Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

Posts

Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#1

Advise me.  Block plane... Low angle or regular?

Mike Circo

So, I've lusted after a Veritas block plane for a long time as my first hand plane purchase.

I often feel a need for a plane to trim tenon ends, or chamfer their ends for ease of insertion. Same for leg bottoms, trimming plugs, knocking down sharp edges and other yet undetermined uses.

Lee Valley is having a free shipping event for the next week and a half so that is the final straw to get my first plane. (free shipping 2/11 thru 2/22)

My first instinct is to go for the Veritas low angle block plane. But being a rookie at this, I wondered if the standard plane is more versatile for a starter. So... what say you all?

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#2

Re: Advise me.  Block plane... Low angle or regula

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have both angles and use both. You might consider getting the LV expensive angle you think you would most use and a used Stanley for the other angle. The LV is a nice plane.

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#3

Both

Hoa in Alameda

When it comes to Lee Valley block plane, you can have the cake and eat it too. :)

Get the low-angle block plane, and a 38° blade.

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#4

Re: Low Angle

Hank Knight

I have two low angle block planes, a L-N 102 and a L-N 60 1/2. The little 102 is probably the most used plane in my shop. It is a basic plane, no adjustable mouth or other fancy features, but is a very well made, solid work horse, capable of very fine work. The 60 1/2 is heavier with an adjustable mouth. It is an excellent tool too. I don't own a regular angle block plane and I have never run into a situation where I wished for one. I also have a small Sauer & Steiner infill that is my small regular or high angle plane, but I seldom use it.

My $.02, FWIW.

Hank

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#5

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never seen an application where adjusting the block plane mouth was useful.

I would find changing blades between low angle and effective high angle a nuisance. For me a block plane is something I want to be able to reach for , take a few swipes and move on.

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#6

Re: Advise me.  Block plane... Low angle or regula

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Mike

Others here have advised you to get both 12- and 20- degree bed block planes. I agree, but you should know why and when to use them.

I keep all blades at 25 degrees. With low angle/bevel up blades, a 25 degree bevel is durable (I would go to 30 degrees for bevel down bench planes). I also hollow grind and freehand at this angle, but a flat bevel is just fine as well. Since this is your first hand plane, consider how you plan to sharpen it/them. A cheap honing guide, such as the Eclipse, is all you need.

My go-to block planes are a LN 103 (20 degrees) and a LN 60 1/2 or Veritas NX60 (both 12 degrees). A word about block planes .... they are cute buggers and they multiply like rabbets. Some will say they do not need them. I use them all the time. There are many: vintage and new. Even the cheap ones work, while the more expensive ones provide more pleasure, if you are the type of person to enjoy good tools, like a quality beer or wine. For myself, they enhance the fun of building furniture.

The classic block plane is the Stanley #60 1/2. Another is the Stanley #65. Both are 12 degree beds. However the are different in the hand, with the latter a wider plane and more suited to a large hand. I like blockplanes to be small, although my hand is on the larger size. The point is, this is a personal factor. It helps to try first before you purchase. The block plane most similar to the wider #65 is the Veritas LA Block Plane.

The LN #103 is no longer available. It is smaller/narrower than the #60 1/2 or NX60. Here's the thing with BU planes - just grind a higher bevel angle, and it functions as a hiher bed. So a #102 with a 33-degree bevel will work the same as a #103 with a 25-degree bevel. Another small block plane that is worth considering - an alternative to the LN102 - is the Veritas Apron Plan.

OK, so why 12- and 20-degree beds? The lower cutting angle is better for end grain. It will leave a smoother surface than a higher cutting angle. Get a 12-degree bed for trimming end grain. The 20-degree bed is better on face grain and chamfering edges since it is less inclined to tear out.

Reviews: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasPremiumBlockPlane.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/The%20Orange%20Block%20Plane.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#7

Different Experience

Hank Knight

Drerk, you cautioned about tear out issues with the low angle 102. As I said in my post above, I use my little 102 for just about every block plane task. I have been using it to chamcer edges for over 15 years - it's my favorite plane for chamfering. I can't recall ever having a tear out issue with it. Admittedly, I seldom use it on face grain, but I have used it on face grain in the past and I don't recall having issues with it. I'm well aware of the cautions about using a low angle attack on face grain, but I simply have not experienced that problem with the 102. I don't use it for large face grain tasks - it's a tiny plane, after all - but, in my book, it's just about perfect for almost everything I use a block plane for. As you said, block planes seem to multiply. I have a bunch of them, but I could get along very well with only my 102. YMMV.

Hank

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#8

Re: Different Experience

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Hank

It will depend on the wood. Soft woods and straight grains will not test the plane much. However interlocked grain certainly does. The #102 with a 25-degree bed cuts at a low 37 degrees. The #103 with the same blade cuts at 45 degrees. Plane most face grains in my world with a low angle, and you will get tearout.

The method to minimise tearout when chamfering is to plane at an angle, and take fine cuts.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#9

Re: Different Experience

Hank Knight

Derek, I often forget how pleasant it is to be blessed with compliant, submissive woods. :)

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#10

Re: Different Experience

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Hank

I would dearly love to have the ease of working with woods, such as your Cherry and Walnut. I likely would never have used - even thought of - high angled bench planes or turning the chipbreaker - if they were available locally. Our timbers are very beautiful but very hard, often brittle, and definitely highly interlocked .. a bitch to work with handtools. (I am sure some of the tuning focus I go into in my plane reviews must come across as OTT to those outside Oz).

Do you want to trade a boatload of Jarrah, She-oak, and Marri for some Cherry, Black Walnut, and Maple? :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#11

Re: Different Experience

Hank Knight

Derek,

Your timbers may be a bitch to work, but I wish I could come even close to the quality of your work using our more forgiving woods. And, for the record, I'd love to swap you a boatload of North American hardwood for a boatload of your gnarly Aussie stuff. I think a lot of your wood is extravagantly beautiful. I'm sure this a case of "the grass is greener on the other side of the fence," but I do admire your jarrah, sheoak and blackwood.

As for your posts about tools being a little over the top, I don't think they are at all. You are always dead-on with the theory (high angle attack for face grain, etc.,) but in this particular case, the OP was inquiring about recommendations for the purchase of his first block plane, and he expressed some concern about the expense involved. (How's that for a run-on sentence?) Ideally, he should have both a low angle and a standard angle block plane, and even, perhaps, additional irons ground at various angles to accommodate whatever grain configuration he encounters. But, given his parameters, I think his best investment would be in a low angle block plane, and the little 102 is a jewel. With it's utility on end grain, IMHO, it finds a much wider range of applications using American hardwoods than a standard angle block plane. Plus, it's relatively inexpensive compared to other choices. My opinion and recommendation. Perhaps I should stated it this way in my original post.

Hank

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#12

Re: Advise me.  Block plane... Low angle or regula

C. John Hebert

Low angle is what you'll use the most. I have more planes than I use and most just sit there collecting dust, while my low angle get's a work out.

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#13

Re: Advise me.  Block plane... Low angle or regula

Bill White

C. John??? Where the h--- have ya been?

Glad to see ya posting.

I just use my stupid old Stanley # 60 1/2. Very sharp, and works for me.

Bill

Re: Advise me. Block plane... Low angle or regular?

#14

Plus TWO on the Low angle

Ron in Sterling CT

Get a low angle first, than a regular angle later. You can do more with a low angle, but not everything. My experience and 2 cents worth.

Ron