I can understand both sides of this question but I don't know the right thing to do.
I have one of those old washboards that I dropped on the floor. The frame cracked and I had a friend put on a new frame. He made it out of maple because that is what he had at hand. For this kind of wood that will be in water, do I put a finish on it to decrease the amount of water that will soak into the wood - and then the wood will crack due to the finish not letting it expand? Or do I not finish it to let the water soak in - then worry about it splitting due to the water expanding the wood a lot? Help! And what do I do? Thank you.
They were probably made of a regionally available wood that was resistant to rot. For southerners, it was probably Cypress. For midwesterners, perhaps black locust or red cedar. Northeasterners, it was perhaps white pine. Westerners...cedar?
In any case, the wood will likely weather to a gray color over time and use. The big issue will be to see if the joints hold up if they are glued.
I haven't seen a real washboard in years, except maybe on the wall in a Cracker Barrel; but all of the ones I recall from my childhood had unfinished frames that were weathered gray. I have no idea what kind of wood they were.
I'd leave the wood unfinished and stand the board up to dry after getting it wet. A film finish (e.g., shellac, varnish, lacquer) will just fail eventually, and probably sooner than later. At the scale of a thin washboard frame, expansion won't be a serious issue. The wood will acquire a used appearance in time, which is pretty much the authentic look, IIRC. If you want to keep the maple clean and bright, you can put a coat of spar varnish on it, trying to get it down into the grooves as much as possible.
A bigger concern might be the construction of the frame. I'd check to see what kind of adhesive your friend used to join the corners of the frame. Standard PVA glue (white glue, yellow glue) probably won't stay stuck for very long. Epoxy or polyurethane glue (e.g., Gorilla) will not break down with repeated wetting.
Too late to help, but a suggestion for others *LINK*
Keith Newton
In situations as adverse as this project, a good preventive measure is to use CPES after the parts are cut, before assembly. This product really penetrates into the wood as fast as water will. It is slow to cure, so you can keep adding it as long as it keeps soaking in. Then when it does cure, makes the wood less absorbent, and greatly resistant to decay.
It ends up in the cell walls rather than on the surface, looking more like a the penetrating oil finishes. It also makes a good sealer for top-coats like poly.
It isn't cheap, but it does provide better protection than most of the standard finishes.
It was made to solidify decay in boats or architectural elements that would be very expensive to replace. But it also works great for prophylactic use.
Question: The described CPES properties (on the surface) sound a lot like System 3 RotFix, which we might find easier to source. Do you or anyone else have any comparisons between the two products? I have no experience, so I'm not recommending one over the other.
I have two. One glass and one (the mini) corrugated metal. Both are from the 1950's. The joints are loosely mortised then nailed with the exception of the top which has finger joints. The wood appears to be pine. No finish (For a long time) except for the brand stencil painted on. Been around for a long time. Used once every 3-4 weeks to clean cloth too dirty to put in the washer first. When taken from the laundry tub, just stood up and left to dry.
There are others, like Git-rot. I got the Smith brand from Jamestown Distributing, but then the next time I went to order, their search engine offered me their house brand, "Total Boat", which had a much better price. So I ordered some of it, but found it wasn't as thin, and didn't penetrate as deeply, or as fast. I went out and bought a gallon of acetone to thin it, but haven't had a project needing it since.
I did search online for an independent review, or test, but all I recall finding was each company doing comparisons, and of course theirs own was always the best.
Back on the topic of washboards. Down here in the South, they also do double duty as a percussive instrument in musical groups. Back in the seventies, one of my favorite local groups was Cornbread. Their cajun member was Washboard Leo. He wore thimbles on all fingers that had welded up thickened ends, and were tapped on with adhesive tape. He also had a cow bell, and a couple of blocks of wood mounted on there. He really got some great sounds out of setup.
I noticed the same thing - no useful points of comparison on any of this type of product. I already have West System resin and hardener and a gallon of acetone on hand, so it makes sense to try that before going through the hassle of another special purpose product.
I have a friend who plays a single string washtub bass in a local band. I'm always amazed at how good it sounds.
As far as thinning down regular epoxy. Of the two parts, the resin is often described as long chains of molecules, and the hardener as cross links that attach to them binding them to others.
I don't know if there is only one size that fits all, or if there are some down on a smaller level. I know that with regular epoxy, if you use it full strength, it will not soak very far into the end-grain. If adding a thinner just suspends them in the mix, but they get blocked or filtered out because they are still the same size, while allowing the thinner to soak well on up into the wood, this may not be as good as it seems.
The Smith brand that I used first is very thin, and will soak very deeply into the wood, but I have not done any test comparing them, to make sure just how far each of the two brands that I've used actually went in.
Thank you for your responses - you're great! My friend used a doweled butt joint and glue. I' going to leave it as is. When I was younger we used a washboard and a wringer Maytag for clothes. But what I use it for these day is as an extra scrub on those or items that need an extra scrubbing before putting in the wash machine. Don't forget the Fels Naphtha soap!