Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

Posts

Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

#1

Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

Joe Pack

I am looking at some 1/2" baltic birch at a "real" lumber supplier and at Menards. The lumber supplier offers 5x5 sheets/25 square feet (brand currently unknown) for $39 $1.56/ft. Menard's offers 4x8 sheets/32 square feet (TigerPly brand) for $58 $1.81/ft. Menards is 8 miles away. The lumber supplier is 45 miles away, but carries exotics and a full line of other goodies.

Anybody have an idea of how the Menard's TigerPly compares with the generally accepted quality of "real" baltic birch? Is it worth the trip to go to the lumber supplier instead of Menard's?

Re: Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

#2

Re: Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

Keith Newton

Without seeing both, it is hard to say, however, I would take notice of how well the faces are sanded. Sometimes it seems they leave it too coarse.

Aside from that, I would look at your cut-list. I can always get better part yield from the longer 8' length, than from 5', with less scrap.

Re: Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

#3

Re: Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My local Menards doesn't carry what they call Baltic Birch anymore. I went in one time last fall, and the yokel I talked to didn't even know what it was and didn't know how to spell "Baltic" anyway.

That said, the last time I used it, it wasn't anywhere close to being as stable as real BB. I bought a sheet of 1/2" BB at Menards for a wine cabinet, and it warped badly. In fact, it didn't stop moving until I glued it into place. The only thing I can say good about it was that at least it didn't have any voids.

I prefer the 5X5' stuff if you can get it and even though the measurement is more difficult to work with.

BTW, I find Appleply pretty decent to work with. It's more stable, has bunches of plies and the edge looks nice.

Re: Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

#5

Re: Baltic Birch v Menards Baltic Birch

don stephan

"Real" Baltic birch is made in the Baltic countries and the crates are labelled in Cyrillic. The local hardwood lumber distributor also has "real" baltic birch in 4 x 8 sheets.