Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Enough vacuum?

Posts

Enough vacuum?

#1

Enough vacuum?

Tom Dunlap

I have a DeWalt 780 SCMS that is a terror on wood! Makes sawdust like a banshee.

It's time to think about a collector for it. There is a small vac connection on the back. I'm going to try my shop vac to see if that's enough.

If not, I'm wondering if my old C'man shop vac is going to have enough ooomph to suck enough sawdust with a decent collector shroud. After looking at a few pictures of shrouds I see 3 and 4" tubing not the 2" from the shop vac. Seems like I might have answered my own question...but maybe someone has found out differently.

Thanks,

Tom

Re: Enough vacuum?

#2

Re: Enough vacuum?

Dick Coers

Your old C'man shop vac will sound like it is enough. Man those things are LOUD! It will be plenty of cfm, but getting a big enough tub around the back of the saw to trap it will be the trick.

Re: Enough vacuum?

#3

Re: Enough vacuum?

fredhargis

I wish you the best of luck with this. After trying about 4 different ways to catch the dust from my miter saw (with a large DC) I gave up. It's one of those tools that just seems to defy collecting the dust.

Re: Enough vacuum?

#4

Re: Enough vacuum?

John K Jordan

I've read about the difficulty collicting dust from compound miter saws. The most successful seem to be a wide collection box behind. The design I liked the best had an angled back deflucting the sawdust spray downward to a vacuum manifold of sorts connected to a 6" DC port.

For now, I keep mine in a corner of a back room, wear a dust mask, and let the sawdust pile up.

JKJ

Re: Enough vacuum?

#6

Re: How about one of these?

Tom Dunlap

Terry

Thanks for the link. Since I can see I e thought of a bag unit. It would store away necely too.

From what others are saying my thinking will shift from having a vacuum assist to making just a better dust pan

An idea just popped into my head for emptying. Use a draw string closure like on a stuff sack to drop the sawdust into a bucket

Today is rebuild the welding cart so woodwork will be on hold

Tom

Re: Enough vacuum?

#7

Re: How about one of these?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey


A bit more ambitious if you have the room . . .

Handles my Makita LS-1211 well. Very little escapes the hood.

Hood is 1/4" ply with 4 ports built in then fiberglassed. Attached to the cabinet that incorporates a funnel drop-box. Fold-up wings are nice in a small shop as you can drop them out of the way.

Re: Enough vacuum?

#8

Re: How about one of these?

Tom Dunlap

Mark

are you using a real dust collector on the hood or a shop vac?

My scms is mounted on a Ridgid fold up cart to save space in the shop

Tom

Re: Enough vacuum?

#9

Real DC

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

2(real) hp, 1500 cfm rated blower, 6" PVC ducts.

Mindful that the SCMS "station" is at the end of a 60' of ductwork with 4 90° bends.

Re: Enough vacuum?

#10

Enough Vacuum?  Nope.

Grant in Iowa

Tom,

The above posters are correct about a shop vac style collector not being adequate. Shop vacs use high static pressure, and a relatively lower volume of air to move material in to their collection bin. This means that once you open the collection funnel up to the size required by a tool like a miter saw, there isn't a lot of air moving, and any dust can fall out of suspension or just go anywhere other than the shop vac.

In contrast, a true Dust collector with a minimum of 4" duct can be effective with a well designed hood. A 6" duct and north of 1200 CFM with a Cyclone is better. I have a Dust Gorilla DC with 6" ducting and blast gates. It is only about 15 duct-feet from the saw, and I have decent results with a hood similar to that in Marks photo. I have toyed with different configurations and ultimately landed on the inlets being slots along the bottom rear of the hood. I will try to post pics once I get home.

I further improved collection by using movable sliding doors left and right of the saw. This allows me to reduce the size of the opening when the saw is at its usual 90 degrees, resulting in an increased concentration of air flow where it is needed. Adding a 90 degree PVC elbow to deflect chips downward from the saws factory outlet helps deflect the dust downward towards the hoods inlet ducts.

Let me be clear here. (semi-rant mode on, I apologize in advance) The chips that will fall in to a bag on their own are only a nuisance, but it is the fines that remain airborne which are a health hazard. Swipe a finger across a shelf in your shop and think about what must be in your lungs. If you are operating an active wood shop with no real dust collection, you may just end up regretting it as you get older. Investing in a quality dust collection system is key to a long life as a woodworker with the power tools of today.

What your solution ends up being is up to you, but the decision also affects your loved ones both directly and indirectly.

If you would like to learn more about shop dust collection, I recommend Bill Pentz web site for more than you will ever find elsewhere in one place. I have linked to the introduction page, which is the best place to start.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Enough vacuum?

#11

Re: Enough Vacuum?  Nope.

Tom Dunlap

Hi,

Thanks for taking the time to reply to my query.

From the get-go I realize that my shop vac is only going to, at best, collect the big chunks. I think of it as being an air broom not a dust collector.

My shop is in my two car garage. Most of the time I’m just making the odd chop and whack cuts. The doors are open so there’s lots of air movement.

I do pay attention to fines and dust. When I’m going to make multiple cuts I add my face mask with replaceable canisters.

I also realize the concern about fines and dust. My Dad died from complications of COPD. He turned for a long time and did’t pay close attention to dust. That sure didn’t help him.

Building a small cyclone system is the next big project. I’ve got a small blower motor that has enough oomph to cleanup one tool at a time. Since I have a hobby shop it will be sufficient.

The current project that I’m working on is cutting down one of my welding tables and adding pieces to another welding cabinet. Floor space is a premium and I really don’t need two welding tables. As much as I love working with wood the magic of melting metal and controlling a short circuit gives me such pleasure. As an arborist I take trees apart. Putting metal and wood back together keeps my creativity in balance.

Enjoy your week,

Tom Dunlap