Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

Posts

Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

#1

Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

Barry Irby

I have a Dewalt drill That had worn out brushes. Ordered new brushes from eReplacements.com. They were advertised as "after market" or otherwise not original parts. While trying to install the brushes one of them came out of the poly bag in two pieces. The metal prong had fallen off the wire. I was at the job site and decided to reinstall the little plug. Took a while, but I finally opened the little grippers and reinstalled the plug. Reassembled the drill and Nothing. Before it sparked and spluttered but it worked. Now nothing.

Is there something about replacing brushes I don't know? Have I skipped a step or two? Is it worth taking another whack at it or should I trash the drill and get a new one? Should I contact the parts dealer?

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

#2

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

del schisler

maybe no contact between wire and metal part ? i would take it apart and use a ohm meter and check wire to brush for connective ? check both for a comparison , ? good luck

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

#3

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

Ralph Lipeles

I have found Dewalt drills to be of good design and good quality. I believe that your problem warrants more time investment. Do the new brushes look like what remains of the old ones? Do they slide easily in the slots without getting hung up?

Good luck,

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

#4

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

John in NM

About the wire coming off the post? Yes, that is just crappy manufacturing and eReplacements should know better than to buy aftermarket when it's crap (it isn't always).

The sparking and sputtering makes me think that the brushes were not seated well on the commutator, which I've found to be fairly common with replacement brushes - the theory being that curve on their front doesn't match the curve of the commutator and thus they arc. The cause of the arcing may be something else, but I've found that when new brushes arc like that they never get better (contrary to advice I've seen to "run them in").

The last two times I've done brushes though, they didn't arc at all, just worked normally (Milwaukee hammer drill and my old Hitachi slider). The spare brushes came with the drill, bought in 1988, and the Hitachi brushes came from a supplier that might well have been eReplacements.

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

#5

Re: Should I be ticked off??? Drill/brushes

John McGaw

You should definitely contact the supplier of the brushes and complain vociferously -- there is no excuse for delivering defective materials. And no, I certainly wouldn't get rid of the tool -- there is a lot going on with any motor with brushes and commutator and even the best replacement brush may not work properly with a commutator which is in rough pitted shape from the old brushes arcing. It is sometimes necessary to polish and clean the commutator before replacing brushes when full performance is expected. In the best of cases removing the armature, chucking it in a lathe or drillpress and smoothing the commutator with fine emory cloth will do the job (with a thorough cleaning of the insulators afterward to get rid of fine copper power). In the worst of cases it calls for chucking the armature into a proper machinist's lathe and removing metal to bring things into shape. In the latter case it might be worth junking the drill unless you have the lathe and the skill.