also, would you make it an end grain visible top or an edge grain top?

Re: Butcher block top

#2

Re: Butcher block top

Dick Coers

I'm not a fan of 8/4 tops. It's more expensive, and the supplier has to be good for it to be properly kiln dried. There can be cracking if it's not dry and moves. Also your jointer has to be in tune to get a good glue up because it's tougher to clamp up and get the wood to move if it's bowed a little. You can get an odd color deal with 8/4 because the core can be slightly different than the surface. To do end grain, you better have a drum sander!

Re: Butcher block top

#3

Maple  BTDT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey


Did 1-1/2" x 36' x 5' hard maple with cherry accents for the top that sits at "bar" height. Keep in mind that it will be very heavy. Made the mistake of used Waterlox for the finish. The first hot pot led to refinishing the top.

:(

Also keep in mind that it will have to go through 30" doorways to get into the kitchen so you should plan on some on-site assembly.

Re: Butcher block top

#4

I have done one

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....for daughter. She finds it to be an essential kitchen addition. I made the top from maple 2 x 2 strips edge glued. Looks good that way. I realized I never took a picture of it.

Re: Butcher block top

#5

ps

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

strips oriented to be along the depth (short length). Glue it up in sections that can go through the planer and then glue these assemblies one joint at a time.

Re: Butcher block top

#6

Re: Butcher block top

Barry Irby

I agree that hard maple would be an excellent choice. End grain would be good but problematic. Tends to be "brittle" and crack from shrinking and swelling.

Have you thought about buying a ready made butcher block top? (would that be cheating?)

Don't make it too big without considering moving it and getting it through doors.

Re: Butcher block top

#7

Re: Butcher block top

ChuckInND

For bacterial reasons I'm not a big fan of making a food cutting surface out of wood, but if I did I would not do it in the end grain style because end grain can really absorb the juices in whatever your cutting.

Re: Butcher block top

#8

Re: Butcher block top

John McGaw

One needed bit of information: is the surface meant to be a cutting/chopping/butchering/carving surface or is it just for looks? It makes a huge difference in the material and construction.

On one hand making a decent large end-grain maple surface is a real bear to handle in the normal home shop; even smaller blocks can be maddening to deal with. On the other hand, edge grain is more manageable in the small shop and, if it is held together with concealed metal rods, splitting and movement is not much of a problem and drilling the rod holes with an accurate jig will largely alleviate the problem of leveling the surface.

On the third hand, one can purchase really great ready-made 'butcher block' which is relatively inexpensive, easy to handle, and is available in many sizes and thicknesses. It is nothing to be ashamed of -- you don't make your own screws and hinges do you?

Re: Butcher block top

#9

Re: Butcher block top

paul in AZ

That myth about wood and bacteria has been debunked repeatedly.

Re: Butcher block top

#10

Sub-Assemblies

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Exactly. I did the one pictured in three sets of 12" width. Goal was 1-1/2" thick so strips were cut 1-3/4" wide from 1-1/8 thick board stock (the Systematic Glue-line earned its price), strips run through the P'Max to get repeated 1" thickness with no tear-out, then glued up on the wide side. The extra 1/4" in "thickness" was used to get the sections dead flat and straight. Lastly, the whole top was run through the 22-44 to get the top surface flat.

[Yeah, with a 1-1/2x36x60 maple top, I had help putting the mutha through the sander]

;)

Re: Butcher block top

#11

Re: Butcher block top

John K Jordan

I made one 30+ years ago with 4/4 hard maple.

I cut the maple boards into 2" wide strips and hand planed the 2" sides for gluing. Working only with my inexperienced self, I drilled holes in all boards except for the outer two, applied glue, and bolted them together with three or four lengths of 3/8" all-thread rod then glued on the end pieces and clamped.

It's held up fine except for two end cracks from being right up against a hot stove top for 20 years.

JKJ