Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

wood choice for drawer material

Posts

wood choice for drawer material

#1

wood choice for drawer material

cameron

I've just finished making the first of several carcasses for some built-ins. I have made >40 drawers over the past several years for other cabinetry and ~95% of them are made of maple with the few others being cherry (started doing this based on a belief that the maple would be a very resilient choice for the drawer frames, something that I often see failing in old furniture..., not sure if this is true or not but bought a pile of maple and got in the habit) My maple pile has gotten down to some mostly narrow boards so to continue I'm going to either have to glue some together to get the width I need, buy more maple or change to a different species. The maple looks nice but is tough on my router bits.

What do you guys prefer to use for drawer frames (I typically make a box and then add an inset front to my mostly shaker pieces)? I've got a pile of poplar which is obviously easy to mill but I fear may be too soft (although I do use accuride slides so there is minimal friction on the frames.) I've seen people use plywood, I'm not sure I'd like the look but is this a good option? Other suggestions?

Thanks

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#2

Re: wood choice for drawer material

Dick Coers

I'm a little confused since you are bouncing back and forth between frame and drawer stock. My go to on drawer stock is soft maple. Lighter color, no greens and purples like poplar. It usually machines nicer, less fuzz. Another option for soft wood drawer sides is to glue on a thin hard maple wear surface on the bottom edge. I made some quick wardrobes with 1/2" plywood drawers for the kids when they were little. I used biscuits for the joinery. They are both still in use, 26 years latter. Not a single incident with those drawers. Including the teen years! I'd stick with hard maple for the wood runners inside the case.

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#3

Re: wood choice for drawer material

cameron

Sorry about that, I meant the frame of the drawer (should have said drawer stock/sides)

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#4

Re: wood choice for drawer material

Barry Irby

I think the classic choice is to make the box out of something softer than what ever it slides on so that the wear will occur on the drawer. Easier to repair the drawer many years alter that to make repairs inside the carcass of the piece.

OTOH, if you are using drawer slides and there is no wood on wood friction, it may not matter. Does whatever you are using prevent the wood from touching each other?

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#5

Re: wood choice for drawer material

cameron

Yes, There's no wood to wood contact as I'm using the Accuride full extension metal slides. The wear should just come from putting things in the drawers.

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#6

Ellis Walentine

Side material

Ellis Walentine

I have a few favorites, including yellow cedar (sometimes marketed as Pacific Coast cypress), quartersawn sycamore (cool ray patterns, if appearance matters), and sassafras (preferably quartered). If the drawers are side-hung, I don't see why softwood wouldn't work.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#7

Some points to consider

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You have avoided poplar because you have seen failures in old (presume you mean very old like in Period Furniture) drawers. For your purposes this is an irrelevant observation.

It is a good bet that cabinet makers used what was best to use in 1750. Period Furniture makers reproducing these antique pieces use what was then used- white pine in the north, poplar in the middle and yellow pine in the south. These reproductions cost thousands of dollars so they aren't making these choices to cut cost.

It is trivial to repair a worn drawer and near impossible to repair a worn drawer divider. For a traditional drawer you want the drawer to be the softer material that wears. Personally I use poplar sides and maple runners for traditional drawers.

But you aren't making traditional drawers, so none of these considerations are relevant. Your only meaningful requirement is that the drawer side hold screws. Any wood will outlive the metal slide unless the screws fail. Find some criteria other than perceived durability to make your choice- looks ,cost, availability etc.

I don't see any wear in my 25 year old poplar kitchen drawers hung off Accuride slides. I chose poplar because it cost less than alternatives and it holds screws adequately. Looks was not a consideration.

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#8

Re: wood choice for drawer material

Johanna Johanson

Since these are built-ins with metal slides, why not use Baltic birch? You are going to add a front, so only the top of the drawer will show that it is plywood. I have used it quite a bit for "utility" drawers with metal slides.

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#9

Re: wood choice for drawer material

jgdillon

Cameron, in your situation (i.e. Accuride sliders) I think almost anything would work. I would sort through your wood pile and pick something that is thick enough, have enough of, and is wide enough so no excessive glue ups are needed to get the width you need. I have no real favorites and generally pick something from the pile that meets the above criteria and compliments the carcass in color. I've used quartersawn sycamore, oak, and douglas fir, mahogany, poplar, and plywood (with a hardwood cap). All served their purpose. For the drawer bottom, I generally use veneered plywood to avoid issues with wood expansion. In most cases, I construct the drawer to allow removal of the bottom if necessary. Jim

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#10

Re: wood choice for drawer material

Larry

I've been using Baltic birch for over 35 Years

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#11

Re: wood choice for drawer material

Jim O'Connor

I've used mostly poplar but here in our area it is not a plentiful wood. Always has to be shipped in. I like it because it is the easy one to work when making half blind dovetails.

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#12

got some soft maple

cameron

Thanks for the advice everyone, I looked into baltic birch plywood but decided to run out to the mill and grab 100 bf of soft maple instead (didn't want to use up my cherry and the maple will actually come out nicer and much cheaper than plywood at $0.70 bf...) My first time using "soft" maple and I have to say that ~3/4 of the boards seem pretty similar to my hard maple (density, hardness, machining) while the other 1/4 are noticeably different. Will be curious to see if I notice any difference routing dovetails in the stuff... Is this stuff a different species or just a grading output?

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#13

Soft maple is usually red or silver maple

Dick Coers

Red being more dense than silver. You'll see the red maple cut cleaner, the silver a little more fuzzy.

Re: wood choice for drawer material

#14

Re: wood choice for drawer material *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Cameron

I use a lighter (in colour) wood for the sides, tending to find one as plain as possible, that is, minimal figure, as this will best set off the drawer front and dovetails. (This is not relevant to you as my woods are Australian, but the drawer front is dark Jarrah and the sides are light Tasmanian Oak, which is similar to White Oak).

Two points I wanted to make:

1. The sides are best made of quarter sawn boards if they are to run without mechanical aids, such as slides (all mine are like this). Quarter sawn boards with not change shape over time/humidity. Frankly, I cannot see any quality drawers made with other material.

Example ..


If you need, you can make your own quarter sawn boards by re-sawing flat sawn boards and glueing them with the grain.

2. High end drawers tend to be thin-sided in Europe and Australia. The ones I am making are about 9mm thick. This is too thin for a groove, and the reason why they are made with drawer slips. If you go down this route (and it is more work), then the (usually softwood) slips can be lined on the underside with a strip of hardwood. This will ensure that softwood drawer sides have a significantly increased life span.

Example:


Regards from Perth

Derek


Drawer build in current project