Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Demilune-staining the top

Posts

Demilune-staining the top

#1

Demilune-staining the top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



The first picture shows the top face of the top. I am pleased with the grain in the result. Can you find the joint where I added a piece to fill out the width? Many won't notice. The picture is a bit more yellow than reality. The stain is burnt umber, a mixture of manganese and iron oxides, which has a reddish hue. The stain recipe and application technique was described earlier.


The second picture shows the back which in turn show the effect of the stain.

Can you tell I am pushing to get this piece done and out of here? Chest of drawers for daughter is next.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#2

Re: Demilune-staining the top

Barry Irby

That's beautiful. Answered my thoughts on the piece while it was glued up in the clamps. I was wondering about what appeared to be pin knots on each end and the gap or "notch" in the joint of the glued on piece. I doubt anyone will notice the added piece. Great work.

My only reservation was I was wondering if it would not have been better to have the join along the back edge rather than the front. Longer joint and harder to do a perfect match, but protected by being nearer to the rear.

I want to build some pieces for family. Legacy pieces.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#3

Re: Demilune-staining the top

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I've been enjoying this build Bill - all the posts you have done so far.

Hard to tell with pictures over the internet, color balances with various lighting and cameras and so on, but I like the color of this walnut with your stain.

Looks great.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#4

Pigment stain notions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are unfavorable notions about pigment stains derived from those that don't know how to sand, mix the stain and/or apply it.

In the case at hand the finish off the planer was good and the joint of the added piece perfect so I began with hand sanding and I always finish with hand sanding, up close and personal. Sanding was 100 grit, 120 and 180 aluminum oxide and a quick final scuff with 220 garnet. About 80% of the time was on 100, sanded until the surface was perfectly uniform in luster, everywhere. At each step the luster of the sanded surface was perfectly uniform before moving on. This goal is the main component to getting a uniform appearance from a pigment stain.

To get a transparent appearance of the stain I mix it more dilute than commercial stain, in this case 15% pigment. It colors the wood without covering it up.

And I don't slather stain on with a brush and then wipe off what doesn't soak in. With a rubber I can control the take of the stain on the wood. I mixed 20 mL of stain for this top and used not more than 3-4 mL for the job (can't weigh components accurately for less than 20 mL)

The result permanently tones the wood so that I don't wind up with blond walnut after 20 years. Other than some yellowing of the top coat the finish will look that same for decades.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#5

Ellis Walentine

Good advice, Bill

Ellis Walentine

Pigment stains are definitely the way to go for permanence. And methodical sanding is key to getting a uniform appearance.

Now, all that said, I am very partial to dye staining before pigment staining. It lends a depth, coloring and complexity that you just can't get with pigment stain alone. Just wondering if you've tried any combinations of dye and pigment?

Another benefit of dye-staining first is that it seems to reduce the grain/pore accentuation that pigment stain produces. That's another element you can play with as you develop stain combinations.

Regardless, that table is going to be a beauty. Already is.

Ellis

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#6

Re: Demilune-staining the top

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Great job. The added section is impossible to discern, and we know where to look!

My question is why stain? I am assuming that in this instance it was to blend two cuts of wood ... ? Would you stain otherwise, such as to accentuate the figure?

Regards from Edinburgh (heading to Yorkshire)

Derek

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#7

I always stain walnut and cherry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This before and after picture shows what happens when the stain goes on. Whether it looks better at this instant depends on the person. Personally, I am fond of burnt umber on walnut color. Again, in my eye, the stained piece looks richer, more formal. Stained as I do it, the table will look essentially the same decades from now as it does today.

So what if the piece is not stained? If one is fond of the walnut "purples" better keep the piece in the dark and a nitrogen atmosphere. An hour in the bright sun and the unstained walnut becomes a yellow-brown. It is not an unattractive color. Continued sun exposure will eventually bleach the walnut as light as aged maple, particularly so on a lacquered finish. If the finish yellows, as most do, the result is an unattractive yellow cast over the bleached wood.

I believe some people don't stain because they have not learned how to stain and get an attractive result.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#8

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Just wondering if you've tried any combinations of dye and pigment? "

Depends on the wood and what the piece is. I always dye stain mahogany, for example.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#9

Got a favorite brand name?

John in NM

In a pinch I've used off the shelf stuff like Minwax on walnut with mixed results. 90% of the time it does what I want more or less, and then I get the odd bit of walnut that acts more like mahogany. Since I'm making small grips, it doesn't much matter as long as I know how it will behave, but it remains annoying.

I think most of the problem with Minwax is that there seems to be dye in the pigment carrier, making it really easy to completely over do the staining when the wood is fairly porous.

For the grips, I've gone to using transtint instead - for other reasons over and above the Minwax results. But I would also like to try some other pigment stains.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#10

Re: I always stain walnut and cherry

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My initial reaction, when seeing the top, was to wonder why you did not add a couple of coats of (Danish) oil, wax and call it done. I have not worked with Walnut. Aussie woods hold their colour. Unless there is a reason to blend colour, my preference when seeking uniformity is to match boards. I prefer to keep it natural.

Regards from Yorkshire

Derek

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#11

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"add a couple of coats of (Danish) oil, wax and call it done. "

The finish you propose would darken walnut unacceptably for my goals, but it does provide a permanent color. Works great on a gun stock. It would provide no meaningful abrasion resistance, essential for a table that is going to be used. Just oil provides a close to the wood appearance, fine for informal looking furniture (Danish modern for example), but too informal to meet my goals for finishing this table.

After staining this table will get two coats of conversion varnish- tough as nails varnish impervious to most assaults. It will not have a "plastic look" because I will not build a thick layer of varnish.

Compare a piece of minimally finished walnut to one finished with stain and a bright finish that will build on the wood and the difference in appearance is dramatic. Which looks best depends on what style the finish is applied to. For example, a minimalist Krenov finish on 18th century mahogany furniture would look crude, unrefined, where as a stained and French Polished finish on a Krenov piece would be gilding the lily.

Re: Demilune-staining the top

#12

Ellis Walentine

Finishing is alchemy

Ellis Walentine

... in a very real sense. A friend and fellow former guild member who is regarded as one of the foremost experts on American furniture, and who routinely restores priceless period pieces, has a recipe book full of materials and techniques for matching the color and patina of these antiques. What I noticed is that when he is starting with new black walnut, he usually starts with a yellow shock color, followed by a blend of reddish-brown dyes. I don't know that he ever goes to pigments, but no doubt he does if the grain contrast merits it.

In my own projects, I often start with a combination of dyes and pigments to get the full complex potential of the wood. It's all about experimentation and discerning.

Ellis