Lester, there are plenty of good books out there, by folks like Dresdner, Flexner, Jewitt, Masachi and others, telling you exactly how to finish almost anything. Not to mention magazine articles. I'd like you to decide just what you want to know and tell us. Is there a particular piece you're thinking of building and you want to know how to finish it for a certain look or feel? It's pretty hard to lay out all the aspects of finishing in a single post or thread, but we've proven many times that a targeted reply is possible.
I guess what I'm saying is that you don't need an encyclopedic understanding of finishing to take it one project at a time.
Something that I think should be required material in any hobbyist woodworking shop is a copy of either the books by Flexner or Jewitt (or both). Flexner's book is a little easier to follow, I read it much like a novel....Jeff's book is very good as a reference and they both have basically the same information. An excellent place for a start.
Ellis and Bill got that right. The amount of information you could learn about finishing is huge, really huge and somewhat overwhelming, but you don't have to know all of it and be able to do every kind of finish. People here can help you learn what you need to know about which ever finish you want to do.
And Bill's point about the time and effort is well taken. I have heard it said that building the piece is half the work and the other half is finishing it. Get it into your head that finishing the piece is a significant amount of work and start planing for it from the beginning.
For example, get your piece sanded well and ready. Some parts will have to be sanded before they are installed or assembled. Another example is that if your piece includes raised or flat panel doors made out of solid wood the panels may have to be stained and finished before the doors are assembled. (Otherwise raw wood will show when they shrink and swell.)
So, start thinking about the finish early on and let us help you with that particular one. In general you need to have any piece for any finish must be well prepared and you need a space that is dust free and well lighted to apply the finish and that space needs to be warn enough and well enough ventilated.
On a personal level I find it harder and harder to get a piece properly sanded. Maybe my eyes are failing me or maybe I get in a bit of a hurry. I sometimes find the first coat of stain or finish reveals scratches I had not seen. Bummer. I have taken to wetting each piece to reveal these scratches. This not only helps show me the scratches I might have missed, it raises the grain and I get to sand it off one more time. Bill can explain sanding to you as well as anyone.
How one finishes depends on the wood and style of furniture. Tell us what you want to finish, how it will be used and what it is made of and specific advice will follow.
That is the thing to remember about finishing. It is tedious yet pretty simple, and many of the difficulties come from trying to shave time - at least that is where my problems come from even after years of doing it.
Other than that, there is a huge amount of info on the net, and it can be confusing. That is where forums like WC are so invaluable, in helping one make sense of all the information.
Finishing is perhaps the woodworking topic most subject to individual prejudices, often conflicting, involving products and techniques that complicate the endeavor. Dogmatic instruction in the "right way" is common. Keep it simple, and learn from your own experience.
Let me add to the excellent info presented so far. When I taught finishing, each student was required to purchase Bob Flexner's Understanding Wood Finishing. It is the best book for beginners and experienced finishers. I covers the whole gamut of finishing and is written in a very understandable fashion. Jeff Jewett's Taunton's Complete Guide to Finishing is also and excellent book for a finisher's library.
Thanks everyone for the words of encouragement. I guess I didn't say what I wanted to
learn about finishing. First, I am going to be making a coffee table and end tables for the
house. Then the wife wants new kitchen cabinet doors and drawer fronts. I will be using white oak for the lumber. I have picked up 6 large white oak logs that I will cut into lumber so that most pieces will have the same grain and color. I know that will help to make finish
better. I have all the books that everyone has said, but I am one that likes hands on learning. The first thing is the wife wants a medium color. I have tried to make some
samples and none have come out like she wants. I know, wives can be picky at times.
The first time I made a sample, it was too dark and the early wood was not as dark. I am
using dye stain and then finishing with poly so I know just how it will look. I then made a
lighter mix and that was just not the shade and color she wanted. So I guess what I
need to know and learn is how to use different dyes to build up to what the color and
shade we want. I know it takes time and practice to learn but I would like to find someone that could show me how to go about it in a class or in their shop. Is there a base list
of dies and stains that I can use to mix and make samples to reach the color we want? Also, can you mix dies with the finish to reach what you want? I look at some of the
furniture that some make on here and it looks like the finishes I want.
Thanks for all your help, and when I start making them, I can post some photos as I
I am sure not an expert like some on here, but I have achieved the shades and finishes I wanted. First, yes you can mix ANY oil based stain with any other oil based stain to obtain the color you desire. I also have a set of oil based Artist paints. These can also be added (use very small amounts) to change the color of the stain.
White oak, in my opinion is one of more difficult woods to obtain a beautiful finish due to its porous grain and contrasting colors.
I have finished several oak pieces to my satisfaction (and my wife's), but we both like a "natural" finish and enjoy the contrast of the Oak grain. I do fill the pores of the grain prior to any staining and seal the surface, then I use a dye based stain, usually sprayed on, but I have wiped on / wiped off the stain to achieve the "look" I wanted.
I live in Indiana so am not constrained by having to use water based finishes as some are in other states like California. I use very little water based finishing material.
Bill is very knowledgeable about finishing, and Ellis and many others that know far more than me are always willing to answer your questions.
Apologies for shouting.....but I really do hate finishing. Thank goodness that the love of my life has the patience and "knack" for finishing what I/we build. Yep....she's my "right-hand man" in the shop. Always encouraging and many times catches mistakes before I make them. Uh....Type "A" personality here and I think I should be able to build anything in a day or two. Whew....we do make a good pair and she is GREAT at finishing. I do help a little with the sanding
I am surprised that many didn't mention that much of finishing depends upon good preparations.
IE sanding.
As a gunsmith, a Claro Walnut stock springs to life when finished with a high quality and thorough boiled linseed oil finish with sanding between applications. We are talking about sanding to around 2000 grit.
If you want actual hands on learning, Marc Adams School of Woodworking has 5 day and 2 day classes which are excellent. From my experience, the key is to start experimenting immediately, unless you have an established plan. By immediately, I mean take some scrap, sand it properly and try a finish. Do this at the start of the project. As has been pointed out, this takes time. Take notes. If you have to try several approaches, you will not remember what you did. If you wait until Christmas Eve to think about the finish.... Jerry
Here is a saying I learned from a great finisher I worked with when I was new to finishing.
"It's the finish that gets the oohs and ahs, not the joinery". In other words, learn how to finish if you want to show off your work to the best advantage.
Notes can get lost, and essential details of steps and materials get forgotten. I find it very helpful to write down every step of what I did on the back of the piece of scrap. If it's big enough scrap, write it on the front, so you don't get fingerprints in the finish when you turn it over.