Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

design question

Posts

design question

#1

design question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.




I am making two bedside pieces. The client (daughter) wants two drawers and a 10" tall shelf beneath for books. She wants a "post and panel" construction as illustrated in the picture. I have drawn up something, Picture 2. I have not done a post and panel piece. Concerned about post size. I have drawn the posts at 1 1/8" and drawer dividers at 3/4". I saw these sizes used in a "Danish" design. I am looking for opinions on post and divider sizes........?

Re: design question

#2

Re: design question

Keith Newton

Looks fine, although I'd personally like for it to be a little shorter. I'd take about 1.25" out of that top drawer, and maybe add a little more height at the ends of the bottom rail ends for the joint.

Re: design question

#3

Re: design question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Not bad. But if it were me, I'd make the top a little thinner. I'd also give the skirt an arching bottom edge.

As for the fingers in the photo....just a tad creepy. ;-)

T.

Re: design question

#4

I like the posts, but

Dick Coers

the stretchers between the drawers seem heavy. I'd go thinner to match the thinner posts, maybe even hide them behind the drawer fronts. I agree with a narrower top drawer.

Re: design question

#5

Re: design question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Consider

1 top drawer thinner (so items don't get buried)

2 Book rack in the middle (more accessible from bed height)

3 Storage drawer on the bottom

Re: design question

#6

Depends on height of the bed

Grant in Iowa

Today's beds can vary greatly in height. I'd make sure it is designed with the existing bed height in mind.

Is it pictured with the same bed it will be placed by?

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: design question

#7

Another reason to consider this...

John E in SC

As drawn, that design will be pretty top heavy. Unless you have some really heavy books at the bottom, it may want to tip over if the top drawer is opened.

Re: design question

#8

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I'd take about 1.25" out of that top drawer"

That would leave a drawer opening of 3.75" and a drawer depth of about 3". That depth strikes me as too shallow for a bed side drawer. Bu then I put my socks in the drawer beside the bed. What do others do?

Re: design question

#9

response

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"But if it were me, I'd make the top a little thinner. " That is what I was thinking too and at least ease the edge. I usually refine top design when the rest is built.

" I'd also give the skirt an arching bottom edge." I was thinking that too....but....I need to clear that with my artist friend. She goes nuts when design elements don't go together. With nothing else arced I suspect she would not be happy with an arc there.

As for the fingers in the photo....just a tad creepy...Zombie design element. It's the latest.

BTW...The Gallery lady in Asheville said she has a nibble on your bed side piece.

Re: design question

#10

Re:  answer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey



Consider the height of the books (paperbacks vs bound editions) in context of total height of the piece which should be at or slightly above the level of the mattress/pillow

Attribution: Photo of new Stickley Edinburgh Collection nightstand

Re: design question

#11

Re:  question

Keith Newton

Bill!!! You wear socks, who knew? Being from E TN, I just assumed,,,,,,,,,,,,, ha

Well, since you know who is going to be getting it, you should ask how they plan to use that drawer. If it is just little odds and ends, i'd rather have a more shallow drawer where things don't get buried too deep. But if they are planning to use it for socks or undies, deeper would probably be better.

Actually 3" isn't too bad for a top drawer. My kitchen island is 40.5" tall. I put a drawer over the dishwasher, which ended up becoming silverware drawer, and it is just fine for that purpose.

And as Grant pointed out, the height of the bed comes into play. If they have those really thick springs and mattress, the height you have it drawn might be fine. I just thought it seemed a little high for the bed in the pic. Since it is custom, you should send them your drawing, or at least dimensions and let the recipient decide.

Re: design question

#12

Ellis Walentine

Some thoughts

Ellis Walentine

Bill, unless you're trying to match the dresser shown, I'd suggest a slightly modified/refined design.


Relevant thoughts:

- Bedside table drawers are usually for small stuff, so you don't need deep drawers. I'd go 3 1/2" or 4" max.

- 1 1/8" is too skinny for legs, IMO.

- Lighten the visual weight of the top by beveling it under or otherwise molding the edge.

- Skip the divider between the drawers.

- Scale the height off the mattress height. I have found that an inch or two above mattress height allows the person to see the alarm clock, water glass, whatever, easily.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: design question

#13

considering

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Consider

1 top drawer thinner ...see response above. Will ask client what she intends to put in it. I agree it would look better but maybe be uselessly shallow if intended for socks.

2 Book rack in the middle (more accessible from bed height) I need to draw that up. Makes practical sense. Don't know how it would look.

Re: design question

#14

agree on all counts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Drawing was sent. Suggested they cut shape out of cardboard or poster board and stick it beside bed to gauge height and width. But, height and width are probably ok as that was what she sketched for me. Somehow it looks bigger in the picture of drawing than in reality.

I have a 5" top drawer next to our bed and it is good for me.

Re: design question

#15

Re: response

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Hope it sells....I need a new bench grinder! ;-)

Re: design question

#16

Re: design question

Barry Irby

I am late to this and have no design sense, but that's never stopped me. My thought is the book bay is too deep front to rear. the books will get lost in there and you will need to get down on the floor to fetch them out. Maybe the middle bay as suggested or some sort of roll out to make it easy to get to them. Might even have room for two rows of paper backs.

Or you could just make a little slot for one of those fancy little notebook electronic readers.

And I agree with Thomas about the creepy fingers.

Re: design question

#17

Who Knew

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

that "Thing" would get a gig in woodworking after the series closed.

Re: design question

#18

Adam of Oakland

^^^^ i second ellis' drwng

Adam of Oakland

by the way, Ellis, nice sketch! you even have your dims in perspective...i hope some day to be able to draw like a boss...

i agree on not having the divider and having the drawers (at least the top one) shallower. best thing i'd ask the client is: 'what is the biggest thing you plan on putting in there?'.