Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

Posts

Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

#1

Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

Barry Irby

I am giving Expert Witness Testimony as a Home Inspector later today. The house is trimmed out with MDF installed in what the builder calls Craftsman Style. Basically flat 1 x 4" door facings with the top being built out in several layers. There is a dining room with framed panels that rise to about eye level, taller than the average wainscoting.

There are a number of problems. Apparently they used nail guns to assemble the trim. Nearly every nail hole has a little eruption around it. Many of them they just smeared some filler in and on. Some of them they sort of sanded, most, not.

In the dining room with the wainscot they apparently painted it over and over with different tools, spray, brushes and rollers, and you can see every change in texture and paint.

And there are places where the trim failed to "lay flat" and they just sanded it into submission. The problem here is that MDF seems to have a slick skin or surface and when they sand off part of it it shows through the paint.

This seems to be a two part problem. Poor workmanship with an unforgiving material and a less than helpful painter.

My question is, how could this have been done better? How do you nail MDF and then make the nail holes disappear? How do you address the inevitable irregularities without sanding away the surface and exposing the coarser innards? And how do you paint it to cover those spots and make them disappear?

(Let me add that I don't like the stuff much anyway. But that's personal and I will keep it out of this incident.)

Re: Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

#2

Re: Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

David Yoho

Like you, I don't like the stuff for a situation like you described. They would have been much better off using poplar. Of course, there's no accounting for poor workmanship and finishing even if they used poplar.

Re: Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

#3

Re: Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

John McGaw

I have a small amount of home-made MDF trim in my family room and the one thing I didn't have trouble with is the nail holes. Basically, pre-drilling for a suitably sized finish nail (one per stud) and a bit of adhesive behind took care of fastening and some filler took care of the holes. My trim was pre-primed and pre-painted before installation and there wasn't any problem in touching up the filled holes. That is the good part. Joins were impossible to hide no matter what I did and rough chipped profiles off the shaper mar the look in a number of places. I don't know of any way around these and when I re-do the room some day I will be using something else, probably off-the-rack, for the trim. Certainly it will be a cleaner style more in keeping with the era of the house unlike the choice I made before which look like the 'early Victorian brothel' school of design.

Re: Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

#4

Biggest issue was the wrong primer

Dick Coers

The nail holes have to be addressed with a wood sanding block and proper grit. The finish carpenter probably assumed the painter was responsible, the painter was PO'd when he saw it, complained to the other painters about the lazy trim carpenter, then didn't do the right prep to fix the mess ups. Some MDF does have a really hard skin. But if you use the proper primer and thickness of primer, none of those rough issues would have been seen. It would likely take a schedule of primer, sand, primer, sand, then final coat of paint. The painter likely used one of those primer/paint deals they sell at the big box. Doesn't work as you saw. It takes a real heavy body primer like Zinser, and two coats of it if the MDF skin has been broken.

Re: Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions

#5

Re: Biggest issue was the wrong primer

Clifton C


All MDF except the drawer unit that was MCP. No fun at all, but it looked good in the end. All nailed, stapled, and glued as MDF doesn't take to dovetails. Nail/staple holes were "dimpled" using a carriage bolt like a nail set, then filled with spackle pulled tight so a light block sanding brings it flush. Zinsser sprayed via old fashion cup gun set to spray max product at lowest pressure (fan) to give a slight texture. These are old school pictures scanned into computer so I'm sure something will be lost in translation. As I said, not much fun but the owners loved us and so did the painters.