There is a show called Barnwood Builders. The head guy is Marc Bowe. He and his crew take down old log buildings and re-purpose them. I think they are out of WV, but they go far and wide.
They talk about the different types of wood the logs are made of and have a high regard for poplar and not so much for oak.
Once when I considered poplar as the battens for board and batten siding Bill mentioned it will rot while you watch. I used cedar. I am wondering why the poplar logs seem to hold up when others don't? Different type of poplar?
Interesting. Yellow poplar (not true poplar, popple, aspin!) was and is a common wood for barn siding. I've taken down siding that was probably 50 years old and found a variety of wood, poplar, walnut, oak, etc. I also found it used for girts and perlins.
I've used y.poplar myself as outbuilding siding but I prefer cedar and oak. (green oak). Any wood will rot if it gets wet and stays wet, such as close to the ground. I run a 2x12 PT band around the bottom and fasten the bottoms of the boards a little off the ground.
I used board and batten red oak on my chicken house and it's solid after 12 years. For barn siding I mount the boards tight together and let the shrinkage leave an air gap.
BTW, I do prefer cedar (eastern red cedar, to be clear) for siding and have used it in a couple of places. It cedar makes great exterior doors for out-buildings, applied over pressure treated plywood to prevent sagging and painted with BLO.
I've got a lot of poplar on my property and a lot of it is/was standing dead or down. I cut and split a ton of it to burn in my woodshop barrel stove. Some never got used because oaks and maples came down and were better for burning. Fifteen to twenty plus years later, after sitting stacked in the shade, the splits on the ground and the ones on top are rotting. The ones in the middle of the stack are still solid. In fact I'm going to toss the rotting ones into the brush rows and bring the sound ones out into the sun to dry. They are good for a quick, hot fire.
Poplar heartwood is somewhat rot resistant. The sapwood will rot in a year if it is in a location where it stays damp. In every case I know of the siding on local barns is oak. The window frames on old cabins were poplar. I never really noticed the log species. Will study that situation. Barn pole framing is all oak in the old barns on our property.
Regarding the poplar log question, my home has a major portion built in 1867 of poplar logs. It was exposed until the mid 1950's when it was covered in siding. We took the second floor off in 1985 and donated the logs to a local youth museum, as well as logs from a log barn that was just as old. They rebuilt the barn as it was, without siding. They used the logs to repair other log structures that did have some damage. 31 years later, and with full exposure, the majority of the logs are still sound. These logs were up to 24" thick and had been shaved down with an adze to approx. 1 foot thick, the cap log was 24" x 24". I do not know why these poplar logs last so long, but they do. Also, I have some magazines from the W.M. Ritter lumber company for their employees, in one they instruct the employees to check every down poplar log, even if covered in moss, to see if it is still sound enough to mill.
Consider this an act of God for the good life you might have led. I built a goat barn about 13yrs ago out of some poplar logs given to me. I boarded in the structure with 1x's on 3 sides with poplar. All 3 sides have rotted 2' from the bottom so bad you can see through them. The side that was done in Hemlock is only greyed but sound.