Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

Posts

So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#1

So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

Mike Circo

Soon to be daughter-in-law has asked for a sideboard of sorts so she and my son can store all their coffee equipment, cookbooks and accessories. Open shelves, crossbuck look on the sides, thick top (1½"). The design pictures from the internet were from somebody using homecenter "two-by" lumber. I just can't bring myself to do that.

So. To keep the rustic look, but make it more heirloom quality, and have a durable top, I'm looking for a hardwood solution. Never used hickory before, but in some examples it can be made to look like they expect.

What about your experiences in working, staining and durability of hickory for furniture? Does it stain well? (I've got to match an existing piece) Doe is have true hardwood qualities? Anything I should be warned of?

Thanks.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#2

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

Michael Bush

I haven't posted in years, but since this is something I know a little about I'll pipe up.

Hickory is extremely brittle and will chip out in unpredictable ways. It's possible to use it in a simple design with few if any routed moldings. Hand tools are your friend. The more sawing and the less routing you do, the happier you will be.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#3

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

Yonak

Mike, I have to say it's not often I see the words "rustic" and "heirloom quality" in such close proximity. However, if the style and the wood complement the existing pieces, it should look fine. Strictly my 2¢.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#4

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

Mike Circo

Yeah, "heirloom quality" was the best way to say I couldn't use construction pine like shown in the examples. I wanted it to be useful by my son without having it warp, ding up easily or get wobbly because of age. Rustic meaning knots and such are okay, heirloom meaning long lasting.

I've used construction pine before with great success, but wanted this to be a long term gift to my son and his someday wife.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#5

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

John M in Mid Mich

We live in a "log cabin-like" house with exposed beams, plank ceiling, etc. To keep the theme we put #2 common Hickory flooring throughout and it is perfect. Lots of character but extraordinarily durable (3 big dogs with toenails...). The tone and feeling of it next to pine is just perfect.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#6

Questions

David Yoho

I'm wondering why or how you are considering hickory. Is it because you have a stash of it, its cost, or comes closest to the look you're after?

The first choice that comes to my mind for reasons of hardness, availability, cost, and ease of finishing would be white oak. Maybe even quarter sawn white oak.

Hickory is a pretty wood but I think you would have better machinability with the oak. Another choice, although not a easily available, could be English brown oak.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#7

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

jgdillon

Mike, I did our entire kitchen in hickory and love the color and rustic look. Like another poster, we live part-time in a log cabin so the hickory fits in very well, especially with black and honey locust hardwood floors. Michael is right regarding the use of hand tools. I'm a hand tool klutz, but found the scraper to be super useful. Indeed, hickory is really prone to tear-out which is probably its biggest downside. If you have a planer/jointer, lightly dampen the surface of the wood to minimize tear-out. I kept the sap-wood in some cases as I like the variation and an oil finish blends the heart and sap wood nicely. Go for it. Jim

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#8

Not too much trouble with sharp carbide tools

Grant in Iowa

Hi Mike,

I have built several items with Hickory. I have used Shagbark hickory for several projects without issue. Maybe 500 Board feet in total over the years. I do not recall significant tear out with smart machining practices, nor much more trouble machining than experienced with white oak. Normal light passes with a router should be fine. Maybe other species of hickory tear out more. Maybe I keep my tools sharper, not sure what others are speaking of.

I have added a table top photo to illustrate that its latewood/ heartwood contrast fades with time. In our case maybe two years in a dining room with a south facing window. Point is to not expect the contrast to last. The final color after "fading" is pretty much the same as the heartwood or darker wood in my image. The late wood will still not have the same grain pattern as the heartwood, but it looks very nice nonetheless. I'm sure some purists disagree, but I tend to build what I like, not what is sold in furniture stores.

color.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#9

Re: white oak

Yonak

"...for reasons of hardness, availability, cost, and ease of finishing would be white oak." -- David Yoho

I would have thought the same until my last trip to the lumber yard. I added one 2X6x12 white oak board, for a friend, to what I was buying. I didn't check until I got home that I paid $106 for the board ! .. from a dealer I often do business with. I called back and got it reduced to $5.40 / bf but that is still out of this world.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#10

Re: Not too much trouble with sharp carbide tools

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I built our bedroom set (Two dressers, pedestal bed frame with book case head board) out of hickory over 30 years ago. It has held up well. It can be stained, but the stain will remain pretty light. I did all the cuts on a 1-1/2 Hp contractor saw and a craftsman router for the edge rounding. You have to pay close attention to grain direction when planing and routing to avoid tear out. Taking light passes helps.




Lee

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#11

Ney to current trend toward rustic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Rustic" is a recent "fashion" that may not last. The only reason I think rustic is currently fashionable is people are too cheap to afford things from quality wood. I think the piece will have greater long term value to its owner(s) if you make it as good as you can from quality lumber, free of knots, stain, etc. It can be of an informal style and most any wood is amenable to an informal style.

There are reasons that hickory (AKA "pecan") is rarely used in furniture. It was briefly fashionable some decades ago but that fad soon passed.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#12

Jesper, Denmark

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

Jesper, Denmark

I built a frame and panel backsplash for my kitchen i hickory some years ago. I do not remember any particular difficulties in either machining or finishing. No stain, but a couple of coats of poly. It still looks fine and has been easy to keep clean.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#13

Hickory... Yea - Thanks

Mike Circo

Special thanks to those who posted pictures. They show exactly what I'm looking for. A look not as smooth and perfect like the maple, cherry and walnut I usually use. But still more durable and easier to finish than pine.

I'll make sure bits and blades are sharp. I had only one exposure to hickory, a local guy who got a load free and was working it, but I didn't recall any particular traits, thus my question. I'll probably breadboard the ends of the top to avoid a lot of exposed end grain. Maybe I'll build up the guts to post my first pictures. (Don't hold your breath)

Again, thanks to all.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#14

Re: Questions

Mike Circo

David. White oak was my first thought, I've used it before. Then I saw the pieces that my son and girlfriend were trying to match and realized it wouldn't go. I don't have an on-hand stash of anything, (well poplar, cherry and maple, not options) so I'm open to most any option.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#15

Consider ash

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Take a look at Ash. It is cheap, lends itself to informal furniture and unlike hickory it ranks favorably compared to other furniture woods in stability. From a distance the two species look similar, with ash being a bit more porous.


I remain unclear what you mean by "rustic". I think of rustic as wood that includes defects such as knots, stain, etc. that give the wood a highly contrasting texture and color. This effect can be achieved with most any wood species if one picks a low enough grade of lumber. Visit "Lumber Liquidators" for many examples in flooring. But perhaps you mean for the piece to be "informal". Informal can be achieved with may woods through design and finish.

.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#16

Re: Consider ash

Mike Circo

Oh great! Now I have another option to consider. :-)

Hmmm. Yes, the Ash looks good for my "Informal" needs. (I like that term better.)

Ash and Hickory are nearly the same price around here.

I may just end up going to the lumber yard and flipping a coin.

Thanks for the option.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#17

Re: Consider ash - 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Breadboarded:


Informal:


Stains well and you can bring the finish and grain color contrast up to whatever level you wish.


Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#18

PS - Stability Note

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

No plywood was harmed in making the AV center. All solid ash panels and hasn't torn itself appart with seasonal change in the 15 years since it was made.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#19

Bill makes an important point...movement *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Bill is right on the money with his comment about movement in Hickory. While I tend to build for movement on everything I build, one must be careful with some woods, and hickory is one of them. It expands and contracts more than the mainstream hardwoods.

Example (with regards to the wood shrinkage calculator tool at Woodweb):

Shagbark Hickory 8" board, flatsawn, with an initial moisture content of 6%, and a hypothetical summertime MC of 15%, you should plan for 9/32" in movement (swelling)

The same hypothetical board in Northern Red Oak will move about 7/32nds of an inch---about an eight of an inch less than hickory

Considering Ash? the same board would typically move 3/16"---less than even Northern red oak.

None of this is a show stopper, but the builder must design and build for it to avoid problems.

I arbitrarily chose those moisture content numbers for a more apparent contrast between species. What a piece of furniture does in your world with the lumber you select may differ. Edit the numbers to fit your needs when planning a project.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Woodweb calculators

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#20

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboa

TomD

Staining I can't help you with, though it is probably pretty easy to turn black. I have used it on a few pieces of furniture, and always been happy with it. I don't agree it snaps off unpredictably to any horrible degree, it is one of the bedrock materials from which to make bows, and few other materials can tolerate being pared with bamboo. The first piece of furniture I made out of it was a base for a small table, it was turned, and while by no means ornate, it has a bead on each leg, none of which blew out.

I don't think it is difficult to finish, I used Watco, and you could also use epoxy on a table to fill and provide maximum scuff resistance, on something like a bar table.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#21

Re: Rustic furniture

TomD

Rustic wood doesn't make a ton of sense for the reasons you say, though some materials like elm, ash, beech, chestnut, and hickory would be good bets. A strong grain contrast as with elm, a crude look in some minds would help on the way. But rustic style in furniture is pretty clear, something country on down. From someone chainsaw milling out pieces in the wilderness up to cruder efforts of country craftsmen. Like outsider art, the best rustic furniture can be exceptional. Very didactic, as well as soulful.

Re: So, Hickory... Yea or Ney for "rustic" sideboard

#22

Re: Bill makes an important point...movement

TomD

I built two cabinet sized doors that when open offer a breezway between two rooms at the farm, right on the water. Never any problem with them, they are natural finish, though I am not sure what that finish was, most likely some kind of drying oil.