Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Which Vise for Face Vise

Posts

Which Vise for Face Vise

#1

Which Vise for Face Vise

Brad Chenoweth

I'm finally building an honest-to goodness workbench in my garage shop. No more plywood-on sawhorses contraptions! It's going to be a general-purpose bench (a dedicated hand tool bench is down the road). I want to install a face vise on the left front corner. I'm looking at the Jorgensen from Lee Valley and the Milwaukee from Joel (I like the ideas of buying American). I've looked at the Wilton as well, but I think the swiveling jaw would be a pain most of the time. Besides, I know Sir William came up with a shop-built solution to do the same thing with a regular vise. I'm also considering the face vise hardware kit from Lee Valley.

Anyone have a favorite brand to recommend? Likes and dislikes?

Brad, enjoying the warmer weather (for now)in Northeast Ohio

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#2

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

Dick Coers

I have an Abernathy rapid action vise on the front of mine. It's now sold as a Jorgensen 41012.

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#3

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

Hank Knight

There's an interesting bench thread going over on the Hand Tools forum. Check it out.

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#4

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

John McGaw

I have a cheap non-swiveling Wilton on the left end of the bench and an antique Columbia at the other. The Columbia, at least 100 years old, was given to me by a knife maker I made some exotic scale sets for. I only had to clean the vise and lubricate it to make it work. I find that I use the Columbia as often as not -- it just has a satisfying feel to it.

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#5

JL

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

JL

I have two vises. I have the twin screw vise from Lee Valley for the end of my bench. It has 2" (nominal) faces. I have them drilled for dog holes.

It will hold quite a few things - including boards flat on the bench.

I have an 8" or so quick release vise for the side of my bench.

I usually use the twin screw for most of my work.

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#6

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Brad

I would not get too obsessional about this one at this stage.

There are many different types of woodworking, and there are different types of vises. Trying to accommodate for all possibilities is going to water down what you will have. It took me 20 years to decide what my priorities would be in a bench and vises.

My advice is to start with something that is basic and reliable, and be prepared to change when you are ready to do so. For example, try and get hold of an old Record #52 1/2, alternatively one of the modern reproductions.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#7

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

Brad Chenoweth

Hi Derek and All,

Thanks for the input, everyone. Derek, I promise not to obsess:>). I'll probably pick up a vintage used vise for now. I can always upgrade later. The old Columbians are fairly common around here, probably because they were built in Cleveland.

By the way, this isn't really a bench in the truest sense, just a top on some shop-built cabinets. It will serve my purposes well for now, I think. Maybe something better as my needs/wants change.

Brad

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#8

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

bob murphy

I have had an Emmert pattern makers vise for many years and am well pleased with it. They are now rather 'pricey' but the new clones are more reasonable and have a quick release feature.

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

#9

Re: Which Vise for Face Vise

Gary Smyth

I bought my vises as new old stock when a woodworking store was folding. Two Record #52 (7") on one end of a 30" wide bench, and a Record #52 1/2 (9") on the face. I use them all the time -- sometimes together and sometimes individually for various types of work. I use the end twins more than the face vise by the way. All have quick release and I would remind that much time will be saved to make sure the whatever vise you do choose has the quick release feature. The vise screw ought to be 3/4" or over or you will wish you bought one with that minimum diameter the first time on your next one.