Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Philosophical furniture question

Posts

Philosophical furniture question

#1

Philosophical furniture question

Barry Irby

I want to make some furniture for my family. Oddly (?) I am thinking of it as "legacy" furniture. Something for them to remember me by. Or maybe a reason for them to remember me at all.

What bothers me about this is I don't see many people buying nice furniture and keeping it for generations. Has our attitude toward furniture changed or did I have the wrong idea, since I grew up in a house full of antiques? Has furniture become disposable? Not sure there is going to be any antique IKEA furniture. If I made such furniture would it be more of a curse than a blessing?

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#2

Re: Philosophical

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Our "Last Year's Chevy" society has been indoctrinated with the new-is-better ethic which in turn fuels the constant transmogrification of style. From schmatas to sheet metal, last year's must-haves are, well, so "last year" that the baseline of durable quality gets lost in the haze of up-to-date. You, Barry, should be well aware of this since you are a house-flipper and must deal with marketability of old/dated kitchens etm.

That said, there will always (I suspect) be those who value craft and quality. If the item has added symbolism ("Grandpa made this for me/us') it may sustain its perceived value for a while longer. But just as the photographs in the album fade with the number of people who knew or who can identify those in the images, the cache of family heirloom is likely to slip away.

If what we make is the measure of our immortality, short indeed will be its length.

Make stuff for them because you love them and love to do it.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#3

Re: Philosophical furniture question (long)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I doubt any of the inexpensive furniture will be considered as Antique in the future.

Certainly for better or worse our society has become a "throwaway" society. When I was a young lad in the 1940's a Bride and Groom starting our could not outfit a home with new quality furniture without going into deep debt. Almost all new families were gifted hand-me-downs from older family members to furnish their home. Small appliances during this era were expensive and were repaired instead of recycled. An Iron, Toaster, and fan together could cost more than a weeks wages. Today cost of repair usually exceeds new cost.

Remember most of the furniture of the 1800's and even much of the early 1900's was hand built by craftsmen and as we all know, it takes a lot of hours of labor to build a dining room table and chairs or a good dresser or Desk. Therefore the cost was quite high in hours of work for the person purchasing them. As these were normally built using quality hardwood lumber material cost was also a significant expense. A purchase of one piece of quality furniture often was a once in a lifetime occurrence.

These "Hand-me-downs" were normally of pretty darn good quality and had built in memories. The dining room set I was raised with (large round oak table and 6 chairs) was passed down from my Great Grandmother - and possibly even farther back. As the elders passed usually the furniture they had possessed passed down to the newer generations. These are the TRUE antiques.

Today, newlyweds can purchase a complete household of IKEA type furniture, mass produced from MDF, plastic ect. for a small portion of their months income. When it dies, it is replaced with like furniture at low cost.

Still many families continue to value and use Grandmother's Table, Bureau, Bed etc.. These hold memories of their youth and have a value far beyond the cash they are worth. I believe the furniture you contemplate building will fall into that category.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#4

Start cutting wood Barry! (long)

Dick Coers

My kids love the pieces I make for them. All are in featured spots in their homes. I was especially gratified when my son's girl friend included his childhood toys into their decor. She has his wooden play tools and tool box on the shelves by the fireplace, and his walnut and osage trebuchet on the mantle. Both kids have wood turnings all around the house. Our daughter still has her childhood dresser that I made in a hurry. Plywood drawers held together with "0" biscuits. It looks like the day I made it. They have lots of other pieces in many rooms.

I also have a friend that travels around the country showing art furniture at the ACC shows. He did really well in Baltimore this year, not as well in Atlanta. But these are folks buying $7000-$9000 tables. Check out Artful Home catalog.

There is plenty of fear in the country about the hammer falling in the economy and career broken from layoffs. The BS and duct tape that holds it together could let go at any time since we all have lived through a crash or two now. Also consider that most families have both working long hours to stay ahead, and nice furniture ranks below healthcare and food every time. When I had my custom woodworking shop, I can't remember how many homes I went into, that the family had over spent on the home and were furniture poor. I learned that some neighborhoods were not worth going into to bid.

Even if they only keep your furniture for 10 years, you think of them every minute you are working on it. That's my favorite feeling about building for family and friends. You remember events and good times (maybe a couple of bad teenage years things) all the time during the process. So get cutting!

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#5

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I hate to bring up Chris Schwarz again, I'm not a Schwarz fan-boy, but the opening paragraphs of his books "The Anarchist's Tool Chest" and "The Anarchist's Design Book" address your "Philosophical furniture question" pretty well I think.

He specifically talks about vernacular furniture compared to the really high end stuff us regular folk can't afford. I don't know, I find it interesting.

His thoughts and views right or wrong, I think, are pretty interesting and eye opening. I enjoy reading his stuff.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#6

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Jesse Cloud

My two cents worth would be to talk with them and learn what they like and don't like. Some may like the antique look, others more modern or some may enough want something plain enough to go with their IKEA.

If you can, personaliize the furniture, for example - a table that is just the right height for them or a chest of drawers with the drawers the size and height they like.

I think furniture works as legacy when it captures some of the personality of the maker or the owner. Its the memory of that person we want to keep, not necessarily the wood and screws...

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#7

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Gary Smyth

If they are in DC then likely they are in a high cost of living area. Two incomes are almost essential. Relatively inexpensive but functional furniture is stop gap while careers and life decisions take precedence of both of them as well as their peers. Give them time to develop their tastes. If they stay for any length of time and visit many places while in the area they will learn what is quality AND what they choose to emulate -- which may or may not be the same. Stuff goes in and out of style, (for example when was the last time good porcelain and silver was important to this generation?) and their experiences will guide them to their own preferences. Your post reminds me of the following story.

Frank Lloyd Wright was asked as an architect “What was his first prerequisite? Mr. Wright replied “Well, to fulfill the client’s wishes”. At which time H.C. Price (H.C. Price Company) of Oklahoma said “ I wanted a three story building”. Mr. Wright responded “You didn’t know what you wanted”.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#8

Alan Young

A Year ago I felt my Mortality creeping in

Alan Young

I had a second episode of amnesia- and thoughts of my future started turning sour. I drew up a piece for each of my siblings with the hope I'd be able to finish these before I had lost my abilities....Each piece was designed to reflect abilities, talents or dedicated interests -So far I have only finished the chess ensemble-


Fortunately, med's seem to have kept me from any further decline and I hope to finish up the other projects in the next year or so...My point is none of us should wait to make something for those we care about if it is in our power to do so--

My 2cents

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#9

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Mark Nowicki

Make something small, something that will be easy to move, or fit in a small suitcase.

You have no idea what the future holds for your family. From personal experience, there is nothing worse that having to throw away stuff that someone though was special.

Mark

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#10

depends on your family

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My daughters cherish the family heirlooms. I am sure others don't.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#11

Clint Searl

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Clint Searl

Decently made good design will always find a home.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#12

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Grant in Iowa

As I recall my youth, and think of my own children growing to adulthood, great heirloom quality furniture wasn't on the agenda of two out of three of us. My daughter did ask for a bed as a teenager, but she has always been one to plan ahead.

Now that my two children are grown, and make the transition from being renters to being homeowners, things are changing. I see them picking up nice quality upholstered furniture, and focus more on making a nest for themselves. When it comes to wooden items, they seem to prefer basic lines so far. Maybe it is the Ikea influence at work. They do prefer solid wood if given a choice, however.

I do believe there is a place for heirloom quality furniture. I think the key is to involve them in what they might like, and in what style and size. I have found that working with them as the "customer" allows us to grow closer, to communicate more, and they even are beginning to spend some time in the shop.

It can start out with helping them make hand made gifts for their friends, or items they want for their home, or just do some scroll sawing or the like for the joy of it.

The corollary is that maybe one in a couple hundred or fewer are lifelong woodworkers, so I see no reason that my kids need to embrace my hobby like I have. I consider myself fortunate that they are taking an interest at all.

So far the items I have made them early in life have been largely outgrown because of the style. More recently, now that they have input in to design, things are kept in a prominent place in their homes. These items have been mostly timeless designs, such as craftsman style or traditional. Some modern sleek lines have crept in on smaller pieces.

As my mother was slipping away, and we held an estate sale, I found myself bidding on her beloved Ethan Allen china hutch from the mid sixties. I never even really liked it growing up.

I do have plans to build until I cannot, and what they do with these items after I am gone is for the future to decide. I am at peace about the idea that much of what I build will not make the cut as generations pass. Doesn't stop me from trying, however :)

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#13

A wise thought

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I do believe there is a place for heirloom quality furniture. I think the key is to involve them in what they might like, and in what style and size. I have found that working with them as the "customer" allows us to grow closer, to communicate more, and they even are beginning to spend some time in the shop. " Sage advice indeed. I believe if you want your efforts to be preserved they need to be useful to their future owners.

I have a friend that builds for the challenge of building. I think many Period Furniture makers fall in this category. While this furniture fit into a merchant's mansion in 1750 some things don't even have any practical use in a modern home. Where does the computer go in a slant top desk, for example.

On the other hand, a place to put your socks will be with us for the foreseeable future. Antique shops are filled with chairs and chest of drawers because they sell, and they sell because they are still useful.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#14

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Some really good advice given throughout this thread. I agree with Clint regarding good design and made well. I would add that quality of materials also adds long term value.

As for me, if there weren't people who bought quality anymore, I'd be out of business! I make furniture that even I cannot afford. But my clients and the customers who buy my work in galleries are not shopping at Ashley or Furniture Row. So, in that case I am not in competition with that market. My clients want unique work with beautiful materials. I have no idea how long my clients keep my work, but I have a feeling they keep it for the long haul.

As for the Furniture Row and IKEA stuff, I wonder if at some point environmentalism will come more into play. The least "green" thing to do is to buy cheap crap and toss it out on the curb in 3 years. Perhaps keeping well made furniture and re-upholstering well made frames will some day catch on as an environmentally (and economic) thing to do. Hope so.

T.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#15

Re: depends on your family

Jim O'Connor

I started making chests of drawers for my now grown granddaughters when they were in HS. After the oldest married she asked me to make a similar chest of drawers for her new husband. the dining sets for the daughters in law will be passed along within the family I am sure. I always tried to find out what design they had in mind and if it was too strange give a few tried and true design hints. I did succumb to making an entertainment center to fit certain equipment that I had to work over later. Now the only limit I put on is not to make anything to fit specific electronic equipment. lastly I always date and brand each piece, even I'm surprised at times how long its been since something was made. At family gatherings we sometimes wind up turning furniture over to see when it was made.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#16

I embed a dated coin

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I used to use dollar coins but can't find recent dates so I use quarters.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#17

Re: Philosophical furniture question

John Foster

Just an experience. A couple of years ago my mother moved into a senior's apartment from a house. she was born in the Netherlands, and had a large oak wardrobe that her mother had received as a wedding gift. Admittedly it was large, had that early 20th century dark stained look and and was in that grey area between old and antique. It was still in very good condition, and a family heirloom. I contacted all my mother's siblings, nieces and nephews, and great nieces and nephews and could not find anyone interested. Eventually a cousin of mine who I love, but has addiction issues took it. At the time he was squatting in a home with no utilities, and now he is living in an old camper; I expect the wardrobe has been used for firewood by now.

On a personal level, I have been making cribs for our grandchildren as they arrive. Some of them are from wood that was grown on a farm that was owned by their great great grand parents, some are made from wood that was salvaged from century owned barns in the neighbourhood that their families had lived in for decades. Will this mean anything to them? Who knows.

Re: Philosophical furniture question

#18

Re: Philosophical furniture question

Brian Holcombe

I am probably biased as I have only ever dealt with high end furniture, but most of the people I met were either established or settled into a place they felt they would stay for a while.

I doubt anyone 'wants' temporary furniture, I think they just buy it as an easy solution.

I never bought termporary furniture myself, as I worried it would be perminant, so instead I made what I didn't have.