Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

Posts

Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#1

Dale Lenz

Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

Dale Lenz

Don't see any use for it, son paid over $200 for it at Lowes. Gonna take it back tomorrow and add a few extra dollars for a back pack leaf blower, got close to 2 acres to round up leaves with and burn.

Can't think of a decent thing to do with a biscuit jointer, never have used one, just think they are a cheap tendon joint.

Anyone give me a good reason to keep it?

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#2

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

billv in SE Michigan

I tend to use mine for glue ups to assist the process of leveling multiple boards at a time and keeping them from moving around when I apply clamp pressure. Often I am too lazy to pass them in a planer to get them all the same thickness so glue then plane. Really don't use it much for joint work. Its really a function of limited time in shop means all at once glue ups are common place.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#3

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

David Yoho

Dale, if you've never used one you probably never had a need to. They do have one good purpose in my opinion. Biscuits are a good way to line up different assemblies like face frame to carcass or in a corner miter to keep the two end grain pieces on the same plane. However, I don't think they are necessary in edge joints for panels. They only provide alignment but no strength. A well jointed and glued panel stock gets its strength from straight square edges and the glue.

Now, a good backpack blower is a thing of beauty! I finally bought a Husqvarna last year and the difference it made in ridding my yard of leaves in short order was wonderful.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#4

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

Keith Newton

How about trading it for a flame thrower, ha ,,,,,, ok maybe a snow blower to clear your drive. I'm betting you just got a few inches of snow last night.

We just had a brief but unusual weather event. The thunder and lightning was about ten second interval, with a mix of rain and big wet snowflakes in the beginning, but later to just hard rain, which never melted the snow off my roof window. It reminded me of an episode on the Weather Chanel, where Rick Cantorial started jumping around hootin and hollering because there was lightning while he was doing his doing his show in a snowstorm.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#5

bought one, used once

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have one and have found little use for it. Anybody need one? Porter Cable.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#6

Can be handy, but not required....

John in NM

Handy for alignment, but not necessary by any stretch.

I had a second hand one for a while, mostly used it for aligning cabinet face frames to the plywood boxes - helps keep the pocket screw from pulling the alignment off as it cinches down.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#7

Re: Can be handy, but not required....

Barry Irby

I have one and use it rarely. Just as others have said. Useful for lining up miters and face frames. Maybe more trouble than they are worth. One thing I like better about them than Kreg screws. Those screws are pretty hard and will ruin a saw blade. A biscuit won't. The biscuits are less visible than Kreg Screws also.

I'm wondering if a Domino machine falls in the same category?

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#8

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I have two of them. Both Porter Cable. One I bought and one was my dad's.

I started using it a lot when I was building my kitchen cabinets 15 or so years ago. But while I was building them I started using pocket hole screws and quit using the biscuits.

I don't remember using it since.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#9

I love biscuit joiners

Dick Coers

Even wore one out. I prefer the Elu, and bought a third one when I found out the were going to be discontinued. That new one in the box is going to be a rare bird on my estate sale one day! It was fault the first Elu wore out, I didn't keep the bevel gears lubed for all the hours of use. I've used them to make drawers, and plywood book cases by the dozen. Kitchen cabinets case construction as well. I detest cutting dados for plywood since the sheet thickness varies so much. I've made a lot of money building with those things, like I said, I love them!

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#10

benefit auction?

John K Jordan

>I have one and have found little use for it.

>Anybody need one? Porter Cable.

Same here. I donated mine for a Stephan Shepherd benefit auction. When I started looking around, I found other tools I probably would never use and auctioned them as well. I think at last count over $1000 was raised for this poor guy. (it could happen to any of us between one breath and the next)

Or a benefit auction to help keep WoodCentral on the net would probably also be much appreciated!

JKJ

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#11

Kreg screws....

John in NM

Yeah, I currently have a love/hate relationship with pocket screws.... they are wonderfully convenient in terms of speed and easy, but then they tend to move things around more than I like. Then one adds some mechanism by which that movement will be prevented and wonders if its really worth it - that extra effort pretty well cancels the convenience!

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#12

Re: Can be handy, but not required....

Jesse Cloud

Just responding to the thoughts about whether the domino machine falls into the same category as biscuits...

I've had the domino for several years now and I use it in almost every project I do. The thing is that the domino makes real mortise and tenon joinery with a fit thats at least as good as anything I can make in my shop. The other day I dry fitted a small table with dominoes and stood on it. Though I weigh close to 300 lbs, it didn't wobble - with no glue.

:|

I'll agree that the domino is not worth the $$ if you don't do mortise and tenon often.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#13

I just remembered

Dick Coers

I forgot about the Delta bench top biscuit machine on the back of a storage shelf. So I have 3 in use, and the backup brand new Elu. Maybe that's a record based on the opinions here.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#14

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

Denny

I've used mine for cutting the slots in door pulls. Here's an example done in ebony. Pardon the poor photo...


Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#15

Dale Lenz

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

Dale Lenz

That's a Good idea, congrats on coming up with that thought. Husky Back Pack Blower is setting in my truck seat. :)

Thanks to all that replied...

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#16

Dale Lenz

Not even a flake that I'm aware of


Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#17

two issues, the real answer.

TomD

Issue number one is whether given your skepticism you paid too much. There are cheaper machines that do a good job, so if you don't think you need one, but might need one, you could get your refund and find one for 50 bucks, maybe you can do a deal with Bill.

The other thing is whether you are ever in a rush to do anything. Franz Klausz is a pretty good hand with the tools. He can dovetail and fit a drawer in 20 minutes, yet he did a tape on BJs. He showed how to use them to build cases, and presumably sold that kind of work as a pro. But a lot of us are looking for ways to use up time, if I BJ a joint I don't feel like I did the right thing. I could have done a proper MT

Here are a couple of additional points:

- For some the BJ is a step up. All their projects use drywall screws say, but the BJ is solid wood joinery.

- Creativity is part of it, you can do a lot with a BJ if you don't have other tools. I put together a bank of simple cabinets for my parents when I was down for a visit. They have pretty good tools, including a Dewalt BJ. What they don't have is any of the extras that are necessary to make proper M&T cabinets in any kind of efficient manner, if at all. Nor is there any decent wood readily available, even the paint grain pine would need truing. What I eventually found was mahogany door jam sets for the frames, bead board, and paint grade ply. It all went together with biscuits, I even used the biscuits to make a french cleat system. Part of an efficient build is keeping the work flowing, and in this tiny shop the BJs really helped that happen. At one point my mom asked me to make a wall hung pocket to hold her phone books. In an M&T set-up, the settings on saws and such would have been lost by this point. But with BJs, I could just slap the frame and panels together, and then BJ then to the tapered sides, and then I used BJs to hang the whole cabinet from the drywall. I just put them in then cut away some of the Bs until they looked like fangs. I used a thin chisel to cut slots in the drywall, and hung the cabinet directly to the drywall. No exposed hardware, triips to the store to buy hardware, and it comes right off if you need to clean the wall, or move large pieces of furniture past it. But at home I have specialty tools for everything, so I don't need to use BJs, and my vanity makes me believe I am a better craftsman for not using them when there is something more time consuming that will do a better job a few centuries from now.

Re: Biscuit machine, Christmas gift....

#18

Re: Pockets and dominos

TomD

Mathias has a pretty convincing video showing how weak pocket screws are. Biscuits are very strong when used in the directions they are intended for, and for as long as the glue lasts.

I can't afford dominos, but they look to be superior to all the other machines in every way. They are not going to be as good as an M&T in every case, but they are probably 90% as good, or 75%. If you ever look around and think "I don't have time for this beep, life is too short". But life is also too short to turn out junk, then Domino is your huckleberry.

The only thing about Dominos is they are so expensive they push some people to biscuits, and others probably figure when they are spending that much, why not throw in a BJ while they are at the store.