Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

Posts

Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#1

Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

Ken Krawford

I'm using General Finish's High Performance Polyurethane on a table top.

A bit of background first, if I may.

I applied teak veneer to my table top using Titebond glue. I painted a liberal coat on the veneer and the table top and let it dry. I then placed the veneer on the table and ironed it on. Everything looked great - tight adhesion and no bubbles. About a week later I started spraying the General finish on. I noticed several areas where the veneer was detaching from the substrate. I was able to iron the veneer back down but my next coat produced more bubbles. I assume the water and/or solvents in the finish are what's causing the veneer to fail.

Could I possibly avoid this by letting the finish cure before applying any more coats? Right now I'm applying new coats every 24 hrs. Would the cured finish form a barrier and prevent the water from coming in contact with the glue?

I'm also considering a coat of shellac before applying more poly.

Any other suggestions would be welcome.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#2

Remedy

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is two coats of fresh mixed dewaxed shellac applied as 3/4 lb "cut, preferably by spray. Stress on light coats and freshly mixed.

Recommend you start your waterborne finishes with shellac to prevent puckering of the wood fibers that will interfere with the visual "depth" of the resulting film. I also make it a point to dry out my DNA before mixing. Most DNA you can buy will, even from fresh cans, have up to 15% water content in solution. You can remove 95+% of it using tapioca (the pudding stuff).

1. Pour a qt. of alcohol into larger jar and add 1 cup of dry tapioca.

2. Lid securely and shake.

3. Shake about once an hour for 6 hours.

4. Pour through a fine sieve into a clean jar to remove the tapioca which will have pulled the water out of the alcohol like little sponges.

5. Spread the wet tapioca out to dry (can be used many times).

Stay away from old shellac and waxy types as you'll have problems with adhesion of the top coats and cold checking under the final finish.

I use fresh Ultra Pale shellac as a sanding sealer mixed 1-1/2oz dry flakes to a pint of alcohol. Apply, sand, vac off, apply second coat. Let dry at least 4 hours, then apply the top coating.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#3

Re: Remedy

Ken Krawford

Thanks for the info. Mark. Are you suggesting that I need to sand all the WB Poly off that I've already applied or could I lay a couple of coats of shellac on top of the poly.?

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#4

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

Dick Coers

I'm not a fan of your veneer application. For a table top, I've been taught that a rigid adhesive and clamping is required. How thick is he veneer? Paper backed? I've always dusted on he first coats of finish on veneer if I'm worried about delamination. I'd suggest you veneer up a small sample to test your theory. The adhesion might be better on a small sample, but you might confirm the issue.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#5

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

Ken Krawford

I did a small test sample before starting and the adhesion was perfect. The table is ~ 3x4' and the veneer was a solid piece with what looks like a luan-like backing. I considered cauls and clamps but the iron on technique was suggested and my test sample looked so go.

My concern is that, if possible, I'd like to work with what I've got. I don't have enough left over veneer to re-do the project.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#6

I question your water numbers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It makes no sense to me that alcohol bought for use as a solvent would contain more than 5% water, and probably less. What was the source of the 15% amount?

Ethanol distilled from a fermentation source will contain 5% water because that is the mixture that volatilizes. Ethanol from a petroleum source will contain no water. The methanol that is mixed with the ethanol will contain no water unless it is purposely added.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#7

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

Dick Coers

So the solvent had to have soaked through the veneer and a wood backer. Apply some finish on a piece of scrap like you did the table, and see if it makes it through. That seems pretty tough to me. What is the substrate or main table surface made from? I'm still thinking wood movement may have had something to do with this. Did you veneer the bottom surface too? I'm asking because getting the veneer to lay down now may just be a temporary fix, and you might see "bubbles" every time the weather changes. 25+ years ago I used contact cement on a wood backed veneer. Shut down the shop over the weekend, and came back to delamination after a huge heat and humidity swing. Never used contact cement again. I know you didn't use the cement, but veneer and particle board can move, and at different rates.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#8

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

don stephan

This question also was posted on the Homestead Finishing Products forum.

Until finish is applied in a similar fashion to the test piece, and a resulting bubble sliced open and studied, the cause is not known.

There could be poor adhesion between the two layers of veneer, or between the two ply and the substrate, which has also not been clarified. Water in finish of course causes wood to expand temporarily. If there is an area of poor adhesion below, and the surface veneer wants to expand, a bubble results.

A moisture barrier, like dewaxed shellac, will reduce the amount of water in the finish from reaching the two ply but won't fix the underlying problem if there is poor adhesion.

If spraying finish on the test panel is not attractive, moisten the glued two ply with a wet sponge for several minutes to simulate the effect of a sprayed wet coat of water borne finish, and see if a bubble appears. If it does, slice it open and lift to start analyzing the adhesion issue.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#10

No guaranty

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Part of the issue may be a weak/broken bond of the veneer to the substrate that gets exacerbated by the water in the finish. Teak is somewhat difficult to glue due to its oil content like many tropical woods. If your veneer has already come loose from the glue layer, 50 coats of finish are not likely to help it stick. Sanding off the finish (or most of it] and then removal and redoing the loose veneer may be your only option.

Did you wipe the glue surface with solvent before applying glue? Removing the surface oil might have helped. I've use thed iron-on method with domestic veneers but not teak or other tropicals.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#11

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Once the gallon's been sitting in your shop partially used, the problem gets worse as ethanol will suck water vapor out of the air whenever the can is opened.

Like most all distillates, there are different grades of ethanol (and thus DNA), and the stuff we buy at the paint store ain't the top-of-the-line.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#12

Re: Talk to the Professor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The reference does not support your claim for water content over 5% in store bought alcohol. In fact quite the opposite for the information is about drying the alcohol flashed from fermentation, prior to sale. Presumably the dried product is less than the water concentrations quoted in the report because it has been dried for sale.

That said, if drying works for you it is ok to suggest it. Personally I have never had the need to employ additional drying of the alcohols I have used (what ever Lowes sells). But don't alarm potential users of water concentrations they will never see in store bought alcohol.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#13

It establishes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the presence of water in the non-fuel grade stuff we buy at Lowes etc. From backpacking I can tell you that fuel for alcohol stoves is more expensive, and my old stoves maker cautioned against using "plain old" paint-store DNA.

Ethanol is hydroscopic as well, and it's water content in the can will increase over time. The age and how good the seals on the cans on the paint store will determine how much water vapor has found its way into the mix and I don't have blind faith in the quality of what some company puts in its cans. I prefer to make sure my DNA is as dry as possible before I use it.

I seem to remember a thread here about SealCoat shellac cans rusting through and leaking. Ethanol doesn't rust steel.

As I said, your mileage etc.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#14

Re: It establishes

William Duffield

The Seal-Coat problem has just happened to me, for a second time. This time it ran all over the bottom of my emergency finish repair go box which just happens to be a #4 Tanos Systainer. I thought Zinsser had fixed that problem. By now, I should have known better. :( It the future, I'm going to decant my shellac, DNA and drying oils into recycled polyethhylene tetrapthalate soda bottles.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#15

Re: Da Can Ting

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'd look for something a bit heavier than soda bottles as they may not stop O2 uptake. Probably should also check the MSDS on your oil finishes to make sure the solvents present won't attack the bottle. I know that PE is supposed to be "inert", but I'd be wary of those thin bottles.

We might see a change when Zinnser runs out of steel cans :D

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#16

Looking at some MSDS's

John in NM

I would be fairly certain that the admonition to not use "plain old hardware store" DNA in a camp stove is just so much salesmanship to go along with the price of the camp store approved stuff.

The manufacturers I looked at (Klean Strip and Sunnyside) both indicate that the alcohol percentages are in excess of 95% (though methanol may be blended in). Given the relatively low cost of these products, it makes little sense for a manufacturer to limit their market share by saving pennies on their costs.

Granted, manufacturers do not always do what makes sense, but given the info I find on their MSDS's I think it's a bit unfair to assume that their product is of a low grade.

Unless what you get at the camping store is sold as "anhydrous" it is quite likely the same stuff you buy at the local True Value Hardware, just in a smaller and more expensive can.

Given that the tapioca fixed your shellac problem (and what a neat idea that is!), I would bet that most of that water came from the air at some point or another, or perhaps that you used Everclear (often 75% ethanol) instead of DNA.

What I really want to know about the tapioca process is how the pudding tastes after dehydrating alcohol? Bourbon tapioca anyone? :D

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#17

Re: "Plain Old . . ."

Mark Mandell

That admonition may be "dated" as I put away the camp stove 30 years ago and ethanol as a fuel has mushroomed since then. Interesting that I pulled up modern alcohol stove fuel and the MSDS on one brand showed 20% methanol; 4 times what I use to mix my shellac. Don't think I'd be happy cooking with that in a cold tent on a windy day on the trail.

I rather doubt that marketers would be disclosing the water content of their DNA; certainly wouldn't put it in the MSDS.

Had the grain-raise issue for years, even with fresh-mixed shellac from a new can of DNA, couldn't figure why. While it may be anecdotal data (don't have a lab to test) the results of my little drying operation are strong evidence of the presence of water. The tapioca takes a while to dry out and shrink back to its normal size. That wouldn't happen if it were soaking up alcohol.

Pudding? Think I'd prefer rum flavor.

Re: Water Based Finish Lifting Veneer

#18

Re: "Plain Old . . ."

John in NM

Water content isn't disclosed in an MSDS, but it can be inferred from them - the wt percent of the various chemicals add up to 96%, and you can be pretty sure that the rest is water.

One could soak raisins in the rum with the tapioca - they'd probably soak up the alcohol more than the water, and provide a nice contrast in the pudding. Call it the shellac surprise :D