Pigment stain notions
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
There are unfavorable notions about pigment stains derived from those that don't know how to sand, mix the stain and/or apply it.
In the case at hand the finish off the planer was good and the joint of the added piece perfect so I began with hand sanding and I always finish with hand sanding, up close and personal. Sanding was 100 grit, 120 and 180 aluminum oxide and a quick final scuff with 220 garnet. About 80% of the time was on 100, sanded until the surface was perfectly uniform in luster, everywhere. At each step the luster of the sanded surface was perfectly uniform before moving on. This goal is the main component to getting a uniform appearance from a pigment stain.
To get a transparent appearance of the stain I mix it more dilute than commercial stain, in this case 15% pigment. It colors the wood without covering it up.
And I don't slather stain on with a brush and then wipe off what doesn't soak in. With a rubber I can control the take of the stain on the wood. I mixed 20 mL of stain for this top and used not more than 3-4 mL for the job (can't weigh components accurately for less than 20 mL)
The result permanently tones the wood so that I don't wind up with blond walnut after 20 years. Other than some yellowing of the top coat the finish will look that same for decades.