I'm a bit confused. My can of boiled linseed oil has dire warnings about spontaneous combustion of cloth(s) saturated with boiled linseed oil. The can says to let soaked wiping rags air out but nothing about how long, how to let it "dry", if it can be placed in a refuse container and when. There is nothing about surrounding temperature, soaking in water, or anything leading to sure prevention of fire. In winter weather can I simply take saturated materials outside, lay flat, for a day or two before disposing? My refuse containers are plastic and not air tight. What do I need to be concerned about? I need no surprises.
By the way, local VFD says to put it into a air tight container, but I cannot dispose of it in normal trash.
Its hard to say because curing time can vary so widely with conditions and even brand of BLO. You can safely dispose of the rags when they have stiffened and squeezing one does not yield oil on your fingers. But if it's cold and damp, that could take several days at least if you are using a brand like Tried and True.
I've found that warm, dry conditions speed drying, as does sunlight - not sure if that is the heat or the UV though. At 7000' we get plenty of both.
I, like everyone else, has heard and read those warnings forever but I was skeptical. During my 'MSgt' days, I had the additional duty of being the unit safety NCO and I gave the warning to the shop guys too but then I decided to test it out. The methodology involved a chart recorder and a precisely-calibrated thermocouple, a fireproof (but open) container, a wad of rag, and enough BLO to saturate it. I can say that in my tests I never got any temperature rise beyond normal random deviation and certainly a few hundred degrees short of combustion. I tried the same test with the high-oil varnish which the shop used frequently with the same results. I guess that there might be some way to light a fire with BLO, but I couldn't verify it in my test. YMMV, of course.
I have a couple of feet of cord tied between a couple of convenient objects outdoors, and a stock of clothespins (yes you can still buy them in the grocery store).
Rather than take a chance, I just pin up any rag that has anything that might conceivably combust. When the rags are dry and stiff, I toss them into the nearby trash bin.
The airtight containers are a questionable solution - will the rags ever dry in those?
No doubt if one had a pile of oil soaked rags such that substantial heat was produced and the volume insulated, the heat generated in the assembly could get hot. But for a small amount of rag the reaction is slow, hence the rate of heat production is slow and the heat loss to air is high unless insulated somehow.
But to be safe, put the rag on the patio paver and ignite it. Or put it in a zip lock with some water and toss anywhere. Or seal in a discarded paint can.....etc.
If in Eastern TN toss out a car window about 2 miles from any McDonalds. It will not be noticed among the burger wraps. Alternatively stuff in a beer can and toss anywhere.
Gary, I think your approach is fine. About 25 years ago, I was using Watco on everything. One day I threw a bunch of soaked rags into a 5-gallon bucket and took the bucket to the edge of my yard and under a shed. While I don't recall the exact time frame, later I happened to glance down to the bucket and LOTS of smoke was issuing from the bucket. I must have broke the record for the 100-yard dash (I was a lot younger then) getting to the bucket and dumping water on it. So, as Bill alluded to, my takeaway is not to bunch your rags together. Since then, I lay my finishing rags out separately to dry, usually outside, and haven't had a problem. Jim
Simply soak them well in water and put in a plastig bag and throw in the trash. If the rags are small, I usually put them into the disposable gloves I wear, filll one up with the rag and water and put it in the other one.
Any oxidation reactions will be quenched by the water.
I too heard the warnings repeated constantly, but never knew if this was just idle safety talk persisting through the years, or actual caution to be heeded. One day, I was in my garage doing what I do best - "puttering". I kept hearing a high pitched noise I couldn't pinpoint, and it bugged me. I went out in the middle of the street and determined it was coming from the neighbor's house kitty corner across the street. As I walked closer, I heard the dog was barking too. Turns out it was their smoke alarm going off with the doors closed. Just then the owners showed up and next thing I knew, so did the fire truck. Turns out they were refinishing a kitchen table and had left the oil soaked rags laying on the table and ran some errands for a few hours. They had to have Service Master come in to do a thorough cleaning due to the smoke damage.
I now lay any rags with drying oil (like Watco) flat on the concrete floor or outside in the gravel in a single layer. Heck, I even do that with stain soaked rags now too, just in case. When stiff, toss them in the trash. Unlike John and Bill, my experience indicates the caution is valid.
Bill and Jesper mentioned putting oil-soaked rags in a ziplock bag with water and discarding them in the trash. I have been doing that for years, except I don't add water. I started putting my oily finishing rags in a ziplock sandwich bag after I applied the oil finish so they would stay soft and I could use them again the next day. I found that if I left them in the bag for more than 3 or 4 days, they cured slowly and eventually became rock hard. At that point I could toss them in the trash without worrying about combustion. Just to make sure I wasn't playing with fire, so to speak, I checked the bags intermittently during several finishing operations and found they never got even warm to the touch. The curing process for drying oils is an exothermic chemical reaction. The heat released builds up when the curing rags are left wadded up in a confined space and can quickly reach the kindling temperature. When that happens, the rags ignite - a spontaneous combustion. The ziplock bag limits the amount if air/ oxygen that gets to the oily rags and retards the curing process. Whatever heat is released is released slowly and the temperature of the curing rags never reaches the kindling temperature. Moreover, not enough oxygen gets through the plastic to support combustion, so the rags won't catch on fire. I've been using this method for years to keep my finish rags useable for several applications. When I'm done, I just leave them in the zip lock bag until they get hard and toss them. Never had an issue with combustion.
Back in the sixties I worked for the largest mink ranch in the country, and during the pelting season, they had a lot of rags saturated with mink fat, used during processing up to a hundred thousand pelts a year. A truck would pick up a large load of greasy rags and haul them off to a laundry. One night, lo and behold, the truck burned up during the night That was an eye opener.
Years ago there was a case where the guy threw the rags outside. They landed on his deck and it later caught fire.
The warnings are valid!
I have an old shop-vac type drum container with lid. Inside I have a large coffee can half-filled with water and stick all my finishing rags in it. When can is filled it goes out in the garbage. We drink enough coffee that we always have plenty of empty cans.
Rags wet with finish, or rags and finish in a container with water are hazardous waste, the legal disposal of which is complicated and expensive. Oil soaked rags which have dried stiff are OK to trash. You can throw away a piece of finished wood, so you can throw away a finished rag as well. While it is true that you are unlikely to be caught illegally dumping finishing rags, the legal option is simple: dry your rags first. No legal exposure, and no ethical compromise.
Over the years of working with others in the shop, I've found there are a lot of people that don't know about this hazard, and don't have a lick of sense in other respects. One friend comes to mind. We were doing a small project for him. I don't recall what it was, but it was a small object. While I worked on another piece I suggested he start finishing one small part. Rather that cutting a handkerchief size rag, he wadded up a whole shirt, and poured out about half a can of stain or wipe on poly.
While it was too late to stop him and explain how wasteful that was, since the rest of the rag would be absorbing the finish away faster than he could get it onto the wood. After he left, I found it waded up and thrown into a big trash can full of wood scraps. Yes, he got a talking-to the next day.
The point of the story, is SIZE MATTERS. A small rag that will make a nice wad, laid out flat or hung over the lip of a container isn't much of a hazard, while a big pile of oily stuff is.
I toss them into the wood stove, and just go ahead and burn them.
Friend left a rag soaked in BLO in his garage. The fire marshal said the fire was caused by spontaneous combustion. I don't know beyond that, but I take no chances with solvent/petroleum based products. Alcohol and lacquer thinner are not a problem for me. I put the rags in a bucket of water and put them in the trash with the can on the curb.
... are particularly dangerous. When Watco first came out there were many fires caused by the rags igniting. Oil/varnishes like Watco contain a drying agent that more rapidly heats up than pure linseed oil or boiled linseed oil.
In a woodworking club I belonged to we tested raw linseed oil, boiled linseed oil, Watco and the ubiquitous Minwax Tung Oil which contains no tung oil but is linseed oil based. We wetted rags with each product, wadded them up and put them into large metal coffee cans. We then inserted the metal probe of meat oven thermometers and tracked the heat build up.
All products generated heat. The Watco was the fastest to smoke followed by Minwax Tung Oil Finish, and then boiled linseed oil. The pure linseed oil. never smoked but it too generated heat.
As I recall, Watco was involved with a number of suits back in the "olden days." Watco has changed their product a number of times since it's inception so I don't know if the same tests would give similar result.
I bought a quart of my usual finish, Minwax semigloss poly recently. When I opened it and decanted it into smaller units in glass containers, I was dismayed to note it's now a pale yellow/green color, not the amber shade it's been since forever. It was also noticeably thinner than I was used to. I checked the label to see what might be up but there was nothing of note except for a brand-new warning about spontaneous combustion. I checked an older can of gloss Minwax and there is no warning. Apparently the formula has changed as well as it's label. However, the new product produces the same results as the old although it gets less mileage in terms of coverage and doesn't darken the wood as much.
Spontanious combustion starts when heat is generated, and insulated, thus allowed to rise. Wadded rags hold in heat.
Done with a rag? Lay it out flat on the floor or hang it up to dry over a wire or over the edge of a trash can (my trick). It'll dry without the insuating effects of the rag to keep the heat in. Never had an issue, nor felt ANY heat in my rags this way. Once dry, they are safe to throw away.
This trick holds true when ANY sort of evaporative solvent (varnish, paint, thinners, oil, gasoline, linseed oil, etc) are contained in the rag.
Dry, there is no issue. If there were, your table would burst into flames.
...and drape it over the edge of my trash can overnight, then discard with the trash when dry. Alternatively, in heating season, toss it in the woodstove.
Been doing it this way for over 40 years.
Ellis
PS, and disclaimer: This question falls into the category of "don't believe everything you read on a public forum." There are official instructions out there for disposing of oily rags, and only those are deemed reliable. Our personal approaches may work for us, but should be taken with a grain of salt by others. WoodCentral, nor individual posters, assume any liability for your choices in this matter and any other safety- or regulatory-related issues.
The shop I work at has an OSHA-approved dedicated metal container for rags. The pedal-activated lid seals almost tightly but enough air leaks in and out that after a period of time the rags end up stiff and dry. If a large enough mass of oily rags were to combust spontaneously the metal would contain the fire and it would go out for lack of oxygen.
Spreading rags out is effective for preventing spontaneous combustion but it does have the risk of a spark starting a fire.
I think the biggest danger is that so many people are unaware of the risk in the first place. A shop I worked at years ago had a fire caused by a low-paid helper who did a good enough job on the finishing but just didn't know how to dispose of rags.
The underlying thing here is that the "overscare" (my words, others may not agree) is certainly effective in making sure we're all aware of the danger.
Ellis's solution of burning the rags is a good one - if it's available or viable. It certainly eliminates the combustible material.
I have used oil finishes for forty plus years and always dispose of the rags by laying flat outside overnight, i have never had a problem myself but, many years ago i was in a very expensive ( Heliport outside) newly constructed home to discuss making several furniture pieces with the owner, when a pile of rags sitting on the newly oiled Brazilian Rosewood floor started smoking and a frantic worker ran across the room grabbed up the pile of smoking rags sprinted to the door, swung it open and threw them out into the snow.
Thinking about what could have happened has stayed with me. Just that single forgetful moment, had they packed up and gone home leaving those rags on the floor that entire house would have burned.
I took that as proof positive that it can happen! and ever since then i have been careful about disposing of oily rags.
This is one area where i would err on the side of safety.
The heat generated will depend on the temperature, and the details of the varnish/oil formulation (amount of reactive groups and catalyst activity), and oxygen concentration. We have no information about the formulation to guide us. If the heat lost by convection is less than the heat generated the reaction rate will increase with time and the temperature will therefore increase with time.
Heat lost will depend on temperature difference between rags and air, and surface area exposed.
Note that the only variable we have control over is surface area, and oxygen if we seal in a can. Which leads to all the sound recommendations offered by all- spread out the rags to "dry" or seal in a metal can.
Had a friend with a machine shop whose insurance "inspector" told him they wanted his used oil rags put in water. Now, I know that machine and cutting oils are not "drying" oils and should not involve any polymerization (the process that creates the heat) but the guy was insistent that the procedure be followed. Since my friend got burned out of a shop, he wasn't taking any chances with his insurance coverage.
I have to wonder whether there's some chemical process involving the rag fibers, metal particles and such, and the oils that actually created some danger of S-C.
Some years ago I was working on a project using blue shop towels and BLO. That evening I spread them on the concrete floor to dry. I would usually leave them until they stiffened up when I would put them out for the trash. The next morning was trash day and I had enough in the shop to take out. As I gathered the trash I also added the shop towels that were not yet fully cured.
Later that day...I was napping on the couch and awoke to someone knocking on the door. A neighbor was driving by and stopped because my garbage can was on fire. When I got out there the only thing left was the metal axle for the wheels.... everything else was gone... including my mailbox, mail and half the mailbox post.