A "good" design idea that wasn't
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Period case furniture is usually constructed with a false top dovetailed into the case top and perhaps bottom as shown in Picture 1. I thought I had a better idea.
I approach things with the attitude that anything can be improved. While it might be presumptuous to think I can improve on furniture building procedures time tested for centuries one must consider that in modern times we have access to different tools, different materials, and most of us work part time at woodworking, not full time. A different situation could lead to a different result. Not in this case.
PIC 2
I thought, why waste the lumber and time to prepare a full false top when three dovetailed strips would do to hold the top together- front, back and middle. Plus the piece would weigh less. What could not be better? Plenty.
One, it takes little extra time to prepare the panel for the full top. Two, there are 6 dovetails in the 3 strips and only 5 in the full top. And the full top accommodates large dovetails that are much easier to execute, at least the way I do them. Finally, the full top reliably squares the case.
The practice I got dovetailing the wasted strips can be applied to the drawers 




