Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Water and Shellac

Posts

Water and Shellac

#1

Water and Shellac

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The question of water and shellac comes up from time to time. What follows is some information on this topic.

The "alcohol" solvent for shellac may be ethanol or a mix of ethanol and methanol. The way methanol is made leaves it water-free (anhydrous). Hence, it contributes no water to the mixed solvent or the dissolved shellac.

There are various routes to making ethanol. If at any step the ethanol is distilled from water, for example a fermentation, it will contain 5% water. It is a property of ethanol that it vaporizes from a water solution as a 95/5 mix of ethanol and water. In technical terms it forms an azeotrope with water. Other routes to ethanol make anhydrous ethanol.

Because ethanol evaporates as a water/ethanol azeotrope the 5% or less water in the formulated shellac will evaporate with the ethanol and not stay behind on the wood.

As a result of the possible sources of alcohol shellac solvent the result can be an alcohol solvent that contains more or less methanol and at most 5% water. For example the Jasco alcohol in my shop is a mix of 40% methanol and 60% ethanol (by analysis). One would expect it to have at most 60% times 5% water = 3% water.

Anhydrous alcohols will absorb some water from the air but under normal handling this source does not contribute greatly to the resulting water content. For example, my several year old half full can of Jasco alcohol contains 3.6% water by analysis. Presumably the "extra" 0.6% got there through exposure to the air.

A more significant source of water in shellac results from condensation. Ethanol evaporates rapidly and methanol even more so. Evaporative cooling of the coated wood will condense water more or less from humid air. At worse, spraying shellac under humid conditions can leave a layer of water on the wood as though it had been sprayed with water and not shellac! But even under less humid conditions more or less water is going to condense on the coated surface as the solvent evaporates.

Re: Water and Shellac

#2

Re: Water and Shellac

Gary Smyth

I'm not sure I understand fully.

If alcohol only partly fills a can, is there the possibility of moist air enclosed within that can then increases the amount of water percentage when the alcohol is removed?

Also, if the alcohol has 5% water moisture to begin with, if he other components then evaporate, does it then increase the percentage of water (which does not evaporate) in the remaining alcohol? For example if a can has 10 oz. of alcohol and half evaporates to 5 oz. Is the original 5% water increased also by 1/2? If so then 1/2 cans of alcohol ought to be kept sealed or combined to reduce evaporation.

Re: Water and Shellac

#3

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Let us just consider alcohol that does not contain methanol for now......

"If alcohol only partly fills a can, is there the possibility of moist air enclosed within that can then increase the amount of water percentage when the alcohol is removed?" True. But there is but a piddly amount of water in that head space even at 70% relative humidity. And only a small fraction of what water there is will want to be in the alcohol and not in the air. Additionally, what is in the space above the liquid alcohol is largely alcohol vapor , and not all soggy air.

If alcohol with 5% water evaporates, what evaporates contains 5% water and what is left remains 5% water as a result of the property of the water/ethanol azeotrope.

Also, if the alcohol has 5% water moisture to begin with, if the other components then evaporate....what other components?

"For example if a can has 10 oz. of alcohol and half evaporates to 5 oz. Is the original 5% water increased also by 1/2? " Not if the can contains ethanol with 5% water.

If the can contains 40% methanol and 55 % ethanol and 5% water and half the can evaporates the situation is complicated. The result will be a solvent with more than 55% ethanol and something more than 5% water but not 10% water.

Re: Water and Shellac

#4

Sorry, Bill

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Didn't mean to push you into research over the water issue.

I have no way to analyze how much water is dissolved in the DNA I buy. But with it raising wood grain as much as it did, I couldn't believe it was a minimal amount finding it's way into the shellac mix.

The tapioca routine eliminated the problem, regardless of the presence or absence of high humidity air. I do however, add a drop or two of pure turps to prevent blushing in the summer, and am not dumb enough to be spraying in the open garage when it's raining outside.

peace

Re: Water and Shellac

#5

Re: Sorry, Bill

TomD

What is the tapioca routine, Mark?

Re: Water and Shellac

#6

Tapioca

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/messages.pl/page/1/md/read/id/497298/sbj/remedy/

Above thread on 3/13 about water borne finish and veneer lifting when water borne finish applied. In that thread is a link to Purdue Univ. research on drying ethanol after Bill questioned the amount of water that could be present. Since alcohol should not raise wood grain (the whole basis for NGR stains) but I was getting puckering of the wood surfaces when applying a first coat of shellac, the answer had to be water in more than a minimal amount in the alcohol used to mix the shellac. Poked around looking for a way to get the water out of the DNA in a method that I could do and found the report, bought and used some tapioca in my mixing DNA. Bingo! No more raised grain having to be sanded/scraped flat again.

The little pearls get spread out to dry in the sun and then returned to their zip-lock to be used again.

Re: Water and Shellac

#7

Re: Tapioca

TomD

Awesome!