Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Primecell VS MTO Battery

Posts

Primecell VS MTO Battery

#1

Primecell VS MTO Battery

Til Glisson

I recently sent two Festool NiCd battery packs to Primecell for rebuilding. The charge was $33 each plus $10 for return shipping. UPS charged me $14 to ship the batteries. When I received the rebuilds, one charged and worked fine. The other would not charge, and the LED on the charger indicated a bad battery. I contacted Primecell via email and they refunded the $33 cost of the batteries for the one pack, but not the shipping. I wrote again, asking about getting the problem fixed, and received this surprisingly unfriendly reply:

"There is clearly a problem here that relates to the interface between the charger and the battery. This is not what you paid for - and not what we offered service for. and was unknown to both of us. At present you have a new set of cells at no cost to you. you now need to have your other problem - charger to battery interface - determined and serviced. At present it has cost you nothing. We don't offer more service at no cost and don't pay for return shipping - so I guess if it arrived here as a new order, including the charger and return shipping cost we would look at it. Cost would be less if sent along with another order as well - but as it stands - we can't service it without it being here - so we have taken our loss and have no desire to accept more loss.

We don't know what the cost of repairs will be without seeing both the battery and charger in question. we fix - you pay or if you don't pay - we don't fix."

Well, it was clearly NOT "a problem here that relates to the interface between the charger and the battery," because one of the two packs worked fine. I gave up on Primecell and sent the faulty pack and the charger, along with some other batteries to be rebuilt, to MTO Battery and received this wonderful reply:

"We just received your batteries. We opened the Festool battery and found that there was a connection that was never welded when it was previously rebuilt (photo attached). We will weld it together at no charge for you as a customer service."

So Primcell essentially refused to consider the possibility (now a fact) that they had not done the rebuild properly, was downright snotty in their communications, did not refund the shipping on the one pack, and wanted me to pay additional shipping and fees for repairing their error.

And by the way, Primecell would not rebuild with NiMH batteries, but MTO did.

Please tell me why anyone would choose Primecell over MTO.

For those interested in Primecell vs MTO Battery, you can read my entire email correspondence with Primecell here:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/os1k0ag9ncf6g5f/one.pdf?dl=0

Note: The emails are in reverse chronological order.

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

#2

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

Barry Irby

I am surprised they did not test the units before they left the shop. I suppose they wire could have moved in shipping, but if it was never soldered MTO would be able to tell. The shipping is the killer on this. Costs close to as much to ship a pack back and forth as it does to rebuild it. Batteries Plus has packs that are fairly reasonable.

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

#3

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

Til Glisson

Batteries Plus prices are competitive for off-the-shelf (prebuilt) replacements, which they offer for several popular brands of cordless tools. But they don't have such replacements for many of my tools (Bosch and Festool). I just called to check their price for rebuilding a NiCd pack. I was quoted $15 for labor plus $7 per cell. There are 15 cells in an 18V pack, so the total would be about $120 plus 7% sales tax. I went to the MTO website and found that the total cost for rebuilding an 18V NiCd, including shipping both ways, is $53.63, and no sales tax.

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

#4

FWIW: Gulf Coast did a fine job

Tom Dunlap

The last time I bought batteries for my 18v DW I bought from Gulf Coast. They were outstanding.

Tom

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

#5

MTO Battery has good service

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I had MTO rebuild my two Dewalt 14V batteries and they have been very good. I contacted them and was able to arrange to stop by during business hours and they did the rebuild while I waited. They had the welded batteries ready to go when I arrived. Saved shipping both directions and we were essentially driving by any way.

Lee

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

#6

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

Jay Lombardo

I have also sent several of my own and a couple of my neighbors batteries to MTO and have always been very satisfied with their work and their customer service. Good people.

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

#7

Re: Primecell VS MTO Battery

Walt

Another thumbs up for MTO battery. The cells appear to be much higher quality than Porter Cable OEM batteries.