Mineral Staining
don stephan
In lumber I hate mineral stains, but in turned bowls it can be an amazing collection of swirls and tones.
Is there today a consensus on the cause of mineral stains?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Mineral Staining
don stephan
In lumber I hate mineral stains, but in turned bowls it can be an amazing collection of swirls and tones.
Is there today a consensus on the cause of mineral stains?
Re: Mineral Staining
Howard Acheson
Have you googled "mineral stains in wood, causes? Should answer your questions.
Re: Mineral Staining
don stephan
I did before I posted my question. All I found was a 2010 brief description of ongoing study of red oak mineral stain. It said possible causes of mineral stain ran from disease to overly wet soil to dissolved minerals in ground water. There are several forestry agents who participate in this forum, and I'm wondering if there has been recent developments in understanding of mineral stains in trees.
You want a simple answer,
Keith Newton
If I had to venture a guess, I would say Oxygen. In most trees, even the smallest injury which exposes the cambium to the atmosphere causes a dark streak up and down the grain from the injury. Of course, other things like a nail will cause a big blue area, usually out around it in all directions, but further up and down the grain.
Example for oxygen. Yellow-bellied Sapsuckers are only here in AR through the Winter months, and are the only species of woodpeckers that peck on live wood. Their little wells are into the cambium, which produces a little drop of sap to the atmosphere. In all the trees that I've inspected, there will always be at least a dark spot in the wood, and in most, there will be a streak up and down the grain.
In Eastern Red Cedar, Juniperus virginiana, the results is even more pronounced. After they leave, and quit working the holes, sometimes there will be enough sap to run out for a while before it gets sticky, then turns into a solid plug. This little solid patch will not only cause a dark streak in this newest live tissue just under the bark around the hole, but it seals out the oxygen from the sapwood behind it, preventing that sapwood from ever becoming red heartwood.
I had been aware of this for a long time, and wondering about the process of sapwood becoming heartwood. Does sapwood become heartwood one ring at a time gradually like annual rings, where say in Oak, the open porous ring grows in the Spring, followed by the more dense late-wood. Or does it make a change, say during the inactive Winter months. I've turned some woods, like Red Mulberry during the early Spring, before budding, where the outer layer of heartwood would be pail yellow. Ah ha, I thought, this will be interesting to share with clients interested in buying a turning. However, by the time the pieces were dried out, whatever minerals were out in the sapwood always made it over into that pale area as it dried out, and I could no longer distinguish any difference.
Back to the ER Cedar. About 15 years ago, someone at UCA had the bright idea to have a ceremonial mace turned out of an old tree which had stood by the entrance of one of the great halls on campus that had to come down. A limb about 4" in diameter was saved for me. The upper half had been killed, probably by hail or something, leaving the underside in good shape to continue transporting moisture out to the limbs.
Sometimes I wonder about the fate, wondering why this portion of tree came to me. Late one night I was about to throw the last piece of that wood in the fire, but when I picked it up, I realized it had brought me a clue to the sapwood into heartwood conundrum. After making a fresh cut, and fine sanding, under magnification, I could see along the edge where the new wood was forming under the bark where it curled around, the sapwood layer got thinner, until right at the edge, there was no sapwood layer at all. The air coming around the edge, through the old dead heartwood allowed the air to expose the minerals in the sap turning it dark as the new cells formed.
Don, I read that PDF also, and wondered after reading the site or soil part providing, or not the minerals causing the streaks. I had to wonder why they didn't mention the roll that the leaves of each species plays in producing the chemical mixture sent down the phloem for new cell growth. You could have a Cypress or Cedar growing alongside a Poplar or Sweetgum in the same soil, yet the mineral in the cells of each would have a major difference in chemical content. Are the Cedar and Cypress just better at extracting the minerals from the soil, or does it happen up there in those wonderful little chemical factories called leaves. What do they do besides using Sunlight through photosynthesis to strip the carbon from air giving off Oxygen. I'm sure the sap in each sent back down the phloem to nourish new cell growth, and then send the other extractives into the heartwood is totally different in each species.
This chemistry is way beyond my pay-grade to understand, but I'm trying to learn. So as far as I know, the minerals may just be concentrated Sunlight. But of course, besides my woodpecker example, any injury knocking some bark off, like a falling neighboring tree, or lightning can expose the wood under the bark, but maybe not the only.
Oh, Yeah
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
"Simple" 
Note to self, Ellis may not have the band width for "complex" answers.

Hey,,,, That is the short answer,,
Keith Newton
I thought I would elaborate more during the question and answer session. But since there haven't been any questions, I guess I pretty well covered it, or there isn't much curiosity on this subject.
Re: Hey,,,, That is the short answer,,
Larry Barrett
Hi Keith - I am curious so if you have more please continue. My simple understanding of how a tree grows is that new cells form in the cambrium layer, or at the juncture between the cambrium and the sapwood. Half (roughly) of the new cells head in one direction to become bark, the other half head in the other direction to become the new growth ring. Your answer, in part, addresses how sap wood becomes heart wood. Does this happen at the same time as the new growth ring is forming, or is it a somewhat continuous process. It is also interesting that some types of trees have only a few years of sapwood (for instance,a black oak I recently had to take down had 7 growth rings (years) of sapwood) while other types of trees, hickory for instance, might have many growth rings in the sapwood, and relatively little heart wood. I would like to understand more about how this works.