Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

cutting board

Posts

cutting board

#1

cutting board

ben d.

A friend of mine has some very nice red oak and wanted to know if I could make him a cutting board from it and I advised against it because of the open pores in red oak. Was I correct in this or is there a sealer than can be used to keep stuff out of the pores so it is not a health hazard.

ben d.

Re: cutting board

#2

Re: cutting board

paul in AZ

I agree with you.

"very nice red oak" is kind of an oxymoron. To me its firewood.

But, if the wood is somehow special it could be sealed with some sort of surface finish and called a 'presentation board'. i.e. not to be cut on or used with anything wet.

Re: cutting board

#3

JL

Re: cutting board

JL

I make rolling pins every now and then.

My test for rolling pin wood (which can be applied to cutting board wood) is I take a handful of flour and wipe it over the surface of a planed, sanded piece of wood. If I can wipe off the flour with a damp cloth or paper towel - it is a good wood to use for rolling pins. If enough of the flour remains to visibly change the color or appearance of the wood, I don't use it.

I do the same for wood cutting boards.

Re: cutting board

#4

Re: cutting board

ChuckInND

I was a meat cutter for about 17 years. The feds and maybe the state also banned wood cutting boards many years ago.

Re: cutting board

#5

Re: cutting board

Howard Acheson

You are correct. Red oak is a poor choice for a cutting board. The open pores absorb food juices which can cause bacteria to grow in the wood.

Re: cutting board

#6

Research doesn't support your statement

Dick Coers

“Hardwoods, like maple, are fine-grained, and the capillary action of those grains pulls down fluid, trapping the bacteria – which are killed off as the board dries after cleaning,”

https://news.ncsu.edu/2014/09/cutting-boards-food-safety/

We soon found that disease bacteria such as these were not recoverable from wooden surfaces in a short time after they were applied, unless very large numbers were used. New plastic surfaces allowed the bacteria to persist, but were easily cleaned and disinfected.

http://faculty.vetmed.ucdavis.edu/faculty/docliver/Research/cuttingboard.htm

One of the most unexpected results was that the wooden boards actually killed 99.9% of the bacteria within a few minutes.

http://www.iasj.net/iasj?func=fulltext&aId=93069

Re: cutting board

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: cutting board

Jack Guzman from Maine

I don't know about the science of it but I built two cutting boards years ago. One maple and one red oak. When I'm cutting meat I use the maple one but I never noticed a problem with either board. When I cut meat I clean the board with hot water and detergent. My wife reoils both boards periodically. ---Jack

Re: cutting board

#8

The Real Problem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is "Cross-contamination" which occurs when you use one board for different tasks without sterilizing the surface after each operation.

Don't cut raw meat on a board, especially chicken, turkey, and all store-bought ground meat or sausage, then use the same board to cut up veggies for salad or to prepare some other food that will be eaten uncooked; you'll be eating raw meat and any pathogens in it if you do.

The issue is fairly easy to avoid by simply using different "coded" CB's for different stuff. We have three sets of boards: white for raw meats, green for veg, and blue for fruits. If, for instance, it's a mixed protean meal, like surf-n-turf, two white boards are used.

Our working boards are HDPE plastic that get cleaned with chlorine bleach after each use and then run in the dish washer.

I also have several wood "carving" boards for cooked meat only.

We could replace our plastic boards with wood, but wood doesn't look very nice after repeated chlorine bleachings.

If you have trouble storing different boards, you can minimize your risk through a work-flow routine where you make the salad first, then to-be-cooked stuff second, and the meat last, followed by a sterilizing wash before the next use.

Re: cutting board

#9

Re: Research doesn't support your statement

Richard McComas

After reading all the replies I discovered I should be dead...............but I'm not.

Don't get me started on the government banning things either..............the government hasn't proven

to me they are all that bright.

Re: cutting board

#10

Nah, Just Lucky

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

G-I illness has accelerated over the years since we (let alone our grandparents) were kids. The supply demands for a population increased several times over since then has challenged how food gets from the farm to our forks, and the "old ways" of preparation are just not sufficient to make it safe to eat.

95+ of all raw chicken carries the compylobacter microbe. A USDA inspector has less than 2 seconds to "inspect" each chicken as they fly by on the inspection line, and can't do a bacteriological test anyway . Hence they tell you to cook it to 160° to safely kill that pathogen.

My grandfather was an old-time butcher with his own shop. He repeatedly told me to never eat chopmeat that you haven't ground yourself from a fresh cut of meat that you rinsed well in fresh water. He didn't have knowledge of bovine e-coli infections, but he surely did know how to keep his family and customers safe.

My father died from a Listeria encephalitis infection from eating some fresh fruit that he didn't wash first. He didn't understand what happened to him, and it was a very tough way to go. Listeria is very common and is easily removed by washing the surface of fruits and vegetable before cutting. Normally it will get a healthy person a slight upset stomach, but in kids and others with less effective immune systems like older people it can easily migrate to the spine and then to the brain resulting in death as it kills brain tissue.

Bottom line is we, in 2016, have to take more precautions handling and preparing food than did our predecessors in order to put safe food on our table.

Re: cutting board

#11

Re: The Real Problem

Bill Howatt

Good plan. Most cases of what people call the stomach flu are really food poisoning and a lot of that is from cross-contamination which your method for using cutting surfaces would avoid. Unfortunately, these days fruits and vegetables are also carriers so care needs to be taken after processing them as well.

Bill

Re: cutting board

#12

Re: The Real Problem

ben d.

Thanks for the replies and I will see what he wants done.

ben d.