Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

A "good" design idea that wasn't

Posts

A "good" design idea that wasn't

#1

A "good" design idea that wasn't

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Period case furniture is usually constructed with a false top dovetailed into the case top and perhaps bottom as shown in Picture 1. I thought I had a better idea.


I approach things with the attitude that anything can be improved. While it might be presumptuous to think I can improve on furniture building procedures time tested for centuries one must consider that in modern times we have access to different tools, different materials, and most of us work part time at woodworking, not full time. A different situation could lead to a different result. Not in this case.

PIC 2


I thought, why waste the lumber and time to prepare a full false top when three dovetailed strips would do to hold the top together- front, back and middle. Plus the piece would weigh less. What could not be better? Plenty.

One, it takes little extra time to prepare the panel for the full top. Two, there are 6 dovetails in the 3 strips and only 5 in the full top. And the full top accommodates large dovetails that are much easier to execute, at least the way I do them. Finally, the full top reliably squares the case.

The practice I got dovetailing the wasted strips can be applied to the drawers :)

Re: A "good" design idea that wasn't

#2

Re: A "good" design idea that wasn't

Sgian Dubh

Bill, you could have used just six dovetails in total on those three rails; one at each end glued and screwed in place. The construction form you illustrate is pretty standard, albeit most commonly using joinery much as I've described, rather than the twin dovetails you show in your photograph. See the image below for an example, with a front rail twin dovetailed for some reason I forget now, but probably because of that rail's width.

That would have saved you both sawing and/or routing and chiselling time for the sockets. Your point about a full sub-top adding rigidity and squareness to the carcass is, I think, of minor concern in such a small piece, although in a large carcass your observation carries greater weight. Slainte.


Re: A "good" design idea that wasn't

#3

A dovetail number consideration.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The false top or the wood strips that could be considered an alternative to a false top join the top to the carcass. The only thing holding the top onto the carcass is the glue surface of the dovetails. There must be enough dovetails to hold the top on under whatever circumstances one can imagine the would try to pull the top off, for example moving/lifting the piece by the top.

Re: A "good" design idea that wasn't

#4

Re: A dovetail number consideration.

Sgian Dubh

"There must be enough dovetails to hold the top on under whatever circumstances one can imagine the would try to pull the top off, for example moving/lifting the piece by the top."

True, but that's where the screws inserted through the rail dovetails help. The fact the screws go into end grain isn't ideal I agree, but long screws with a coarse thread can work pretty well. Slainte.