Working with MDF as Residential trim Questions
Barry Irby
I am giving Expert Witness Testimony as a Home Inspector later today. The house is trimmed out with MDF installed in what the builder calls Craftsman Style. Basically flat 1 x 4" door facings with the top being built out in several layers. There is a dining room with framed panels that rise to about eye level, taller than the average wainscoting.
There are a number of problems. Apparently they used nail guns to assemble the trim. Nearly every nail hole has a little eruption around it. Many of them they just smeared some filler in and on. Some of them they sort of sanded, most, not.
In the dining room with the wainscot they apparently painted it over and over with different tools, spray, brushes and rollers, and you can see every change in texture and paint.
And there are places where the trim failed to "lay flat" and they just sanded it into submission. The problem here is that MDF seems to have a slick skin or surface and when they sand off part of it it shows through the paint.
This seems to be a two part problem. Poor workmanship with an unforgiving material and a less than helpful painter.
My question is, how could this have been done better? How do you nail MDF and then make the nail holes disappear? How do you address the inevitable irregularities without sanding away the surface and exposing the coarser innards? And how do you paint it to cover those spots and make them disappear?
(Let me add that I don't like the stuff much anyway. But that's personal and I will keep it out of this incident.)




