Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Rocket Mass Heaters?

Posts

Rocket Mass Heaters?

#1

Rocket Mass Heaters?

TomD

Anyone drink the Koolaid on these. Seems like a wonderful idea, which is basically a chimney fire with heat storage. More efficient and lower emissions than almost any alternative. I like the idea, and like the idea of making one into a workshop fixture that would allow one to heat as required, but use it the rest of the year as some shop furniture.

I bring it up here because BillT mentioned something about heating kilns with by-product wood, and it sent my mind a wandering.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#2

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters? *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Here's where I first heard of these:

It also seems to me that FWW did an article on them, or maybe it was FHB, many years ago. They're highly efficient and would be a great use of my scrap hoard.


Russian Fireplace

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#3

Re: Has to have a barrel 

TomD

More like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4usXIAoy9us

Don't need this kickstarter, there is a lot of free info out there:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/paulwheaton/rocket-mass-heaters-4-dvd-set/comments

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#4

TomD---edit the links

Tom Dunlap

If you delete the 's' in https WC will make it clickable...I think ;)

Tom

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#5

Re: Has to have a barrel 

TomD

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4usXIAoy9us

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#6

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

CJ in MPLS

Ya know, I think they are great. But at some point, I just don't want the house to look like a yurt. I think that the much nicer looking versions of this are those soapstone Scandinavian stoves that have so much thermal mass. NOT as efficient as a rocket stove I think, but they go better with the martini and the leather chair. ;)

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Links

Ellis Walentine

The only way to get clickable links into the text of your message is to use HTML, which I don't particularly recommend unless you know what you're doing. Members with valid profiles (their names appear as blue hyperlinks at the top of their posts) can paste one link into the "Optional Link URL" box and it will appear as a clickable link at the end of the post. Unregistered members don't have this option, so they must cut and paste URLs into the message box, and the rest of us must copy and paste the URLs into our browser's address bar to view the pages.

Ellis

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#8

Re: Has to have a barrel 

CJ in MPLS

Funny you should say that. I clearly recall melting crayons on a barrel stove that was red hot when I was about 4. Murphy watched over me as a child I think.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#9

Re: Not practical in most area of USA

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I researched these when I heated with wood for about 8 years. They sound great until you figure out you have little control about adjusting the temperature in your home. They are very suited for much of Siberia and Russia, and possible much of Alaska.

The problem using one in climates that have widely variable temperatures like my state of Indiana is that there is no way to shut down the heat output rapidly.

IE: Say it drops to 0 degree on Monday, you build a large fire and your home warms up to 70 in 8 to 12 hours (Yeah they don't heat quickly). On Tuesday a warm front comes through and it is now 40 Deg.. Your home is now in the 90+ deg range and stays there for 8 to 12 hours or more (open windows).

They are basically like heating with a 2 ton cast iron stove!

In areas where the winter temperature is somewhat constant (and quite cold) they are quite efficient but.....

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#10

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

TomD

I think that is just the hippiescape they are coming from. There is no reason they can't look like Manhattan whether they can get approved there is another mater. Some are being installed with horizontal evacuation, like a drier, though that really isn't all that viable yet, but I imagine it will get there eventually and eliminate one of the ugly elements.



Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#11

Re: Not practical in most area of USA

TomD

I think you have a point. My thought was more for shops, where too much heat would make a nice change now and then. For homes my main interest is for when the power goes out and we loose heat, and for providing a base of heat, that might get the house to 50 or 60, plus create some warm surfaces, and let the central heating do the rest. I have gas which exposes me to world markets, grid collapse, and gives me a bad forced air heat experience. It is true that it just runs in the background and is well modulated, but hardly perfect. Something to supplement would be nice.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#12

Re: I heat with wood for over 40 yrs

C. John Hebert

and I'm sorry...I don't find that much of a fluctuation that drastic in controlling temps. Last night was one of those nights where the temp outside rose and I cracked a bedroom window. It was nice to have fresh air blowing in my face. I keep my home really warm as I hate clothes on. I am very comfortable inside until it gets -20 withe the wind blowing. I have a good stove and get 7-8hrs on a burn and toward the end...the house temp drops about 5 degrees depending on how tired I am. I know to well that staying in bed when the temp drops has a price tag, so I get up right away and throw a few pieces on my bed of coals. I have a small log home and heat it with about 4-5 cord with no back up system in place and wouldn't trade it for the world. Some may regard bringing in wood everyday and cleaning ash a pain in the arse, but I look at it as exercise at my age and the savings in regards to oil makes it all worth while. As for building large fires and then being to hot...is really an inexperienced person with wood fires. Dampers slow down the burn and why would you load up a stove when you don't have to? If it's to warm outside...just throw one piece in just to keep it going. If you use a blower, shut it down. Also...I use ceiling fans to better distribute the heat more evenly. You couldn't convince me to go with a conventional system if you tried. There's nothing like smelling birch or cherry on a cold morning while having my coffee, or at Christmas. I also have glass doors and see the flame glowing in the room when I go to bed....it just adds to that warm feeling when you hear the wind howling here in the woods of Maine.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#13

Re: I agree with wood heat~

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

But the discussion here was about the "Russian Fireplaces", ones that have a large mass of stone for heat storage. They are quite efficient but the large thermal mass makes "quick heat or reduction of the room temperature" impossible. I totally agree with you regarding wood heat. I heated totally with wood for 8 or 9 years. Only reason I stopped was that surgery of my neck / spine made it impossible for me to cut and split wood. I had no problem heating my home or controlling the temperature with conventional wood stoves at all!

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#14

Re: 1/10th the cost and CO2 of gas

TomD

Well actually we are talking about rocket mass heaters. But your point still plays, but would it be so bad to have to open a window, or air out the house?

RMH users claim to be able to heat for the winter off scrap from trees off a few acre lot. I don't know about that, but I like the security of having an option that can't run out, even if I am able to heat with gas for as long as the money keeps poring in, or the grid stays up. And for my shop, I have gas, but it doesn't really get me what I want. I use elctric, but it is too little for time when the temp plunges. A base of heat from my scrap would appeal to me.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#15

Re: I agree with wood heat~

C. John Hebert

Well..........I didn't see anything about a Russian, but I built one in my other log cabin from the field stone we took out of a new pasture. Stone, while it works...is not as efficient as brick. The concept of the Russian is great!! While I see the authors point on regulating is only with opening a window...then maybe he needs to just stick to something less physical like lowering a thermostat. The only problem I didn't like with my Russian was bringing in so much wood for that short blast fire. The wood was free as I burnt slabs from a local saw mill, but it was messy cutting and handling that I didn't like. Hell, I even burnt cardboard boxes in mine lol. The fire lasted maybe 1 to 1/2hrs to heat the massive stone structure....and it radiated heat for almost 24hrs that kept the house toasty and very comfortable from that 1 1/2hr fire and the ash was cold. Inside the chimney was white as opposed a regular chimney of black soot, or tar in appearance.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#16

Re: let me add

C. John Hebert

I don't "ever" remember the house being to hot with the Russian. The Russian heated 1/2 of a 3000 sq. ft. Log Gabriel. The other half by a wood stove. The Russian replaced an antique cast iron cook stove with a small firebox.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#17

Re: Rocket Mass H. not = Russion/Masonry heater


Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#18

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

david weaver

Where did this go so far, tom? Are you going to build one? I think if you could build one that had decent looking geometry, it would be a worthwhile thing to do. It creates a warm spot, burns hot and clean, and doesn't burn 24 hours a day (but still gives residual heat).

I could live in a house that was heated by such a thing, but I know my wife couldn't in the days of no part of the house being 2 degrees cooler than any other part. If the temperature fluctuated 10 degrees between firings, I'd think little of it.

I live in the burbs, though, so it's a no-go here due to code and lack of wood supply. I like the idea of the system because it's how we heated the house when I was a kid - a large woodstove and a hearth. It was warm nearer the wood stove, but we didn't try to keep the rest of the house the same temperature. I don't remember feeling limited as a kid by not being able to go to the far corners of the house and feel 70 degree heat, but I sure appreciated a warm spot to come in to after cleaning snow.

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

#19

Re: Rocket Mass Heaters?

TomD

Living in Can heat is a mater of survival. And periodically there is an ice storm or a power outage lasting a week or more. Last time there was an outage, it lasted only 24 hrs. and the 3 kids/shareholders were onthe verge of appointing a whole new board So I have some interest as backup heat.

Immediately, I am more interested in it as shop heat. One of the limiting aspects of these heaters is that they have so far been most successfully configured as couches. I am interested in having one configured as a workbench so that I would loose little space. Since they are solid stone, etc... They can be right against the wall, though codes may not agree. Codes have not caught up as yet.