Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Question for you physicist

Posts

Question for you physicist

#1

Question for you physicist

Keith Newton

A couple of my cabin neighbors are wanting to build floating boat docks out in front of their cabins. Seeing how badly they were starting out, I thought I would offer some friendly advice and help. They were planning on using poly chemical drums for floatation. One of them got a portion done, and in less than a month, I guess someone got too much weight to one side, and they all popped out. He was having one heck of a time getting them back under.

There is a plant along my route going down there that makes foam insulating panels for large freezers, and roofs using Polyisocyanurate foam, which is closed cell, I think,,,,,, or at least that is what the fellow selling their seconds or rejects said. I thought they were polyurethane when I bought a couple of panels.

After finding out that they are Polyisocyanurate, I've been searching the net to see if I can find out if they are suitable for our needs or not, but I'm not finding anything very convincing, and the tech guy at the home office for the plant hasn't returned my call.

So today, I thought I would do my own test, so I cut out a round bar that would fit into a fruit jar which was an inline moisture filter for a vacuum line. I put the sample in there with a puck of lead to hold it under, then filled it with hot water from the faucet, then pulled 25" hg. I'm sure that if anyone had been watching, they could have seen my disappointment as the bubbles grew and increased around that foam sample.

I figured that when I released the vacuum, that an equal amount of air would slowly enter the foam, so I went on about my daily task until a few minutes ago, when I thought I should pull another vacuum to see if more bubbles came out. After reaching 25" of mercury again, there weren't any bubbles, even after about 5 minutes. I thought to myself, oh my gosh, it must already be totally saturated.

But then, when I took it out, instead of weighing about the same as a cup of water, if felt as light as when I put it in the jar. I got my smile back after that, and did a head slap when I realized what I had overlooked in my experiment.

I'm sure some of you already know what threw me, but for the rest, I'll share.

Water boils at a lower temperature as the atmospheric pressure drops, and 25" of mercury is a pretty deep drop, so my hot tap-water must have been boiling, rather than pulling air out of my sample.

I weighed my sample after bandsawing, before putting it in. It measured 3" tall, by 2" diameter, and weighed 6 grams. It gained 1.5 grams, after drying it with a cloth, but it still feels moist, so that may mostly be water caught in the broken cells on the outside.

Does this sound like a good enough test? I know almost everything is somewhat permeable over a long enough time. But the price is just so darn good for this material in this format,,,,, or size.

Re: Question for you physicist

#2

Re: Question for you physicist

TomD

Sounds more like a question for a boatbuilder, or a chemist.. I can play the former. I am not sure what you are planing to do with the stuff , but guess that you are dropping it in the water for ever or a long time, with a dock over top of it.

Did I read correctly that your test shows that the material took on 25 percent of it's weight in water? That sounds pretyt bad. If the dock is pulled and it freezes in that condition the foam may start to fracture and you can end of with a horrid mess. Polystyre is used a lot in the situation you seem headed for, and the bonds between the nodules are not as strong and the nodules and the result is beaches covered with styrofoam pellets. This is pressumably the reason for the use of drums. I live next to the water and most floating docks today are built using the blue barrels, or interlocking square dock modules. That is nice, but many do make a run for it. One would think that one could limit that outcome by properly detailing the structure, did they use plans, or at least a detail sheet?

I personally wouldn't use foam because the environment is pretty hostile to it. Freezing, mechanical loading, sunlight, and water. But I couldn't get any info online about the type of foam you are contemplating. Except for one article that seemed to say it was suitable for level floatation which is a very different use since one hopes never to have to rely on it.

The USCG is a possible source, or the EPA.

Re: Question for you physicist

#3

Re: Question for you physicist

Keith Newton

Thanks for your input Tom. Well, that volume of foam was very light, so that tiny gain of water relative to it seems high, but after posting, I tried to weigh the volume of water that the foam would displace, but I only had 200 grams of weights for my little balance scale, which wash't high enough to balance the arm, so 1.5 relative to that is much smaller, and some of that may dry off, if it is all on the outside.

Freezing is not a big deal down here. I've only seen this creek frozen over once in my life.

These blocks are 6" thick, by about 45" wide, and around 10'long. We'll be using 2x4 joist and band, with a 2x6" outer band to capture the foam with 2" down over the edge, and the deck will be full 1" x 6" treated deck lumber. When the lumber is wet, it will probably sink 1.5" into the water, leaving only 2.5"of exposure to UV, so not much exposure.

There aren't many boats making wakes to deal with, and it is too sheltered for any wind generated wave activity.

I recently dug waterlogged spray in foam out of the bilge of an old boat, so I know I don't want that.

Thanks for your suggestions.

Re: Question for you physicist

#4

Re: Question for you physicist

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In spite of the name assigned it is a urethane foam, which can be made from various components. "Urethane" just says how the components are linked together. Typically urethanes are not stable in light over time. On the other hand if it is cheap and lasts a few years its stability in light may be unimportant. Ditto if it is largely closed cell.

Re: Question for you physicist

#5

Re: Question for you physicist

Barry Irby

Not a chemist or a bat builder, but if the price is right go for it, but make a provision to replace it when necessary. Buy a few spares. Make your design keep the sun light off it. (The reason to buy spares is you may lose your source.)

Re: Question for you physicist

#6

Thanks Bill,

Keith Newton

I was hoping you would weigh in on this. Since the blocks are only 6" high, and there is a 2" lip, then part of the remaining 4" will be under water, there shouldn't be much Sun exposure.

ANother of the nice things about this stuff, is that the deck will be only 8 above the water. All of the gents are getting long in tooth and ears, and all have bad knees, which will make it nice stepping over into small boats.

I put my sample back on the scales this morning, and am happy to report that it is back to its starting weight, which would indicate that the weight gained was all on the roughed up surface.

Re: Question for you physicist

#7

The reason to use....

Brian Roberts

the blue barrels is cost, availability and ease of installation.

Several friends have boat houses (not houseboats) and they have all gone to the blue barrels.

The only reason for needing replacement is the occasional leak....which causes them to sink.

Installation is done by filling them with enough water to make them neutrally buoyant ... slide them under the object to be floated....then using a compressor to force the water out....and voila.....up they float.

There are a number of methods used to accomplish the "valving" needed to do the water sinking and air floating regime.

They are not normally captive to the boathouse.....thus they fall to the river bottom when they leak and sink. It is just not practical or necessary to attach the underneath.

If, however, you desired less than the full buoyancy offered by the empty barrels you could attach them to a dock and only blow out enough water to float the dock to the desired height.

Re: Question for you physicist

#8

Can't help with specifics

Gary Smyth

But perhaps help. CHECK BEFORE PURCHASE!!

You may still have a bit of time to review some book learnin' I found three that may serve. Found on "Used and Out of Print" book sites.

Building and Maintaining Docks (Residential), Chris Lamping (2007) near $10

Outdoor Recreation Projects. James L. Bright (1978) about $9 but some far more expensive

Dock Manual,-Design, Build, Maintenance. Max Burns,(1999) about $6.50

I have not looked at any of these, so make sure it is for residential docks. No large Navy or commercial docks. You can also just write in the title and author and be able to find a book seller you can call and they will pull the book and tell you more about it.

The books can be found on used book online sellers like Alibris or ABE, even Amazon, but they are more expensive books.

Re: Question for you physicist

#9

Re: The reason to use....

TomD

"They are not normally captive to the boathouse.....thus they fall to the river bottom when they leak and sink. It is just not practical or necessary to attach the underneath."

Sounds like your tribe knows how to use them. Around my bay you can pick up blue barrels any time of the year. They make a break for it, but the bay has a narrow outlet, and most presumably stay on our waters. I would like to rescue them since they are trash at this point, but they are often impossible to move, filled with mud or frozen in place.

Re: Question for you physicist

#10

I didn't mean....

Brian Roberts

to suggest that their sinking is not a problem.

They do indeed become a trash problem if left on the bottom.

Not sure if they are better or worse, in the long run, than the old steel barrels....which sank WAY more often.

Both required an owner who gave a damn and kept an eye on his barrels.

Re: Question for you physicist

#11

more info

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

daughter works with former Dow product manager for this stuff. She will ask.