Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Residential construction tidbits

Posts

Residential construction tidbits

#1

Residential construction tidbits

Barry Irby

My home inspection group had an expert on roofing give a presentation the other night. He testifies on roofing defects everywhere east of the Mississippi.

He tells us that as the 2015 IRC Code is adopted roof sheeting will have to be 5/8" PLYWOOD (not OSB) regardless of the spacing of the rafters.

Having followed codes for the last forty years, I don't understand. Has anyone seen large scale disasters that were caused by 1/2" OSB? This has an ecological component as well. Takes better trees to make plywood.

Also told us that no pneumatically driven 8 penny nails are available that meet the code. The shank diameter is too small. Some areas are permitting double nailing.

Since they are being persnickety I wonder if they will accept 15mm plywood? Can't remember the last time I saw a sheet of plywood that was ACTUALLY 5/8"

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Residential construction tidbits

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

This is where I get annoyed with building codes. Thirty, forty, fifty years ago, almost any new code addressed widespread problems and deficiencies and vastly improved the overall new building quality in the U.S. However, now that the big problems are more or less fixed, the code organizations need to have a product to sell, so they keep finding problems, and they're down to the minuscule issues, even when correcting one small deficiency causes other, larger problems, which then then try to fix... Meanwhile, the local building authorities dutifully adopt the updated codes along the way (albeit with a bit of a delay).

Jason

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#3

Agree...

John in NM

Seems like a pretty faked up "problem" to me. I guess building is just too inexpensive with $6 OSB :D

Their time would be better spent working on genuine problems if they can find any - and you make a good point that there are few any more. Standardization of practices is a great thing for that very reason. Sad to be reminded of the switch to this kind of niggling BS.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#4

Re: Residential construction tidbits

Dick Coers

That's going to be a rough job getting some of the curved construction grade plywood sucked down to the rafters.

I've always wondered about the life span of the chopped up veneer structural lumber.

A quote from an article I found;

"OSB takes longer to get wet than plywood but also takes longer to dry out. When used as a roof sheathing, this tendency to hold moisture means it can degrade faster than plywood when exposed to chronic leaks.

When OSB does get wet it also tends to swell along the edges, and those edges stay swollen even after the material has dried out. Swollen edges have been known to telegraph visible ridges called “ghost lines” through asphalt roof shingles."

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#5

What Dick said

Gary Smyth

Last May a relative reroofed his garage. Planned for months. He used OSB. Then came the rain. The roof was largely protected by tarps but the gable overhangs and some eaves were exposed. It was a simple afternoon spring squall, but the result was quick -- a dozen or so of the OSB boards had to be cut/replaced along with a bit more than a square of new shingles. A full day lost by a crew. In his case OSB was an expensive mistake.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Residential construction tidbits

Jack Guzman from Maine

I've done alot of roof repairs here in Maine. I have seen 7/16" osb fail many times as roof sheathing.People love using it because it is so cheap. Roofs were formerly sheathed with 1" rough boards. 5/8 plywood is a fair alternative but osb is just pushing your luck. I prefer either 3/4"plywood or t&g pine boards for roof sheathing.Osb should never be used as roof sheathing because is isn't adequate for the task. Even if it was allowed I wouldn't use it.Of course things are a little more critical in Maine than in more southern states. I have seen upwards of four feet of snow on roofs locally. That is where cheaply built roofs show it.---Jack

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#7

Good to hear this,

Keith Newton

Although I hope I never have to put another roof on for as long as I live.

I surely hope they have a foil faced plywood, and they ought to make that mandatory, when you consider how well it works, for so little material expense, and no extra labor to install.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#8

Re: Good to hear this,

Barry Irby

Keith, have you used the foil back roof sheathing? I have heard of it but never seen it. I have heard good things abut it keeping the heat out in summer and in in winter. Does that match your experience?

I have heard stories of it retaining moisture by not allowing the OSB to breath and it becomes soggy. Any experience with this?

Where are you? climate wise.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#9

Re: What Dick said

C. John Hebert

I'm surprised the codes wern't changed a long time ago to get rid of that OSB garbage. Every single re roof I've done, I can't tell you how many sheets had to be replaced on roof's less than 10yrs old due to dry rot around condensation around roofing nails into the osb. OSB on framing members 2' on centers, and some 16" centers sag, and most cases noticeable from the road. While it's cheaper in the short term to use this garbage...it's costlier in the long term with replacement before time, and real sale value's.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#10

Re: Roofers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Our roof was 30+ and due for replacement. Called several guys for quotes on a full tear, r/r sheathing were needed, + I&W.

First guy comes in 3K below what I expected so asked for specs as I knew we had several sections that needed new sheathing after some persistent leaks. Sure enough, plan was for OSB, light weight felt, and only 2' of I&W. Sales pitch was "You got a steep roof, so heavier sheathing not required (and sky lights don't need the rubber)".

"Next!!!"

We put on 3/4 ply and rebooted the skies.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#11

I wonder if it's climate...

John in NM

The stuff is so popular out here that its in every Home Depot - but then the climate here favors materials that help with cooling and also appears to be much more forgiving of OSB than the wetter parts of the country. I can't say as I've seen foiled plywood for sale, its all OSB (which my neighbor calls SOB :D )

If I leave OSB exposed to the summer rains the edges start to swell after a couple weeks, rather than hours or days. It sure sounds like that is not the case on the east coast!

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#12

Yes I have, and it really does the trick *LINK*

Keith Newton

I guess the first time I ever used it, was for my nephew's new master bedroom addition about 12 years ago. It had a black composition shingle roof on top. But when the Sun was high, I could get right up under it, without feeling any heat radiating down from it. Of course, you would feel the heat by putting you hand against it, but not before touching it. For this reason, you wouldn't want to fill the space with insulation where the insulation touches it.

This addition had a cathedral ceiling, so I think I went with 2x10s for the rafters, which allowed a decent amount of insulation for the cold months. But then for this situation, they make a 1/8" thick foam extrusion which has ridges about like metal roofing, which can be stapled to the underside, which provides a clear air path from eve vents to ridge vents.

I'm in LR AR, at about the same latitude as you. Never heard of any moisture problems, and can't imagine any naturally occurring problems, other than maybe having bathroom vents going right into the attic space. Having a BIG hot water heater combined with raising teens that like to take LONG hot showers, can ice up any already cold surface that will get covered with frost in a cold attic space. I've seen this on raw wood before, and is easy to avoid by sending a vent duct either out the roof, or a gable, instead of just dumping it in the attic, which is the norm.


http://www.buildgp.com/thermostat-radiant-barrier-plywood

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#13

Re: Residential construction tidbits

TomD

Does anyone know how these codes work? Normally insurance is the thing driving stuff out there. With all the extreme weather the damage to homes that loose their roofs partially must a concern. OSB has been marketed as a superior product but that is a bit of a joke. If you see million dollar, I guess 10 million dollar home today, go up they have 3/4 D-Fir sheathing, or better. And OSB is not that cheap if you factor in all the stuff that people do to bring it up to code of the weather. People are plating roofs with ice and water shield, then shingling. You end up with so many products going up there in addition to shingles it is as expensive as if you used real wood in the first place.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#14

Re: Codes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As mentioned, I think the code writers are reactive by nature.

Take Ice & Water shielding: My house was built in '85 as part of the higher-end housing boom in this area. It's a contemporary design with cathedral ceilings, sky lights, and less than half the roof over attic space. Rafters are all 2x12, and there are sofit and ridge ventings but the builder didn't use either bay vent channel or I&W because local code didn't require them then. The result, of course, were ice dams and leaks as the melt-water over "heated" roof backed up under the shingles and worked its way in. Without the true air-flow up the bays (packed full of glass) the bottom surface of the ply sheathing was the place for water vapor from the interior to condense and begin to attack the ply.

Now, both I&W and vent channels are required here by code.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#15

Re: Codes

Barry Irby

This has been interesting. I thought the change was over kill. Maybe not.

I wish there were better feed back channels for the problems the code inspectors are seeing that motivate the changes. At least that's what I hope is happening.

Thirty years ago I reported water leaking under exterior doors to the local Building Official. They were not interested. Said the problems took more than two years to show up and did not show up on 100% of houses or doors. I was stunned. (You only count 100%?????) They said they don't improve the code, they just enforce the one they are given. If I wanted it improved or changed I should submit the changes to the national body myself. So the people in the field feel no obligation to report or improve the Code. Eventually they improved the flashing under doors.

I've done about 10,000 inspections and am not aware of any failures that were specific to OSB. I have seen OSB fail because there were leaks, but I have also seen plywood and sheeting boards fail for the same reasons.

I wonder how much it woudl cost to make OSB better? Masonite failed because they kept cutting back on the glue. It was a race to the bottom and they nearly ran themselves out of business. Just have to wonder if another 50 cents worth of glue would seriously improve the product?

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#16

Suspect

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the problem is we have far more cellulose than we can turn into something useful. After all, isn't OSB ( and the other engineered stuff like microlam and MDF) an effort to use waste and cut the cost of ply and heavy solid wood beams at the same time?

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#17

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

We just up-graded a bathroom which involved some framing. Contractor I hired had to go home and get his big gun Hitachi framing nailer when his cordless Paslode hit the 30 year old LVL and just bounced!

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#18

Re: Residential construction tidbits

TomD

"Takes better trees to make plywood."

I think they may be trying to GMO that. Apparently it is underway. There is an interesting talk on ted about hi-rise wooden apartment buildings.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#19

Re: Residential construction tidbits

TomD

And the cool deal there is carbon capture.

Re: Residential construction tidbits

#20

Sidling off onto a different topic.

Barry Irby

I just heard that huge forest owners can get big bucks for carbon capture. I have 135 acres of pines. Looked into it. No joy for the little guys.