Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Tough finishing question

Posts

Tough finishing question

#1

Ellis Walentine

Tough finishing question

Ellis Walentine

My son is putting up this little cabin on their property in California, and he wants to know a finish that is totally natural, i.e., no hydrocarbons, no pigments, no synthetic chemicals. The cabin is made of spruce, and I've already admonished him to get it up off the grade so that water and snow can't rot out the wood. but I am stumped as to what kind of finish would let the wood oxidize naturally and offer at least some workable modicum of protection. I recall a couple cedar treatments that were pretty natural, but I've lost the trail. Any help?

Thanks in advance.

Ellis


Re: Tough finishing question

#2

Olive oil?

Dick Coers

Just kidding, but that is a pretty tight list of requirements. I don't know if you can get raw enough linseed oil to meet the requirements.

Re: Tough finishing question

#3

Re: Tough finishing question *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

Take a look at CedarCide. I've heard good things about it but have not used it.


CedarCide waterproofer

Re: Tough finishing question

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tough finishing question

Jesper, Denmark

Check the SDS sheet - petroleum distillate with some siloxanes added. probably does not qualify.

Re: Tough finishing question

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tough finishing question

Jesper, Denmark

Ellis, Where in CA is it to be located? Churches built from pine and spruce have lasted i Norway for hundreds of years.

If in a dry climate sumer and winter, maybe doing nothing is the answer?

Re: Tough finishing question

#6

Rub it down with bear fat

Keith Newton

Just kidding, I'm sure he wouldn't want to shoot a bear either.

Why didn't he use cedar? It is a nice looking little cabin, but I'm wondering about some of the details. What is with the fascia being higher than the shingles?

Re: Tough finishing question

#7

Re: Tough finishing question

E Snow

Admire the sentiment but it seems like a bit of waste to go all natural for a compromised finish when it is likely that all the materials made heavy use of hydrocarbons to get to the site and in their processing. I would advise one evaluate the net effect of having to rebuild when the finish doesn't work vs a bucket of a a less impactful finish. Low/no voc, no/few metallic modifiers/catalyst, plant oil base. (sadly there may actually be fewer Kj of energy used in the manufacture of a petrochemical finishes than plant based, conjecture) As well the willingness to maintain said all natural and friendly finish.

Hempshield came up looking for a plant oil without metallic catalyst. Might be worth investigating.

If he insists, I'd suggest something with linseed oil for water resistance and whiting (lime) for some uv value. Without a modifier it won't dry within the year and I am not coming up with much for all natural modifiers. Boiling it won't really do it. Sort of a whitewash plus idea.

Re: Tough finishing question

#8

Penofin Verde is Rosewood Oil.. *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Ellis,

I have long been a fan of Penofin products. It looks like they make a "Green" solution for outdoor finishing. I have no experience with it, but if their other products are any indicator, it is worth looking at.

I do recall Penofin no longer being available in California due to spontaneous combustion issues. This was 15 years ago, however.


Penofin Verde

Re: Tough finishing question

#10

Re: Tough finishing question

John in NM

I think it's down to a lime whitewash if that would suit his tastes. Probably would run afoul of aesthetics though....

Re: Tough finishing question

#11

The picture...

John in NM

I think that is a modeled image rather than the actual building - that's why the fascia is taller than the roof surface, just a glitch in generating the image that wasn't fixed.

Re: Tough finishing question

#12

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Could it just be a small "detail" piece added to cover the joint in facia at the peak that projects above the roof line. Same thing appears on the gable over the front door.

Re: Tough finishing question

#13

Adam of Oakland

I don't know, but it sure is a pretty cabin! 


Re: Tough finishing question

#14

Ellis Walentine

Wet climate

Ellis Walentine

...in the hills north and east of Ft.Bragg. If it were me, I'd be trying to protect against moisture.

Ellis

Re: Tough finishing question

#15

North and east of Ft. Bragg?

Dick Coers

Have you visited College of The Redwoods when visiting? I spent a weekend there when working for Woodworker's Journal. I talked the editor into letting me take a weekend class with Krenov, then travel to Anaheim to work in our booth at the AWFS. A very fond memory!

Re: Tough finishing question

#16

Re: Tough finishing question

jgdillon

Hi Ellis, I've had good luck with the exterior finishes offered for log/wood cabins by Schroeder Log Homes. Here is a link to a variety of exterior finishes they sell. I haven't looked at them all, but the Sansin ENS looks interesting as a environmentally friendly finish. There may be others they offer that meet the needs of your son. Hope this helps. Jim

The usual window for entering a web address didn't appear on the message reply page so I will just copy and paste it below.

http://www.loghelp.com/c-19-exterior-log-home-finishes.aspx

Re: Tough finishing question

#17

I think you're right...

John in NM

You looked at it closer than I did! :D

Re: Tough finishing question

#18

Geographical relevance 

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Sun, moisture and temperature are the variables that interactively affect the life and appearance of a finish. Advice on what worked for me in a climate different from some other application is likely misleading.

We speak of not doing "chemistry experiments" on our furniture, that is trying something we are unfamiliar with on a finished piece and hoping for a favorable result. I would offer the same advice here. It would be risky to use something that had not been proven to work satisfactorily in this particular microclimate. Pick something a neighbor used successfully and find some other way to feel good about perceived environmental impact.

Illustrated is what an "all natural organic" finish will look like in E. TN after a few years. It is naturally colored by what ever is growing on it with a base coat of sun bleached wood. It sounds better than it looks, to me.

Re: Tough finishing question

#19

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tough finishing question

Jesper, Denmark

Ellis,

Something which does not fullfill all the requirements, but may be acceptable is Falu red paint:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falu_red

This has been used i Sweden for centuries, painted on sawn clapboards of spruce or pine. Does not work quite as well on planed surfaces.

I don't know where the pigment can be obtained in the USA, but surely it must be possible.

Another alternate is Tonkinoise varnish - again, this does not meet all the requirements, as it contains mineral spirits - but not much.

Re: Tough finishing question

#20

Ellis Walentine

Re: North and east of Ft. Bragg?

Ellis Walentine

Been there many times. Spent the best part of three days with JK working on a piece I was writing for American Woodworker. I was just there last July in my travels and got a chance to catch up with Michael Burns and David Welter. The shop and the program look exactly like they did when I first visited there in the early 90s. It's quite a legacy that's being carried on there, though I know that Krenov's presence was a real catalyst.

Ellis

Re: Tough finishing question

#21

Re: North and east of Ft. Bragg?

TomD

I would imagine he would not want to do this, but the Japanese burn the wood black that pretty much keeps the criters at bay. They use tung oil on boats. My experience with it is that it doesn't hold up well, but maybe there is a process to it one could follow. Obviously cedar shingles made of old growth will hold up. But the cedar we get these days with a lot of knots would present a challenge to epoxy with a two pack over top.

One thing about high performance finishes is that some are not all that toxic in use. California is tough about keeping the world for the waves of population to follow. So using the best new stuff might pick up on Bill's point about the whole cycle, and be enviro friendly even if the stuff is the product of modern day chemistry.

I am a long time lover of Wooden Boats. But the reality is they melt away. A lot less wood with epoxy and cloth will last a hundred years, use less resources to make and run, and perform better. It is weird how many people want to drive stuff like electric cars but when it comes to just building stuff to last they show no mercy.