Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT - Old house/Salvage question

Posts

OT - Old house/Salvage question

#1

OT - Old house/Salvage question

Nat Robison

My mom is trying to sell an 1847 farmhouse (I grew up in it). It's been listed for about 7 months and hasn't yielded a single offer (even a lowball one). Maybe 15-20 walk-throughs in that time.

It was lived in until it was listed and, in my opinion, is livable as is but does need some full-scale updating and modernizing. I would love for someone with a big budget to buy it and bring it up-to-speed for the next 100 years.

Without ongoing maintenance, I fear it will depreciate to the point where the house and land will only be the worth the value of the land. Now, I find it's in need of some significant structural repairs (sagging floor, about 1") and could probably stand to be painted. I'm worried that none of these projects will yield equity, only money spent.

Anyone been in a similar situation with a property? Is there a guideline for salvage values with a historic house? Again, I DO NOT want to see this house demolished but am faced with the potential of ongoing maintenance in the tens of thousands of dollars. I know all of this depends on the market where the home is but I'm just looking for similar stories and how they worked out.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#2

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

Dick Coers

A picture would be nice, but I think you have to realize that the only person with a sentimental investment is you. I think it would have to be a in special location to warrant a big restoration expense. What are the mechanicals like? In the old farm house I grew up in, the single bathroom was an add-on shed roof structure on the front. It included a tiny entrance porch and then inside access to the basement that had been an external bulkhead. It was drafty and had an old coal furnace. We salvaged some lumber and built a new ranch house right behind it. That was in 1960. Our family doesn't own that property any longer. The only sentimental attachment I have is my tiny infant foot prints in the concrete of the corn crib. I doubt if I ever get to see those again.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#3

footprints

John K Jordan

> The only sentimental attachment I have is my tiny infant foot

> prints in the concrete of the corn crib.

I left one kid's footprints in concrete at our first house. Later I had another idea: I put some of a concrete pour in a separate small wooden form then took that boy's footprints with me when I moved!

JKJ

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#4

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

Gary Smyth

1847. Is it listed as a historic landmark? If so you may be in for additional expense as here in PA there is only so much that can be done if in that registration. I grew up in a 1850 house. Two big concerns, too close to the road and a rubble stone foundation that had to be 80% replaced.

If not historic, play the currency game. Take a $20 dollar bill and go around the perimeter of the kitchen. Whatever that total number is is about the cost of a remodeled kitchen. Then do the same for the bath, but this time use a $50 bill. Will a new buyer have that additional expense?

If you also have floors and roof to repair/replace you have a pretty good chance of never selling unless for the land only. Even then, some municipalities won't let you change the building footprint. Best to check with the local ordinances. Also if you have a septic tank, and sewers are available you may have to connect to the new system with a remodel and new owners.

Don't ignore new tax appraisal when sold.

What does the real estate agent say?

You may be able to get some value out of architectural features, wainscoting. lights, mantles, hinges, etc.

Location matters with all above. Pictures will help.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#5

$20 and $50?

Tom Dunlap

Did I get this right?

My bath is 59x89

[59+89]x2=296/6.14" [length of $50 bill]=48x$50=$2,400=estimated cost of remodel

Hmm...interesting rule of thumb :)

Is this a gut to bare studs and flooring estimate?

Tom

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#6

$2400 won't go far

Jerry Nicholson

In the early 80s I set my budget at $1000 for upgrade of a bathroom. I quit counting when I blew past $6000. And the labor was all mine.

Jerry

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#7

Ken Vaughan

Re: OT - Old house disposal

Ken Vaughan

Asbestos and lead based paint are significant costs for disposal and for worker protection.

After a $1000 survey of the building and clearing lead and asbestos, demo on a house cost $20,000

If lead or asbestos was involved the demo cost can double or triple.

And getting caught with improper disposal gets really really expensive.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#8

Re: $20 and $50?

Gary Smyth

Long story shorter. This guesstimate was provided by a suburban Pittsburgh kitchen remodel firm in Spring 2013. I went back to check my notes. The $20 & $50 numbers are as in my notes. This info applied to my situation. It included a new stainless sink, faucet and laminate countertops, and replacing a wall of cabinets (non-custom). Table and microwave and its cabinet remained. Major appliances stayed where they were. Wood floor remained. No gut and no change of power, or water. I was to be the tear out and most of the labor. Removal was by pick up of nylon Waste Management container. So, nowhere near a full gut, not even a full remodel, but it was my bare bones effort. Never did it as my champagne tastes didn't match the beer budget.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#9

Ellis Walentine

What does the realtor say?

Ellis Walentine

Those folks are all about getting a sale. They have a pretty good idea of how much you need to do to get the place salable. My feeling is that there's no need to totally renovate and improve a property before sale. Barry Irby could speak much further to this.

Ellis

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#10

Re: Who Me????

Barry Irby

This is a very difficult question. My background is that I grew up in one of these, on a farm. Worked my way through college building cabinets. With that degree in Building Construction, went to work in commercial construction. Hated it. Went to building houses for thirteen years. The buyers finally beat the urge out of me and I started doing Home Inspections and have been doing that for almost thirty years. In about the last five years I have remodeled and rented or flipped about ten houses. Somewhere in there I also did appraisals.

Back to your question. The old thing about value equals Location, location, Location is still true. Both the location of the house in relation to the surroundings and the economy of the surrounding area. sometimes an 1847 house is a historic treasure and sometimes it a tear down. Your sentimentality has no market value to anyone else unless you are famous or historically significant. (You aren't a recent President or perhaps a notorious bank robber are you?) Houses in North Dakota were cheap until the fraking boom. They may be going back down now? Some things you have nothing to do with. Take a look in the cold light of day.

If you have not received a single nibble its priced too high. The house is worth what a willing buyer will pay and a willing seller will take.

If the house is livable now trying to upgrade it to sell it may or may not work. The old advice here is that money spent in the kitchen and baths is worth while and may return more than was spent. Maybe. The problem is you are trying to out guess the market. There are no universal standards. A young couple may find something appealing an older couple will hate.

On my projects I try to do structural stuff that will come up on the home inspection and spend a moderate amount of money on the kitchens and baths. I am working in the low end of the market, for first time home buyers. I am resisting the urge to put in granite counter tops. Might be a mistake, but it works for me. On the one house I did use granite, they complained I did not upgrade everything else. When I offered to make the upgrades at cost, they declined.

Another problem I have in answering your question is I am doing a lot of the work myself. I am finding I enjoy it, so it does not bother me that I may not be getting paid as much as I should. It also stuns me what some people are paying for similar work.

And, I have had to adjust my standards. In the beginning, if a piece of wood had a little spot of rot, I ripped it out and replaced it. Maybe even all the similar pieces. In stead of fixing a door frame, I would replace it, and replace it with a better door in a rot resistant frame. I asked several local suppliers why they did not stock the upgraded doors and frames. Because when they tried it they NEVER sold one. I am slowly coming down to the market standard. Part of this is as a Home Inspector I see what fails on houses. Its hard not spend the extra money to avoid the problems.

so, Ellis is right, talk to several local Realtors. Get some Ideas. Decide to either do the work they suggest or price the house where they say. an 1847 house is almost unique. You want a Realtor that likes them and likes to sell them. A new house Realtor will be lost and won't have the connections to sell it.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#11

Better answer to estimate update *LINK*

Gary Smyth

Hanley Wood publications, “Remodeling” Magazine, a trade publication, issues a “Cost vs. Value” listing in one of their issues per year. The one I’ll refer to is dated January, 2014. In the issue it identifies 35 “big ticket” projects and breaks it down as to cost/value and percentage recouped which is stated as “a resale value as a percentage of construction cost. When cost and value are equal the ratio is 100%, when cost is higher than value, the ratio is less than 100%, when value is higher than cost, the ratio exceeds 100%.”

In 2014 using their lowest range ($5000 to $25,000) a remodel bathroom cost (national average) was $16,128

A minor remodel kitchen (national average) was $18,856

Incidentally, the highest five returns in the 2014 report were listed as:

Entry door replacement (steel) 94%

Wood deck addition 87%

Fiber cement siding replacement 87%

Garage door replacement 84%

Attic bedroom 84%

A minor kitchen remodel was 83%

Bathroom remodel 73%

Newer numbers are available at the link. Top of page -- cost vs value, then fill in required blanks for location and numbers for projects.

Later reports indicate that insulation, a new stone veneer, and vinyl siding are the only cost vs value over 100% recoup. See link for 2016. By the way, high end materials do not recoup value in the latest report.


http://www.remodeling.hw.net//costvsvalue/2015/

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#12

Reply

Nat Robison

Thanks for all the input. I know I'm chasing an unanswerable question.

This is my Mom's house so the hit(s) aren't to my checkbook....I'm just trying to manage this process from 80 miles away......not a simple task. My Mom's realtor told me that everyone who's walked through said it looks like more work than they're up for. I doubt she has a lot of experience with homes this old......there aren't many in the area that aren't part of working farms.

I'm not overly-sentimental about this house and it has little historical significance. I would love to see it restored but more than that, I'd like to see it sold. What the new owners choose to do is up to them.

The tough part of it is that you could sink $10K into each of several areas of the house.....exterior, HVAC, electrical (some of the house has knob-and-tube)......before getting to the kitchen and baths.

Ultimately, the situation is what it is and there is a buyer for it but they probably represent less than .1% of the buyers out there. I'll address the structural stuff and revisit the pricing.

Re: OT - Old house/Salvage question

#13

The 80/20 rule

paul in AZ

You can get 80% of the way to a fabulous result with 20% of the cost or effort.

Its that final push that costs big time.