Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Stair tread finish

Posts

Stair tread finish

#1

Stair tread finish

Dustmaker Mike

howdy all

I am in the process of putting down a laminate hard wood floor. When I am done I will be tiling a bathroom. After all that is done I will be replacing the stair treads. I am using Oak and have already sanded them down to 400 then stained them. I am in the process of putting Minwax gloss poly on them. I have them in a temp controlled area while they dry. My questions are

I have put on two coats already and sand in between them. I let them set for 5 or 6 days between coats is this enough?

Also how many coats should I put on? I was thinking 4 or 5, will this last?

Anything else I should do?

They will not be going on until the end of March so I have time for more coats if needed.

Thanks Mike

Re: Stair tread finish

#2

Re: Stair tread finish

Barry Irby

I have not used the Minwax Poly on stairs. I have used it on other things and was happy with it. On stairs I used Varathane Poly that has aluminum oxide particles in it to reduce wear. I used it one steps in a rental. It is holding up well. I only used two coats. With the experience I have with the Varathane I woudl put a coat of it over the Minwax because of the wear resistance. First I woudl double check that it adheres to the Minwax, and if in doubt stick with the Minwax.

And I am pretty sure you have been using plenty of drying time in between coats. I think sanding to 400 (Anything past 150 or 180) was wasted. Follow the directions about sanding between coats.

Re: Stair tread finish

#3

Are you reading directions on the can?

Dick Coers

Waiting too many days between coats may cause it's own trouble. Poly does not chemically bond between coats and it can get too hard to get any kind of bond. They give you guidelines on recoating times and methods. With days between coats, you'll have to sand very throughly to get a mechanical bond. 3 coats is plenty for me. 5 or 6 coats will look like plastic, especially with the gloss.

Re: Stair tread finish

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Stair tread finish

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Mike,

I'd only sand to 220 between coats, to allow for more 'tooth.' 48~72 hours is enough time between coats, too.

Three or four coats should be plenty, as well. Let the last coat cure for at least a week before walking on it, if you can.

Are the treads already cut to final size, or will you be cutting each one to size just prior to installation? If you're cutting them, then you'll need to do edge treatment prior to installation.

Re: Stair tread finish

#5

Read instructions when I got home

Dustmaker Mike

OK it says to sand to 220 between coats which is what I was doing any way. Also it says if using on flooring let set a few days before use. So I have been doing good with out reading the instructions. The final sanding is with wet dry 400 grit. I use warm with a touch of soap in it to sand it smooth. They will sit at least two weeks or more before I install them. I do have to cut them to size but I will apply a little poly to the edges when I install them.

Thanks

Re: Stair tread finish

#6

Re: Read instructions when I got home

Dick Coers

I was concerned about this; "I let them set for 5 or 6 days between coats is this enough?" I'd always heard that if you let it go full hard before recoating, the bond was in jeopardy. I looked up the instructions on-line, they have stopped talking about recoat times all together. Guess it's not an issue any longer.

Re: Stair tread finish

#7

I got lucky

Dustmaker Mike

I was working on other things and figured letting them set was the smart thing to do. Yup I got lucky.

Thanks

Re: Stair tread finish

#8

Not so sure

David Yoho

Maybe Bill will weigh in on this but I always thought polyurethane should not go too long between coats due to the chemistry involved and how it achieves its hard film. It would seem that if it were allowed too much time between coats the surface would have to be roughed up with sand paper to give a new application some "tooth" to hold it. This certainly holds true when going back after months and years to add additional coats. I usually wait no more than 24 hours between coats of poly.

This is a big reason I prefer a varnish like Waterlox or Arm R Seal. Its so much easier to add additional coats down the road without all the hassle.

Re: Stair tread finish

#9

Re: Not so sure

Howard Acheson

David, you are completely correct. The general rule is that if you can not overcoat within 24 hours, you need to scuff sand to ensure good adhesion.