Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

The fleeting color of air dried walnut

Posts

The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#1

The fleeting color of air dried walnut

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



It is usually claimed by air dried lumber enthusiasts that air dried walnut has a more attractive hue than KD walnut. In fact, about all commercially available KD walnut has also been steamed to darken the sap wood. Hence, the color comparison is more likely between air dried walnut and the dark brown color of steamed walnut. Indeed, a fresh cut surface of air dried walnut will have a purple hue not found in the steamed walnut. However, this hue is fleeting when the wood is exposed to sunlight as illustrated in the following demonstration which can be repeated by anyone.

The walnut was from a log I sawed and air dried, so there is no question as to the history of the test piece. I put silver duct tape over a section of the fresh surface and set the piece behind a sunny window for a few hours. The tape was then peeled back (not very well as you can see) and a picture taken of the result. Under the tape one can see the characteristic purplish hue of the fresh surface of the air dried wood. Where the wood was exposed to the sun the hue has changed to a grey-brown with no hint of the purple hue remaining.

Had the sun tan continued the wood would have taken on a golden hue and eventually the color would have faded to a light yellow-brown after many months.

While it is recognized that the working properties of air dried vs steamed walnut are different, for better or worse depending on your perspective, color is no reason to prefer one source to the other if the finished product will be exposed to sunlight.

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#2

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

david weaver

bummer!! I guess we'll have to stain it the color we want it to be!!

For those of us preferring air dried wood for hand tools, though, we still have the different feel of air dried wood to hang our hat on.

At least in fruitwoods, the difference is stark.

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#3

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

Hank Knight

It's surprising how quickly UV does its dirty work! That's a pertty dramatic change in just a couple of hours. I've seen some once-beautiful walnut antique pieces that have bleached to an ugly, muddy yellow-brown over the years. Walnut fares badly in sunlight, for sure.

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#5

ebd

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

ebd

Sorry, I don't agree. I find steamed walnut to have a muddy fuzzy grain - color may be the same or similar, but the grain is no where near as crisp as air dried. The air dried (turned green and then dried) bowls I've made from fresh cut black walnut trees have exceptionally clear grain. Those from purchased (steamed & kiln dried) not so much.

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#6

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

John Veerkamp

May be the tree source rather than the processing?

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#7

There is a large difference among trees

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One of our suppliers was a furniture factory that worked walnut. The owner, Joe, said they preferred steamed material because it "worked better". I supposed that to mean machined better. This statement implies that there is a structure change from steaming. Personally, I don't detect a difference and use them interchangeably.

We sold a lot of walnut over the years and I planed most of it. There is a substantial difference among lumber from different trees and recently I experienced the extremes. I was looking for some crotch-wood and bought two forked logs that grew in the area but not on the same property. The lumber from one log is the softest I have ever seen in walnut and the wood is light in weight. It is not quite basswood in properties but close. It is a delight to carve. The other log yielded lumber hard as the hubs of hell. It is nearly as heavy and dense as ash. This lumber takes a polish because it is so dense.

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

#8

ebd

Re: The fleeting color of air dried walnut

ebd

Sorry - no. This has been a consistant observation over 40 years. I'm well aware of the variation in almost any wood from tree to tree and even board to board and location in the tree where the piece came from.

Steaming degrades the fine, sharp contrast in the figure. Maybe it doesn't matter so much if the wood doesn't have distinctive figure to begin with or if it's going into a large piece where the grain and figure isn't the focus.