Maple sawdust as mulch
DocJim
I've been making a bed out of hard and soft maple and have generated a lot of sawdust and chips. Anyone know if it is safe and harmless to plants so it can be used as mulch? I know walnut is pretty toxic to most plants.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Maple sawdust as mulch
DocJim
I've been making a bed out of hard and soft maple and have generated a lot of sawdust and chips. Anyone know if it is safe and harmless to plants so it can be used as mulch? I know walnut is pretty toxic to most plants.
Fine
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
I use it all the time. You may hear that it depletes nitrogen (wood rot fungi use nitrogen) but its more than made up if you use fertilizer on your beds anyway. I use 46-0-0 as ice melter on my walks and will sprinkle a bit on the mulch to assist.
KD walnut is not toxic to plants
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I have tested KD walnut wood waste mulch on supposedly sensitive tomatoes and peppers and found no effect. I have added tons of walnut sawdust from sawing logs to a garden spot, let it compost a year and found no adverse effects.
However, rotting wood takes nitrogen. If it is KD it won't rot fast enough to be an issue for nitrogen depletion.
Re: Maple sawdust as mulch
Yonak
"I know walnut is pretty toxic to most plants." The misinformation continues. Walnut is not pretty toxic to most plants.
The subject chemical, juglone, is present mostly in the buds, the nut hulls and the roots, to a lesser extent in the leaves and stems and in negligible concentrations in the wood itself.
The list of plants that you should not plant around a live tree, because the juglone is also present in the soil around the roots of the tree, is very limited. Here is the list :
Annuals and vegetables : asparagus, cabbage, eggplant, flowering tobacco, pepper, petunia, potato, tomato.
Herbaceous perennials : autumn crocus, baptisia, columbine, lily (Asian hybrids), peony, rhubarb
Shrubs : blueberry, red chokeberry, cotoneaster, Amur honeysuckle, hydrangea, lilac, privet, potentilla, rhododendron, yew, and some viburnum shrub species
Trees : European alder, white birch, crabapple species, hackberry, larch, linden, saucer magnolia, mugo pine, red pine, white pine, Norway spruce, silver maple, and some viburnum tree species
Other plants are safe. Additionally, juglone is water soluble and leaches out in a matter of weeks. Also, walnut is safe in cutting boards. Please spread the word.
Re: Maple sawdust as mulch
Ralph lipeles
Black Walnut shavings are toxic to horses.
Sawdust of all woods can be used as mulch for planting beds. Use some fertilizer to offset the nitrogen depletion that occurs when the sawdust decomposes.
some myths never seem to die
Re: Maple sawdust as mulch
don stephan
Well Bill, my experience parallels the "myth." The last garden I made when I was younger extended under a mature walnut tree at one corner. The first row at that end of the garden was caged tomatoes, the second potatoes. The first tomatoes and potatoes furthest from the tree's drip line did well. As these two rows approached and moved under the drip line the tomatoes and potatoes did progressively worse by mid June. Only those first few plants in each row produced, the plants under the drip line died by the end of July. The rest of the garden, and all the others did well as usual.
I'm glad you had a good experience, but that one incident does not disprove the experience of thousands.
?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Did you read either the title or body of what I wrote? Our two experiences have nothing to do with one another, other than they share the word "walnut".
Re: Maple sawdust as mulch
Barry Irby
Don, This discussion comes up here over and over. You have brought up an entirely different question. This question was about using maple shavings and sawdust and then slide off into a discussion of walnut sawdust.
The "myth" is that walnut sawdust if used as mulch or a soil amendment will kill plants. There is very little evidence that this is true. The supposition is that the wood contains the same chemical (juglone) that the roots, bark, twigs, leaves, and sap do. It does but to such a small degree it is nearly harmless. So using walnut sawdust in an other wise healthy and well fertilized garden will have little or no more negative effect than any other sawdust.
Your situation is that you planted near a walnut tree, inside the drip line. This is the zone the tree tries to protect with a heavier dose of the chemical from the roots to keep the competition at bay. Planting a garden under any tree is dicey. Your garden plants have to compete with the tree for the nutrients and water and they may be shaded by the tree.
I have seen many situations where a row of plants under a tree grow at different rates depending on their distance from the tree.
Also, as mentioned several times above, the decomposition of the sawdust consumes nitrogen out of the soil. this process is much more aggressive than the plants trying to feed on it, so the plants suffer unless you boost the amount of nitrogen in the soil. Composting the sawdust first with some green material or nitrogen first will reduce the effect.
some nitrogen clarification
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Green sawdust can compost at a rate that can temporarily deplete nitrogen. I have not seen dry shop waste decompose at a rate that would deplete nitrogen. Even here in rot prone TN it takes a year for sawdust to disappear in my garden.
Feed It
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
The wood-eating fungi ("Black Rot" and "White Rot") need water and, like all vegetables, nitrogen to grow and function. These are, of course, the same fungi that cause spalting. They go dormant in dry wood. Not sure if kiln drying destroys them, but their spores are everywhere and will find their way to your outdoor saw dust pile.
If you want your sawdust to break down faster keep it wet and add some 46-0-0 to it from time to time to boost the rot process.
Re: Feed It
Barry Irby
I had a pile of sawdust ad grass clippings that I had thoroughly wet. Looked out one cool morning and it was steaming. I stuck a thermometer in it and it said it was over 120 degrees. I did not believe that lying ass thermometer so I stuck my hand in the pile. Does not take me long to look at hot compost. Had to apologize to the thermometer.
Re: Feed It
John K Jordan
I compost big piles of equine/camelid manure mixed with dirt and old hay, stir with the tractor. I've seen it get so hot inside the pile that pockets of hay were turned to ashes!
I got some square bales of hay last year that were not completely dry. My thermocouple probes indicated 140+ degrees F on one bale. I monitored the temperature on selected bales for several days to see if it was going up or down. I store mine in a metal building far from the barn - plenty of barns have burned down over the years due to heat from wet hay.
JKJ
Re: Feed It
don stephan
Saw a TV show on composting once that said the goal is to have the internal temp reach 150 degrees F during the process. Might have been to kill weed seeds, maybe fungus, not sure.