Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

What to measure to square a case?

Posts

What to measure to square a case?

#1

What to measure to square a case?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As many "boxes" as I have made squaring the "box" remains a black art. The dovetails I use now days are largely self squaring, yet different measures of "square" usually yield different results on every box I build.

I just glued a box for a small chest of drawers. The diagonals are both 707 mm, indicating astonishingly square. (I use metric for diagonal squaring because the values are easier to compare for this operation.) Yet moving a square around the inside yields measurements of variable amounts of out of squareness. All that I can figure is that there must be irregularities in the smoothness or straightness of the case sides and top/bottom that confuse the square (and me)even if the box is square by diagonals. It's so confusing.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#2

Re: What to measure to square a case?

Steve jenkins

Equal diagonals will mean square except in one instance. If two opposite sides are one length and the other two opposite sides are a different length the diagonals can be equal but the box sure won't be square.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#3

Here's how I measure to square a case?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Measure each side to insure that opposite sides are exactly the same length. Then measure the diagonals to get the same dimension. If the corners aren't square according to your square, they can usually be corrected when you put the back panel in. Just make sure your back panel is cut perfectly square or else it will mess up everything else.

Lee

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#4

Re: What to measure to square a case?

Barry Irby

This is very three dimensional.

In order for measuring the diagonals to "work" Several conditions must be met. The opposite sides MUST be exactly the same length AND the face of the cabinet MUST be in the same Plane. If the cabinet is twisted this idea won't work. Actually, its the four measurement points must be in the same plane.

Assemble the cabinet laying on its back on a flat surface, making sure the back is in a plane. The sides need to be flat as well. (sometimes, the "flatness" is imaginary, as in the case of Bombe furniture or chests with bow fronts. You have to pick the points you want to lie in a plane.) This is why it all starts with stock prep. Hard to build anything true and square out of poorly prepped stock. I know you know that, but that's where it starts.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#5

Re: What to measure to square a case?

E Snow

You can 'also oil can' a dovetailed case if your cauls are not correctly positioned to place the clamping force where needed, which is only the pins/tails area. This means your cauls have to have gap for pins if you don't cut 'english' style.

Often times it is easier to just clamp below the pins or tails but this will bow the case sides and at time permanently, thinner case sides and drawers especially so.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#6

Re: What to measure to square a case? *LINK*

Bob Lang

Measuring diagonals is so often repeated, one might thing it a requirement for nice work, but in the real world I don't see much value in it. For it to work several things need to happen, as a couple of others have mentioned. Opposite sides need to be the exact same length, and all the parts need to be perfectly straight, true and coplanar. If all those ducks aren't in a row, the measurement doesn't guarantee square corners which is the goal if something (like a door or drawer front) is going in the opening. But it does impress people who don't know any better.

I check all four corners with an accurate square, clamp corner blocks inside the corners, or use Bessey corner clamps to hold things together while the glue dries. If the corners are square, how does measuring the diagonals help? If there is a disagreement between a square in the corner and the measurement, which do you trust?

Bob Lang


Get these and get back to work

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#7

clamping a dovetailed case

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I usually don't. Seems that if I put clamps on a case that has self-squared by the dovetailed joinery the clamps invariable pull the case out of square. However, I so far have never done a case where the dovetails are exposed in the finished case. At least my dovetails close up tighter when clamped and hence "look better" in the end if they had been clamped. But since looks is not an issue I do the following:

Apply glue, tap the case together. Sequentially apply a clamp at each dovetail or group of dovetails to pull the joint closed. Remove clamp(s) when all the parts have been pulled together as much as they naturally will go together and let he glue dry. The result is usually hair-line gaps at some dovetails which I presume will have no effect on strength. Strength and square is all I usually care about.

I cut dovetails so that they wind up flush, never with pins proud. On a drawer I make the drawer to just fit the opening , then plane to get desired clearance which removes ugly glue smudges, and brightens up the exposed end grain.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#8

If you don't go to house sales...

Gary Smyth

you're missing out. Only two sales this past summer. Eight Bessey corner clamps at $4 each. My guess is the seller didn't think they could get $5. Six Rockler corner set up angles $1 each and Four Jevon's Tool Co, aluminum corner braces 4 for $5. All are perfect with a good drafting triangle check. If you know what you are looking at there are some pretty good things out there.


Re: What to measure to square a case?

#9

After some thought, a rebuttal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The task at hand- assembling a box-like furniture component.

Various requirements were enumerated for the "measuring diagonals" approach to work to result in a square box. For example, opposite sides must be equal length. Are not these same requirements essential for all four corners to be 90 degrees, or any other means of ensuring the box is square?

As I thought about the situation it would take a fortuitous combination of mis-cut box sides for a box to appear square by diagonals but in fact not have 90 degree corners.

$200 (8) of Bessy clamps is not a solution that appeals to my frugal nature. I am assembling case boxes with traditional dovetail and housed dovetail construction and don't leave the box clamped for glue cure once the joints have been pulled up by mallet or clamp.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#10

Re: After some thought, a rebuttal

Bob Lang

My point is that measuring diagonals is a fussy ritual that doesn't add much value to the task at hand and can be misleading. The goals (perfect parts and perfect corners) are the same no matter what method you use to prove things. If one of four pieces is a little short you can assemble a trapezoid with equal diagonal measurements. If diagonal measurements is your proof of square you'll move forward with that, believing everything is fine until you try to put a square door or drawer front into the opening. If you check with a square, or clamp anything square in the corner you will quickly see that something is amiss.

As to the Bessey clamps, I'm frugal in nature but I'm very happy I have these. I own two, purchased about 25 years ago. My amortized cost is about $2/year and they have saved me far more than that in time in the first few weeks I owned them. There are a bunch of low cost/no cost alternatives; sometimes I use spring clamps to hold a speed square in the corner, or a thick L-shaped block (two thicknesses of particleboard, plywood or MDF held in position with F-style clamps) or a small block with a square corner. Most of the time, something square clamped in diagonally opposite corners keeps the assembly from wracking out of square until the glue dries.

Bob Lang

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#11

Re: After some thought, a rebuttal

Sgian Dubh

"My point is that measuring diagonals is a fussy ritual that doesn't add much value to the task at hand and can be misleading."

Hi Bob, I have to admit I don't fully agree with you. Checking diagonals is a valuable aid to checking for squareness I find. In the case of smaller pieces I do think you have a fair point, and using a square in a corner or two is often all that's needed.

However, perhaps it's because I've worked on many large carcasses over the years, I find the old diagonal test invaluable. Naturally, when undertaking this test I assume the pairs of sides are of equal length (they always are because I make sure they are!) My most common method is to use two sticks, neither of which is long enough to span the length on their own, but held together they do. Span across one diagonal, grip firmly to avoid slippage, lift the pair of sticks out, and span across the other diagonal to see if the distance is the same. If not, adjust the carcass as necessary until the diagonals match. I guess here I'm talking about diagonals measuring anywhere from about 4 feet upwards, say 8 or 10 feet or more - such carcasses do exist!

The pair of sticks method comes in very handy if there are several carcasses or boxes the same. Get one carcass set up right, tape the sticks together after spanning between diagonals of the same length, and use this measurement to check all the other identical items. Slainte.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#12

Re: After some thought, a rebuttal

Bob Lang

I probably should have qualified my response a bit more, and included the phrase "with pieces the size of a typical kitchen cabinet or less". When you're making pieces larger than that, and as you point out really big pieces, your argument (and especially your method) is correct.

It's one of my pet peeves that we see this all the time with the implication that somehow it is magic, when in reality it is one of several tools available and there are plenty of opportunities for one bad link in the chain to leave bad results. In most of the videos I see promoting measuring diagonals a tape measure is used, the hook end haphazardly jammed into a corner, and the tape sags and twists as it crosses the void to the opposite corner. Then the guy in the video squints at the tape for a few seconds and says "that's about right" and moves on.

If this method has any merit, the measurement needs to be better than that. Using two pointy sticks is a great way to do it.

Bob Lang

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#13

I do like the tape

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought a metric tape. It comes in handy when I need to divide a measurement by 2, or 3 etc. I have no idea how much 27 7/8 is divided by 3 :)

I use it for diagonals too. Somehow for me 837 mm is easier to read and remember than what ever this is in inches. I have no trouble spanning it taunt across any case I have made. You are correct that it needs to be engaged reproducibly and I spend what ever effort is necessary to ensure reproducible orientation on the corners.

I have experienced a lot of problem with squares. A large one doesn't fit in any space of a chest of drawers filled with drawer dividers and runners. A small one isn't very sensitive and in my experience every drawer opening provides a different answer. Slidy sticks don't work either in a case full of dividers. .

Any cup or bow in the case side drives one nuts figuring out if the case is square or not with a square. Especially a problem for thin drawer sides that seem to become less than perfectly flat in the course of getting them made and fitted. One could make the argument that a bowed side would effectively shorten the length of the piece and thereby throw off the diagonal measurement, but this shortening is insignificant if it is little enough to not compromise the box.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#14

Regarding drawers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Do others measure drawers the same way they measure a carcase?

I dry fit drawers without measuring diagonals or using a square - a little tight is good, just as long as they go into their recess. Then glue up and slide back in to dry. Once dry I fine tune the drawer.

Square does not count here. What counts is that they fit the drawer recess.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#15

You seem oddly obsessed with measuring stuff

Mark Hennebury

You don't need to measure anything...ever;

cut a disposable draw bottom from a piece of plywood, joint one edge, rip it to a tight fit in the width of the drawer groove, square one end, nip off the corners to prevent it getting glued in, shove it in the drawer grove after glue-up and push/ clamp it tight to the drawer front. it will automatically square the drawer, and all of your drawers will then be identical.

Mark Hennebury

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#16

"Oddly" "Obsessed"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jeez, two adjectives descriptive of woodworkers in general in the same sentence.

Why am I not insulted?

I have a dear friend who has a sizable box of tape rules from 6' to 200'. There must be 60 or more, some in the original blister packs, in that box. So far, he's resisting our suggestion for some kind of therapy.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#17

Re: "Oddly" "Obsessed"

Mark Hennebury

I am sure that we all resemble that to some degree.

Maybe your dear friend is trying to save mankind from the insanity of measuring by removing the evil tape measure from the marketplace and banishing them to eternal imprisonment in the box.

I, for one think he is one the right track. It is the rest of the world that needs therapy.

Mark Hennebury

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#18

Re: After some thought, a rebuttal

TomD

One thing you might try with a CD case or piece of cut stock, is triming the point off your square. It sometime happens the point gets you in trouble. Other obvious possibility is bent wood, not made really square by hand cleaning all the parts. Snipe could give you a corner to corner pass, but square to the square it isn't.

One thing to do is consider what you really want to know. Are you fitting a drawer inside, or is it open. There may be cases where you don't really care that everything shows up perfect at this stage of assembly, for instance snipe could be corrected in final clean-up of exterior, but would be nasty to build into a drawer house.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#19

Re: Regarding drawers

TomD

It is going to count if the recess is square. :)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I think the thing is there are lots of points along the road. Just grabbing one of them will not give you a system. You develop a series of checks or processes along the way, and they end up working. To compare them would develop millions of permutations.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#20

I'm doing the same thing for humanity...

Grant in Iowa

Except I do this with BBQ and smoked meats. Consider it my contribution to mankind.

Come to think of it, I also try to remove all supplies of good craft beer, tools on sale, and resort space in the Mayan Riviera. Homeless and unwanted Cherry logs also get removed.

I regret that I have but one life to give...

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#21

Re: Regarding drawers

Bob Lang

"Square does not count here. What counts is that they fit the drawer recess."

There are numerous ways to approach woodworking. My thinking is to make good parts; the intended size with straight edges and square corners. Then put those parts together into square assemblies.

I fuss the most in the early stages so I don't need to fuss later on. That makes things predictable, repeatable and enjoyable. If things go awry along the way, a good fit will trump perfectly square, but to go into it thinking "square doesn't count" is throwing away your reference before you start. Kind of like tossing your map out the window so you can enjoy the journey.

Bob Lang

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#22

Re: Regarding drawers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bob, I agree that it is important to fuss all one can with the cabinet as the build progresses, and ensure it is as square as possible. The cabinet then should act as a jig to ensure that the drawer is square as well. Recall I wrote the drawer should fit tightly. If it does, then it must be square. All that counts is that the drawer fits snugly and travels without racking.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#23

Re: What to measure to square a case?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you have good stock preparation, equal diagonals will ensure a square carcass. It is helpful to use this test for a six inch box or a 6 foot box. If the stock is poorly prepared, such as boards in wind, dimensions uneven, corners not square, then having equal diagonals or using $2 clamps or $200 clamps will not help.

Re: What to measure to square a case?

#24

Indeed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sometimes in spite of our best effort the result is not perfect, though one should strive for perfect when it comes to square. As you say, a drawer fit to its opening can compensate for the occasional less than perfect.