Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

Posts

Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#1

Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

Mark

Does anyone have any experience and an opinion on the effectiveness of these trash can separator tops designed to allow heavier chips etc to fall into the can on the way to the DC? I have a 1.5HP General DC that is connected with 4" piping..works fine, but the intake of the DC can frequently get clogged with heavier shavings so wondered if this was a solution or just aother load and stress on the DC system.

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#2

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

JoeW in Detroit

I have one. It works. I bought it a number of years ago. I keep it next to my machine so my hose lengths are under 5 feet each. My biggest complaint is that it doesn't fit the can I use very well. I have had to add some weather stripping to top of can and had to invent a way to hold the lid on to the can. I know I'm losing some efficiency, but it does keep the bag on the dust collector from filling up when using the jointer or planer. For the price, I find it's worth the minor annoyances. I hope to have a dedicated system one of these days.

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#3

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

ebushee

There are a few different designs. Two designs are in the link below - I have heard that second one is better as less dust and chips are sucked back up through and on to your dust collector. Even better (I've heard because I haven't tried all these) is to have the outlet in the center of the lid, a design that Lee Valley uses. I have the Lee Valley one on a 30 gallon galvanized trash can and it works very well with my planer. Once the can gets about 3/4 to 4/5 full I notice some of the shavings start getting sucked back up. The Thien baffle supposedly solves that issue by adding a baffle below the lid, but you have to build that one as it isn't commercially made. My only complaint with the LV lid is that is doesn't really attach to the can, only sits on top. Once the air is flowing it gets sucked down tight, but otherwise if I look at it funny it slides right off onto the floor.

http://www.ptreeusa.com/dustacces.htm#399

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#4

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

David Bair

I'll second the Lee Valley unit; it works very well, indeed.

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#5

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

Barry Irby

I have one I made myself. Its a squarish Rubbermaid roll around trash can about 30 gallons. I cut two DC fittings into the lid. I will have to look at it when I get home but I think one was a 45 degree angle and the other was an elbow. It worked well, but there was a complication. The suction would collapse the can. I added a vertical stick in each corner. It cost me nearly nothing. I had the can and fittings were leftovers. I stopped using it because I have a tiny shop. If you are near Richmond, VA or willing to come get it, I would give it to you.

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#6

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

JoeW in Detroit

I have the same problem with mine. I drilled a hole in each handle on the trash can and used a scrape piece of lumber with holes corresponding to the holes in the handles. Placed carriage bolts through the handles then through the wooden stringer and tighten with two star knobs I had laying around. I can tighten the lid down to hold in place while moving it around although at times it still can shifted out of alignment on the can.

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#7

Consider building a thien separator *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Mark,

As you indicated in your question, there is a bit of a trade-off. The right answer for your needs just plain "depends" on a bunch of variables.

Firstly, any time you make a curve with air, or worse try to spin it, the action requires energy. In the case of a large separator, the energy penalty causes reduced air flow at the collection point. Ideally, you want to minimize that loss. The larger the volume of spinning air, the more energy required to spin that air in the space, therefore less air flow (velocity) at the collection point. For this reason, if you intend to improve your existing collector, I would advocate you consider a small separator, such as a Thien type, or newly commercially available cyclones from the likes of Oneida.

I would advocate you consider using a thien separator because the volume of moving air is kept to a minimum. By doing so, the loss of energy is also minimized. This in turn increases air velocity at the collection point.

Secondly, having an efficient means to separate the dust from air allows your filter media to stay clean longer, which also translates to more air flow. it is air flow that allows the capture of fine particles that would otherwise lodge in your lungs and suffocate you slowly.

There are plenty of web pages and videos describing how to build a thien. These pages also show the effectiveness of them visually so you can be assured that they are working well. I am advocating this as a solution, because it is about the best one can do with a sub 5HP collector and 6" ducting. The Thien solution is a compromise to be sure, but it will be better than your current solution.

Whatever you employ, your dust collector is still not likely adequate to keep you truly safe from the hazards of fine wood dust. This is simply because it takes a large blower to move enough air to "grab" the fine dust at the collection point. Google Bill Pentz dust collection and read up. It was his explanations that prompted me to upgrade to a Cyclone and 6" ducting. While still not entirely adequate, my system does a decent job of collecting the dangerous fines. Everything is a compromise in some way.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Thien dust separator video

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#8

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

Mark

Thanks for all the feedback.

I think the thein separator is the way to go. Lots of examples on You tube of designs and builds.

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

#9

Re: Dust Collection Separator Tops for Trash Cans

ChuckinND

Good luck with all the mind numbing gibberish out there about the Thien baffle. Everyone thinks that they are rocket scientists, and make it a lot harder then it has to be. Even Bill Pentz over does it in my opinion.