For a talk to 4th graders I'm curious as to why some woods produce more heat as firewood than others. Is it simply a question of wood density? And if so, why are some woods more dense than others? Are the cell walls different, or closer together? Don't recall seeing this addressed in Hoadley's wonderful "Understanding Wood" book.
Density is correct, pound for pound all wood produces the same BTU, hence: one pound of hickory maybe X size, a pound of cottonwood will be XXX size.
You would think slower growing trees are more dense, not always the case. Gotta be genetics of the different types of trees is why the wood is more dense. Enjoy and good luck...As a forester, gave class presentation many time, usually enjoyed...
I was raised with the same idea that BTU per pound was fairly constant. A bit of trivia though, allegedly back in the steam engine days the fireman would put in more lighter wood at a faster rate when he needed more steam, because the lighter woods often burned faster and hotter.
BTU from a pound of wood is well documented. Guess there are exceptions in every case. Have never seen the BTU values of lighter wood or AKA pitch pine or fatwood.
I recall when we first moved to the county, my wife and myself were raised in the city. I was at work and had several large chunks of pitch pine near the firewood pile that had not been busted up into smaller pieces. Wife puts a log of pitch pine about the size of a normal man thigh into the heater. SMH... She didn't know. Anyway, she calls me and said the heater was making a huffing sound and black smoke was pouring out of the chimney. Told her to close off the air to the heater and grab our new baby and get outside. Called the FD, and rushed home. Log was burned up by the time I got there, 20 minutes or so...LOL we were lucky.
cells are different size and for ring porous woods the ratio of spring wood to late wood makes a difference. The spring wood is way more porous. I have seen slow growth white oak as light as walnut.
The composition of wood is basically identical no matter the species. So pound for pound on a dry bases, they all yield the same heat.
I believe the BTU/weight equivalence is for wood of equal moisture content. I saw a calculation once of the "wasted" energy needed to convert the water in green oak to steam. 4th graders might like to hear about that.
Yep, All Rosewood makes good kindling. I've tried them all. Ha
And if you just get it started then blow out the flame, it makes wonderful smelling incense. Every year for my first fire of the season, I gather up a few scraps from as many projects as I can find, as sort of a celebration.
I love sitting around a campfire with friends telling stories. I like to tell young people that it soothes the savage beast within. ha. I believe there is something inherited in all of us that likes being around a wood fire. When you think about it, all our long chain of ancestors from the beginning, cooked and warmed themselves around wood fires.
As another little side note about moisture, is that I believe it is the reason some woods pop while they burn. And when it pops, you better watch out, because a little ember is being launched out of the fire with each little mini-explosion.
For many years, my nephew and I liked to take a Winter backpack trip up in the Ozarks. All of his school years, he worked in several outdoor stores, so he was always getting the newest coolest gadgets. One year, we hiked down to the Buffalo River along an old roadbed that years earlier I had driven many times before it was closed. We went out over the Goat Trail Bluff, then on down to Granny Henderson's old home-place. A photographer friend of mine, Mat Bradley took a pic of her carrying two buckets of water on a yoke up for her cattle, back in the sixties. Her cabin is still there, but the pastures are grown up mostly with cedars.
It had been raining for at least a week before our hike, but a really cold wind followed and was blowing like stink. We made camp near there. I hadn't been down there in probably 30 years, and didn't realize how popular a destination it had become. It's always my job to find good wood and build a fire. Because of the heavy use, I had to hike about 1/2 mile to find anything that looked like it would burn.
By the time I got back with enough wood to grill the two salmon fillets, it was past dark, about 20º, with at least a 20 mph wind out of the N. This was the hardest I've ever had to work for a badly needed fire, and I was having a hard time even getting it started. I had a little single burner propane stove that I thought I would use, but it wouldn't light. He and a pump up gas stove, with a clogged stem. I finally found a few paper towels in my pack that got the kindling started.
We FINALLY managed to get a good fire to cook our delicious meal, when he pulled out his latest gadget. It was a cool little light frame which turned his thermal rest mattress into a lazy-boy recliner. I have to say, as stiff as I've always been, I was jealous. Well,,,,,,,, until a cedar spark popped and burned a hole in it. Oh, The despair he felt. This was also his bed mattress. I let him franticly search his pack for a patch kit, thinking I could fix it with one I knew I had in mine. When he was finished looking, I reassured him that I had one, but when i found it, all the glue had set up in the little tube. So now the reality really hit again.
Lucky for him that I was along. I still carry my old closed cell mat wrapped around my Thermacell, to use for campfire seat, and extra padding under the Tcell. It has got lots of melt holes in it, and probably got a few more that night, that is, until I made a cool discovery.
Because it was so cold, and blowing wind, we really wanted to get in close to the fire, but because the cedar was so wet, it was REALLY shooting a lot of sparks out, keeping us back too far to do us much good.
As I was laying off to one side, watching the water being forced out of the end grain, and seeing little geysers of steam shoot out of cracks, as well as trying to study the embers popping out, something dawned on me. High heat makes normally strong wood brash, which means it is weaker, and prone to failing abruptly without bending. So what I realized was happening, is there were small zones where the moisture couldn't move along the grain fast enough, and not close exit through splits to relieve the pressure, so a steam pocket explodes under a little plate of burning wood, sending it more or less perpendicular to it's location on the wood. This was a eureka moment to discover that little tidbit.
What I did, was to rearrange the fire from a more or less tepee which would shoot out in all directions, to where they were all laying crossways to the wind. Now all the sparks went flying either into the wind, or downwind with the smoke. This allowed us to move in very close, without worry about burning a hole in our coats, or maybe loosing an eye.
Now, confident and much cozier as we laid there watching the fire doing all it's pyrotechnics, I recalled reading the Jack London chilling short, "To Build A Fire", where the protagonist froze to death, and considered killing his dog to get inside of. I gave a short synopsis to Kev and his chocolate lab Sadie. I think she liked the outcome, since we weren't that desperate, and she got to sleep in the tent between us.
Later a pack of Coyotes sang for us from about 100' away. Sadie sat up and only did one low growl from deep down, and hushed when I told her to. I was glad, since I was the one between her and them, just in case that growl meant something like "Bring it On" in dog. ha
The point of sharing this story, is that it could save someone from dying from hypothermia. When you or someone you are with and trying to save is needing to be dried and warmed to stay alive, being reticent from fear of getting burned isn't a good option to have to deal with.
Hoadley starts one of his chapters with a picture of green red pine being squeezed in a metal vise. Glass beaker below is catching the stream of sap from the wood. Amazing!
You can tell them the old saw about how wood warms you twice - once when you cut it and once when you burn it.
Another story line is explaining how tree leaves "capture" sunshine and store it in the wood. When the wood burns, the light and heat is the released sunshine.
DizD (who just got "volunteered" for a third grade career day program for a granddaughter.)
I have a friend who is the smartest guy in the room. Really, He literally has about 11 masters degrees and two PHD's. He can talk for hours on nearly anything or nothing. Once, when he came by for a visit, my kids in a desperate attempt to avoid going to bed asked him why fire was yellow? They figured that would be good for an hour or more. He said, "You know how the tree stands out in the sunshine?" Yep, "That yellow is the sunshine coming back out."
On a winter camping trip in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness in northern Minnesota we too wondered what the flame colors 'were'. Smoke...yup, gotcha...solids in there which become soot. But, we wondered, if we could put the flames in a container what would we have.
One of the guys on the trip is a chemist. After listening to the lot of us guess he chuckled and told us what flames are. Various gases and heat in various temperatures. Combined, they give the colors.
Here's a chart showing the BTU's in a species *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
I *think* there's more to it than just specific gravity or density. Each tree species, and even where it grows regionally as well as locally would likely have an effect on its heat output.
One example is fatwood, and tropicals that have oils in them such as rosewood. Density sure plays a major role in it, and is likely enough information for most cases. That said, the chemical makeup of the particular log has a hand in determining BTU available in a given log.
One time I had a fire going and had gone to the wood bin (inside in our mudroom) for another log. I noticed a piece of cherry that had several carpenter ants emerging from a hole in the end. I quickly decided it needed to go on the fire. As the log heated, the remainder of the small colony poured out of the hole. Each one soon popped like popcorn. No puffy kernel resulted, however. They did burn readily once popped.
A nod to the web site, Chimneysweeponline. A great resource for those burning wood for heat. Note the lengthy explanation of how they arrive at the numbers on the chart is below the chart itself.