How to make an elongated screw hole
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
credit for sketch , Sgain
I am screwing a frame to the bottom of a cabinet which will require elongated screw holes to accommodate expansion. How are elongated holes made?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
How to make an elongated screw hole
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
credit for sketch , Sgain
I am screwing a frame to the bottom of a cabinet which will require elongated screw holes to accommodate expansion. How are elongated holes made?
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
John in NM
I do it by drilling two or three slightly overlapping holes with a brad point bit in the drill press. The sides of the bit can then be used to fully join the holes by tipping the piece or tipping the drill bit (having moved it to a hand drill motor for a larger piece). The flutes of the bit cut the material out of the slot. I'm usually doing this with a 1/4" bit, but it should work down to 3/16" or so. Works best with a stiff bit obviously, so 1/8" might not do too well.
They aren't always pretty, but it does work. I tend to use a homemade brad point for this because it's a bit abusive of the drill bit. Brad points are fairly easy to make with an old bit and the corner of the grinder wheel, assuming the wheel is dressed often enough to have corners.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Bill, I have done this on my Router table. I set the fence up so that the proper alignment across the board is set. then I set stops up for the length alignment. I hold the board against one stop then, lower the board on the bit, then move to the other stop. (Sometimes I just put up a couple of lines or tape on my fence as the position is not real critical).
I drill the screw pilot holes in the mating part last using the slots for alignment. Works for me, sounds kind of anal but makes a nice clean slot. You do have to move the board very slowly if the slot is narrow (#8 or smaller screw clearance) or the bit will break (been there done that!).
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
Dick Coers
For a quick slot, I drill the initial hole, rock the drill back and forth, then cycle the drill up and down while using a little side pressure with the drill chuck near the wood. If you don't like the side loading idea, a small diameter rasp will quickly remove the small web that is formed from rocking the drill back and forth. I've also just used a larger diameter hole, and put a fender washer under the head of a pan head screw.
Interesting question
Gary Smyth
When making elongated screw holes does the whole hole have to be elongated?
I've always drilled a straight hole 1/64 oversized where required, then inserted a drill from the exit side of the hole and moved it side to side making a "v"/triangular shaped hole, the wide base being in the direction of expected wood movement. I've never had a problem. The screw tip portion has the availability of movement, but the base of the screw pivots and stays conveniently in its countersink nest. The entrance is generally also slightly elongated doing this, but the appearance from the underside is clean. Depending on screw size 1/8 inch movement (with say a #8) is easily achieved. I may have been getting away with no splits owing to environmental conditions but I don't see why the total screw has to have the ability to move in a longer slot. Only the differing movement of the attached portion is all you need take into account
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
John McGaw
If you want it neat, make a router jig and rout a 3/4" slot deep enough to accommodate a washer and screw head and then rout a through-slot wide enough inside that to accommodate the screw shaft. Length of each long enough to allow for anticipated movement. This method gives almost unlimited movement if you want/need it and doesn't really show. Or, if neatness does not count too much, just drill a hole and rock the drill back and forth a bit. I've done it both ways but the latter method doesn't really allow for much movement.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
Jack Guzman from Maine
Bill,
I drill two holes. One at each end of my slot,then cut the web between with a small keyhole type detail saw and follow with a round file. In the case of a shorter slot just elongate one drilled hole with a round file.---Jack
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
Jesse Cloud
Another great application for a Domino (though certainly not worth the entry price on its own).
Start with a wide cutter and a shallow depth setting. Mark your domino's location on the workpiece. Repeat for all the shallow holes.
Then change to a smaller bit with a depth setting that will go through the workpiece. Return to the mark made for the first hole and plunge again. No need to move while you are cutting.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
jgdillon
Bill, can't add anything new to what has been said. In your application (prior to assembly), a drill press or plunge router would both work. Using a brad point bit, I drill the two extremes (much like starting a mortise), then roughly hog out the remainder, switch to a twist bit and run the bit side to side to remove the remaining wood. Usually though I just use a chisel to remove the "scallops" that are left A plunge router would work great as well, if you have a nice jig to hold the piece, but setup is a lot quicker with the drill press. Since this is a "through-mortise", I avoid tear-out by clamping a board to the exit point. Yeah, no one will ever see the elongated hole, but still... . I then use a countersink bit to ream out a channel for the head of the screw to allow the screw to sit flush with surface of the wood. Just looks prettier that way. Jim
Re: Interesting question
William Duffield
I used to do it just like Gary, and for the same reason, but now I usually use my Domino. See Jesse's explanation, below.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
TomD
I am not too sure what the sketch is indicating, but I would only put them front to back in that sketch since if the expansion is happening on the X axis, it is blowing out the mitered frame anyway so presumably that axis, which is the one showing the screws going in, is not actually going to have them elongated.
I know they are common, I don't like them and use angled blocks in mortises in the side frame like a table.
I pulled the pic from the net, and if those are drywall screws, I sure wouldn't be using them.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
Sgian Dubh
Tom the rear of the carcass and plinth is the wider section facing the viewer. Slots are worked only in the side elements of the plinth - they're not needed at the front because the grain orientation of both the carcass and the front sections of the plinth are the same.
The slots can be worked using pretty much any of the methods described by others. Generally, I just bore a hole and then wriggle the drill side to side to extend it, and do much the same with the countersink bit. Every once in a while, I get a bit fancier if there's a lot of movement expected, e.g., a wide oak table top with braces underneath, and I set up a router to cut a clean slot, and attach the brace to the underside of the top with round head screws and a washer to help spread the load. Slainte.
Thanks
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Some of the recommendations would result in too big a hole for the screws I have in mind. I will employ the wiggling drill bit.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
jgdillon
Tom, I agree with the elegance of those "buttons" - especially versus the metal versions. I have made quite a few and they are fun to do. I have found the Domino to be an ideal option, albeit an expensive one, for cutting the mortises. Fortunately I have found many other options for my Domino to justify (rationalize ?) the cost. Jim
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
TomD
"Tom the rear of the carcass and plinth is the wider section facing the viewer. Slots are worked only in the side elements of the plinth - they're not needed at the front because the grain orientation of both the carcass and the front sections of the plinth are the same"
That is what I thought I had said, but sometimes one needs a little help. It does appear they are shown on the front however, in the direction in which we both agree there is no movement. Of course that isn't Bill's actually thing, so he probably has all that in hand, just so that others dropping in aren't getting the wrong message.
Re: A Process Detail
William Duffield
This procedure may be obvious, but I figured I should describe it anyhow:
Start upside down with the leg frame in place on top of the case. Load your drill with a countersink bit matching the screw's small diameter and drill straight holes through the leg frame and into the case. Take the leg frame off the case and turn it over, right side up. Load the drill with a clearance hole bit matching the screw's large (thread) diameter, and drill holes back through each hole in the leg frame. Back the drill bit almost out of the clearance hole until the end of the bit is just shy of the bottom of the countersink, and wiggle it back and forth, in the direction of the expansion and contraction of the case.
A similar procedure works for attaching table tops to aprons.
Re: How to make an elongated screw hole
Sgian Dubh
Tom, you surmised correctly. I suppose in the sketch Bill used, which is mine, and obviously hand drawn, my sketching skills weren't good enough to indicate the screw holes along the front rail of the plinth are circular rather than elongated. Slainte.
Late to the game, but...
Kent B
Drill two holes at the ends of the envelope with a hand-held drill of any flavor.
Use a chisel and a hammer to clear the waste in between.
Not at all complicated. No need for Green Kool-Aid gear. None of this will ever be seen.
Re: A Process Detail
John b chicago burbs
Bill i think that you are a fan of Lee Valley. Check their web site on April 1, they may have an elongated hole brad point bit. 