I use the scary sharp system of gluing sandpaper to glass. Since I'm a wood turner this doesn't get used a lot. Every now and then I do flat wood project and need to touch up my hand planes or chisels. I use 3M super 77 spray and it's always hard to get the sandpaper off when I need to replace it. Anyone have a better idea. Right now I use 4"x 10" pieces of glass as my substrate and cut the sandpaper to fit.
A second question. I sharpen to 1500 grit and then go to the strop. Is that where you guys stop. My chisels seem quite sharp and will shave hair easily. I did find some 2000 grit paper and wonder if I should go that extra step. It would require finding some more glass.
If you want the ultimate sharp edge (I'm thinking carving tools) what method would you use.
I also use the 3M 77 and I use acetone to remove when I'm ready to change sheets. I use a putty knife (or a gasket scraper) to get an edge up and then apply small amounts of the acetone. After the paper is off I use the acetone to clean the surface.
I'll have to try that. I can't remember if I tried it on the 77 before or not. I have tried mineral spirits on some adhesives and wound up with a mess that was a real pain to remove.
When someone mentions stroping I visualize the older barbers stroping their razor on a long leather strop hanging off the barber chair. I guess you are talking about using a cotton, felt or leather wheel on a fast/slow grinder, right?
I talked to my barber about it. They use a stiff leather belt and then they don't drag the edge the way you think they wood. The start with the edge on the leather and then rotate the blade so the edge comes off the leather. He said if you do it with the edge in contact the whole way it rounds over the edge and leaves it less sharp. It wood working I tend to use powered strops such as the Tormek or a piece of MDF charged with abrasive. Then I hold the tool in one position which is less likely to round the edge.
Yea some adhesives gum up more than others. I was able to clean my class completely using the mineral spirits and then wiping it down with a clean paper towel. You do have to let it dry good before spraying with more adhesive. Acetone or Naptha would probably be better but I use the low odor mineral spirits which is much more pleasant.
I like to use mdf. you can mount a piece to run outboard on a faceplate, so you can step around behind to allow working at a good level on top, with the rotation away from you.
I like to shape it, so that if it were cut in half, the edge would look like a rifle bullet, ending in about 3/16" half round. This allows me to strop the inside almost all my gouges, except Vs. Then on the bevel side, I always sit on the heel first then rock onto the flat, then up a few more for the edge. Just a light touch once you develop a feel, only takes a few minutes to go through a hand full of tools.
MDF has about the right porosity for the white compound, and it is easy to re-dress, once the glaze gets out of whack. Leather may be fine for some things, but too soft a substrate leads to rounding over, rather than having a fine bevel all the way to the edge.
I have always used lacquer thinner to remove contact cement. Turn the piece up on the edge and poor a small amount under the edge of the sheet and let it work. Slowly roll the paper back. Practice and use "just the right amount".
I used the same adhesive on mine but have not pulled the paper yet. After I made I I read you could stick the paper to the glass with water. Obviously woudl have to use waterproof paper. Have not tried it. Seems like it woudl work and be easy to remove.
I have not tried stropping. Obviously you like it. I need more info.
get thee to an art store and buy an adhesive for mounting stuff. 3M "Spray Mount" is one brand.
I use glass differently. My glass is 12" x 12", 1/2" thick I mount 2 3/4" strips of adhesive backed paper from Klingspor on the glass- Plate 1 80, 100, 120, 180 on one side and 220, 360, 400, 600 on the other
On a second plate I have 1000, 1500, and 2000
By using small steps between grit sizes it only takes a few strokes per grit to move through the progression. I rarely need to start at 80 but it is there when needed for fast material removal.
I don't carve but the carvers I know all strop with something on leather.
Barry I re read Leaonard Lee's book on sharpening (well actually I'm still reading). The chapter where he covers stropping is really interesting. I think it's the way to go after playing with it for several years but i'm still learning more. I think for carving tools or tools that you incredibly sharp you should use a stiff wheel or hard leather to strop. It keeps the edge closer to the angle you sharpened it. Using softer wheels rounds the edge. It does improve the edge but from what I'm reading it may not be as sharp as it could be. I'll let you know later on. I'm finishing up an article for American Woodturner this morning and won't have time to go back to the sharpening project until tomorrow or Wednesday. I'm going to make an MDF wheel.
I was discussing stropping with a chip carving friend. We both have the yellow bar that came with the wooden carving strop tool and we both have the Green stick from Lee Valley. We are going to attempt to see if there is any difference.
Try sticking wet/dry silicon carbide paper to your substrate with water. Surface tension should hold it in place. Since you can easily peel it off and stick it back down, you should need a lot less area of glass.
The term that is usually used for the effect of honing with a compound on leather is "dubbing" It does not make the edge any duller than a harder substrate; it just increases the bevel angle. A harder substrate decreases the effect. Alternately, lowering the angle of the tool does the same, but the amount of pressure, the angle, and softness of the leather can be difficult to judge. You can use horse butt, which is stiffer than other leathers, and the edge doesn't sink so deeply into it, but it still holds the honing compound in place. For harder abrasives (e.g., diamond) you need a less compliant substrate. Depending on the particle size of the diamond, the optimum substrate may be acrylic, hard maple, cast iron, or even MDF. If the substrate is too soft, the abrasive particles embed more deeply in it, decreasing their cutting effect; If it is too hard, the abrasive particles tend to be rolled and pushed off of the substrate.
"Green crayon" is chromium oxide, sometimes mixed with tripoli, in a binder which is probably some kind of wax. All chromium oxide is not the same. IIRC, the green crayon grit size is about 9 microns. I get better results with 0.3 micron powder, which I have mixed with mineral oil and put into a syringe. I can then squeeze out a small dab onto the leather and just smear it around. Warning: when I did it, mixing it up and loading the syringe made a big mess. I found the chrome online, probably at a jewelry supply house. I use a Monoject 412 syringe.
I have noticed that chrome is not very effective on Lee-Valley's PM-V11 plane blades, and I suspect it is also pretty ineffective on Crown Pro-PM (CPM-3V) gouges and even worse on the carbide insert tooling used by Easy Wood Tools and others.
I have learned not to use the leather wheel on my Tormek. After I sharpen on the regular grinding wheel , that seems to be good enough. I found it does in fact make a tool duller if I use the leather wheel afterwards even with the honing compound on it. Nothing to do with Scary sharp but just my 2c using leather.
"It keeps the edge closer to the angle you sharpened it."
That seems to some extent old thinking. I am pretty harsh on keeping geometry when sharpening old school with Japanese tools and stones. But in the real world of buffing or using diamonds, it works so well that you don't have to worry about angles since they are easily reset or they don't need to be. If you round something over or change the angle, and have to mess around with a regrind that is a time waster, but if you can get razor sharp edges right off the strop and don't hardly ever have to drop down, what is the harm. My diamond stuff is mostly on leather, so it is softer than what I was used to, but it still seems to work better than my diamond stuff on surface ground iron.
Hi John. I sharpen mostly chisels, a couple plane irons and knives. The tormak does a great job but after I run those tools through the leather wheel I can see more reflection on the edges in the light meaning it has become more duller. Under a magnifier glass it confirms my thoughts. Someone mentioned don't use soft leather to sharpen. Perhaps that is why.
Jerry I'm not happy with the Tormek for sharpening carving tools. When using the grading stone they say the finish left is 1000 grit. I don't think so. It leaves noticeable lines that are still there after honing with the green compound. I feel it needs a step in between. Today I went throught the scary sharp system up to 2000 grit and then honed on the Tormek strop. That was pretty darn good. Then I honed on a hard felt wheel with a gold stick that I got with one of my carving sets. It seems to polish better than the green compound. I'm going to try an experiment tomorrow that may answer that question.
Just for the heck of it I sharpened my chip carving knife to the same degree and you can shave off slices of paper like it was butter. The skews that I sharpened to the same degree won't quite do that but almost. Of course they have a 30 degree included angle and the chip carving knife probably has about 10 degree. I'll have to measure that and see.