I'm watching Woodcraft's free band saw class. The demo saw is a Jet 14 in which, conveniently, is my model. He mentions that they now come with a blade tension release mechanism. My saw is over 15 years old and I'm wondering:
Relatively speaking, I've never detensioned blades and I've had no blade failures that I could attribute to constant tension, althought I'm sure it's possible. Maybe that's unusual, but I personally wouldn't retrofit a blade detensioner to an existing saw.
A decade+ ago I put a quick tensioner (with a big lever) on my 14" Delta with riser. One thing it is useful for: releasing the tension completely so changing the blade is quicker!
I don't know if that would be worth the cost of a new one. I bought this for almost nothing from a markdown table at WoodCraft. "That thing has been here forever and we couldn't sell it."
Years ago I put the Carter Version on my Delta 14" saw with riser. At first I used it. Then I stopped. I see no reason to detention on a regular basis. This has been discussed here over and over. I have a love/hate relationship with the bandsaw and have tuned it to death. Like John, the only thing I use it for is changing the blade. Great for that. There are home made versions for it as well if you want to make one and give it a try at a low budget.
I have never seen anyone loosen a blade in a commercial shop. I suppose if one had inferior tires on the wheels and the blade sat motionless for weeks or months the tires could flat spot, but I have not experienced the problem on my saws.
I've visited with some woodworkers that don't use their bandsaw for 6 months at a time. Then I would consider it. Personally, I've not released the tension on a bandsaw blade, without changing it, for 40+ years.
Thanks guys! This is feedback I was looking for. Seems like an unnecessary expense. I do have to say I'm surprised that there isn't one serious endorsement.
I forgot to mention that for a period, I did release the tension every day. That was when I was use blades that were far too big for that 14" Delta. I bought a Starrett tension gauge and found my tensioning was WAY less than recommended by the blade makers. When I cranked up the tension, it needed so much force for that larger blades I felt I was about to overstress the saw so I always released the tension when not using it.
(NOTE: the tensioning scale on every bandsaw I checked with the meter was woefully inaccurate.)
I then got an 18" Rikon which could handle the tension better and although it does have a quick detensioner built in, I rarely use it. (I do use this saw a lot, usually every few days.)
As an aside, I don't generally use the wider and thicker blades any more, even for processing big green wood. I discovered one day that a thin 1/2" 3tpi blade cut just as well or better than the bigger blades and required a WHOLE lot less tension. I had a dozen made up with 3 and 4tpi and those are what I use for almost everything on the 18" saw. The smaller one is reserved for smaller blades.
I used to detension all the time till a discussion here a few months ago told how to tension the blade and the results were such an improvement that I wont de-tension any more.