Staining wood
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I am considering ordering N.American wood handles, and then staining them a dark brown to match Jarrah. Which of these will take stain best?
Red Oak
Maple
Cherry
Regards from Perth
Derek
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Staining wood
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I am considering ordering N.American wood handles, and then staining them a dark brown to match Jarrah. Which of these will take stain best?
Red Oak
Maple
Cherry
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Staining wood
David Yoho
Personally, I would not use oak unless the project wood was oak too.
That said, when you say "stain" do you mean staining the wood using stain or dye?
Traditional stain that is either pigmented or pigment with some dye will not do much for maple. Cherry is not as tough but its grain still doesn't allow capture of pigment particles like a more open grain wood like oak.
I think you can achieve better results mixing your desired color from several dyes if you decide to use maple or cherry.
None of the above, need more information
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
While you didn't say I presume you mean the handles to go on the chest of drawers.
Clarify the color objective. To match as in be equal? Or complimentary? If equal there must be some unapparent reason to not use the wood you got.
Personally I would use African Blackwood or Ebony for handles. I use blackwood a lot for handles. It attractively contrasts to many woods. It turns on a lathe like brass. Holes can be tapped for threaded screws. It is wicked brittle when stressed so don't try to force anything into an undersized hole. Don't finish it which is good for a handle where the finish will wear off or get gummy. Polish and wax, done.
But to get to your specific question I don't see any of the proposed choices being appropriate.
PS
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If you are committed to N. American and stain then ash or hickory will best match the texture. In fact hickory heartwood will match the color.
Re: PS
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Thanks Bill and David
Yes, the handles are for the chest I am building. I have designed handles for it, which I had planned to either build in Jarrah (to not detract from the drawer fronts), or in ebonised wood (as a complementary contrast). The other alternative is bronze, however I wonder if this will then clash with the brass fittings inside the lid?
Anyway, I came across some wooden handles at Lee valley that are very similar to the ones I designed. It may be quicker to modify these. However then I am left with wood that is light in colour.
Regards from Perth
Derek
End grain or face grain?
Dick Coers
Makes a world of difference when adding color if we are talking about a simple knob. End grain may take a pretreat if you want to try and color match. Either that or about 3 shades lighter stain for end grain.
Re: PS
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"ebonised wood " forget the ebonizing and just use Ebony or Blackwood.
An answer and a recommendation
Ellis Walentine
You can stain any wood to whatever color you want; the real question is the texture, and possibly the hardness. Some combination of NGR, dye and/or pigments will provide the color you want. I can't imagine using store-bought knobs (even from Lee Valley), although I'm somewhat of a design snob when it comes to nuances of shape. Most production knobs fall short, for me at least.
I'm with Bill, though, on his recommendation to bite the bullet and make them yourself from Blackwood or Ebony, if black is the color you have in mind. I've done this many times, including in my kitchen where I turned probably 40 large Shaker-style knobs out of cocobolo. Just make yourself a screw chuck for your lathe, pre-drill and tap the blanks, thread them on the chuck and turn away. It's repetitive but you get into a groove with it pretty quickly. Pad some oil on them on the lathe and wax them for a nice finish.
Ellis
Re: An answer and a recommendation
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Thanks Ellis and Bill
It would not be much of a concern if the handles I have in mind were round and capable of being turned. Instead, they are rectangular and will need to be carved out of solid. I was looking at a short cut by modifying something ready made and close in shape. The problem lies with the figure being different, even if the colour is spot on. Or the wood not being re-coloured evenly .... just too many things to spoil the final piece.
Regars from Perth
Derek
If you can't match it, contrast it
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
You didn't answer the question as to why you are not using the same wood for handles as the case if the main objective is to match.
Re: Staining wood
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
I've used cherry, stained (dyed, actually) with dark brown leather dye, or India ink, to get the match (or contrast) I want.
Re: If you can't match it, contrast it
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Bill
I had planned to make the handles using some scrap from the drawer fronts. That would, obviously, be a good match. Now I am not so sure it is the best way to go.
The aim is to not let the handles dominate. I want to keep them on the small side (approx 4" long - this is not a large chest), and only have a single handle in the centre of each drawer.
However, I am mindful that the figure in the drawers is pretty wild, and any small pieces placed on top (in the form of a handle) will have a clash of grain. I think that will detract. Consequently, the handles need to be a uniform colour, and it will come down to either bronze (my wife's preference) or ebony (my preference).
Regards from Perth
Derek
My thoughts
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Disclaimer: I have no confidence in my design ability, nor should anyone else.....but for what it is worth the "busy" front of that case needs a little breaking up with a discrete pull of some sort. Brushed brass, or bronze or black bronze would do, certainly not bright brass. Hold a piece of Blackwood up to the front and you can tell at a glance if it is going to work. I think it will nicely. Just buffed, Blackwood (it's the stuff clarinets are made from) has a rich but subdued luster that seems just right for a knob. And it is all uniform black. And with no finish or stain to wear off it will last forever. I have no experience with ebony...might be as good or better.
Re: Staining wood
John in NM
Of the ones you list, I would try cherry first. If the knob is small and you are going for a black stain, maple would be fine too. If walnut is available in the pattern you choose, you could also try ebonizing with a ferric acetate solution or something similar. That might work with cherry as well, I don't know.
We used to make rectangular knobs by hand in a shop I worked for, it really wasn't too hard with a little practice. Most woodworkers have a good visual memory if they can learn to trust it - practice is just that learning.
You make such beautiful stuff that I would encourage you to make the knobs or handles too out of your preferred material. I think its going to fit your piece better than anything you can buy and stain.
Re: Staining wood
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Thanks John.
It is more likely that I will make the handles myself. I simply cannot find anything that is the design I want in the size I need and in the material that will be sympathetic.
The hard bit is sourcing African Blackwood in Australia. Not easy at all! This is why I asked about staining, or ebonising.
This is close to the design I plan on making ...

I'll make them in a plain, unfigured but dark Jarrah as well as, if I can acquire, African Blackwood.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Staining wood
TomD
I don't think any of those woods is all that great stained. If you want black you can use iron oxide on maple, and that might turn it black, it certainly turns woods like oak black, but then you have the open pores to deal with.