Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

Posts

Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#1

Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

John Foster

Hello all

I am looking for some input on improving a dust issue at work. I will try to go over some of the parameters in a coherent manner. The job is cutting window inserts into steel clad insulated exterior doors. We stock 32" 34" & 36" doors in right and left hand hinge swings. If a customer wants a sealed glass insert ( plain, venting, decorative etc.) put in, we cut it into the desired door ( take less than 15 minutes) . The doors are laid flat on a workbench with the side flush to the door jamb up, and the side inset from the jamb edge down, which allows space between the door and the table for the saw blade coming through. We use a jigsaw with a long hacksaw blade. A considerable amount of dust is produced. A surprising majority of the visible dust does end up beneath the door being cut on the table, considering that the jigsaw has an up cut blade. I know that there is still too much dust getting into the air though. I have looked everywhere for an extra long, downcut hacksaw blade which would tend to push more of the dust down to the table, but there appears to be no such thing.

The next idea is to try to collect the dust. I could make a downdraft table which might keep the table clean by picking up the dust that the saw pushes down, but I can't see that enough air would be drawn down through the saw kerf to capture any worthwhile amount of dust from the top side of the door. I have seen pictures of side draft tables, they might work, but the dust inlet on the side would be a nuisance. Because of the size of the doors, we have to work on both sides of the table and it would not be handy to reach over the side air inlet. To be effective an overhead hood requires incredible horsepower, and OSHA has a very low opinion of dust hoods because the bring the dust up past the operator's face.

Another idea also bounces around in my head. I know that using compressed air to move or clean up dust is seriously frowned upon, but can air be used at the right volume and speed to safely direct dust to pickup points? Sort of "sweep" the dust or direct the airflow to a dust inlet?

We have tried other tools. A spiral downcut router bit that is large enough in diameter not to break or overheat does direct the dust down, but the volume of dust produced is many times larger. A circular saw does a nice job and there are saws with good dust ports on them, but holding back the blade guard while you plunge the saw into the door is hardly safe either and you still have to jigsaw out the corners.

I have probably not given all the needed info, feel free to ask for more details.

Thanks

John

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#2

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

Brad Chenoweth

Hi John,

I don't have any experience with one, but this would seem like a perfect application for a plunge-cut saw, like the Festool or Dewalt. Blade selection might pose some challenges, not sure if there are metal-cutting blades available for these. In combination with a down-draft table, my process engineer instincts tell me that this would take care of most of the dust issues. Just my .02, FWIW.

Brad

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#3

P.S. ...

Brad Chenoweth

I guess you'd still need to finish the cuts at the corners with a jigsaw. I didn't think that all the way through. Still should be faster though.

Brad

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#4

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

John Foster

Intriguing idea. we would still need the jigsaw for the corners. I am guessing the track cut system could be set up to stop the saw at the correct points for the corners. Most inserts are 22" x 36" . We could maybe make up some sort of jig from track sections to make the straight cuts foolproof.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#5

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

Barry Irby

Seems like a application for a CNC machine in a sealed booth. A very expensive.

A low budget solution might be to fix a dust collection hose to the jig saw. I would also include some very powerful magnets at the entrance to the hose to collect as many metal filings as possible.

I have a home made down draft table. I hook it to my DC. Not nearly enough air flow. The table needs side boards that extend above the work to help direct the air flow into the unit and enormous air flow. I woudl make the table lower than a workbench top, maybe 24 or 28 inches so the door could lay in it with the sides up and you could reach down into the side boards to make the cut. Leave a fairly small space around the door for air flow. You need volume and velocity.

I was going to use two furnace blowers under my table and filters. Use coarse filter in the table and finer ones at the outlets. Except for heat lose, it would be better to direct the exhaust outdoors and not have filters. Or, buy filters by the case and change them frequently.

As has been discussed frequently here it is very difficult to filter out the truly dangerous sub-micron dust. Check the Bill Pentz site for more info.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#6

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

John Foster

Thanks Barry

We would be making a new table anyway, so your ideas on construction are interesting.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#7

Taking Brad's Idea A Step Farther

David Yoho

I will qualify my comments by saying in my shop I use two Festool sanders connected to one of their dust extractors and it gets all the dust from sanding. I have heard their circular saws connected to dust extraction perform as well.

With that in mind - Festool jigsaws can be connected to their dust extractors and work with their guide rail tracks too. If dust collection for their jigsaws is as good as their sanders, I'd say that would be a good choice, albeit expensive, to solve your problem.

William Duffield is a Festool user and quite knowledgeable about their tools. Maybe he will weigh in on this.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#8

Makita

John Foster

What about the Makita SP6000 family of saw? Only because we are a Makita retailer. Cost is not the main thing, would still consider the Festool or Dewalt

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#9

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

John in NM

I would second Brad's suggestion of a plunge cut track saw. Festool's dust collection design is generally excellent, provided you have sufficient vacuum.

From your description of the process, I would think that such a tool would save you considerable time as well as mess. After using one of these tools for the first time, I was convinced that they really were designed with keeping the home of a contractor's customer clean in mind. A lot of us hobbyists forget the viewpoint of the professional when deriding Festool over their price.

The tricky thing about dust collection is that the ability to move dust drops rapidly with distance from the duct port. The only real solution to this is a very high flow system. On the other hand, if the shop does want to spring for some of the professional hand tools, a simple down draft attached to some kind of squirrel cage air handler would be sufficient for any dust that comes through the bottom of the cut.

As you note, hoods are useless for dust control, too far from the source of the dust and in the wrong direction. I can't recall ever seeing one used in a woodshop, they are more of a lab safety thing where more easily moved fumes are the risk.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#10

Re: Taking Brad's Idea A Step Farther

John Foster

In the end cost is not a huge factor when compared to health. As a point of reference, do an image search for "Monet Desauw Desawyer 2000" we have two of those beasts. We will be lucky if we can fix the dust collection on these for less than a six figure number.

I see Festool jigsaws have one of the better dust collection ratings. Is it as good as their circular saws? Also how fragile is the vacuum adaptor sticking out the tail of the saw?

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#11

Re: Makita

John in NM

I've never used one, but it looks like a direct copy of a Festool, right down to the box it comes in :D

I bet it would work fine, as would the DeWalt.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#12

jigsaws

John in NM

I have one of the newer ones, and have yet to have a problem with that funny dust port, it doesn't seem to be fragile. I did prefer the old setup though where the port went through the body of the saw. My older Festool jigsaw got stolen... been kicking myself for years over loosing it, even though I do like it's replacement.

I would say that the dust collection on the jigsaw is not quite as good as on the circular saw, due to the nature of the cut geometry, but it is still quite good. I would happily work with it in a person's home and not worry much about making a huge mess.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#13

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

Jesse Cloud

Festool offers a metal cutting blade for their tracksaws. There are also a wide variety of third party blades that will fit them.

Probably the DeWalt and the Makitas use similar blades, but I don't know for sure, no personal experience.

@John in NM, the patent on the Festool tracksaws expired a few years ago and several big box style tool companies made knock-offs. Only one I have tried was the DeWalt. It cost about the same as the Festool but no matter how much I fiddled, I couldn't get a slop free glide on the rail, so I lost interest. Maybe they have gotten better.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#14

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

Jesse Cloud

And, the issue the OP has with "holding back the blade guard while the saw plunges" goes away with all the track saws. The blade remains guarded while plunging.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#15

Re: Taking Brad's Idea A Step Farther

William Duffield

Agree with what David and John have told you. I have one of their track saws (TS 75) and one of their newer model jig saws (Carvex 420, corded barrel grip).

Festool does make stops that attach to their tracks for use with their plunge saws. They also have a metal cutting blade which works with mild sheet steel. I have one of those as well, but haven't tried a plunge cut into a steel door with it. You are right. Even with the larger saw (TS-75), and even if the stops are set up to cut to both ends of the window on the top, there will still be steel to remove with a jigsaw on the bottom surface.

I also have not yet used their Carvex jig saw to cut metal, so I can't report on its performance there.

Festool's CT dust collectors all have HEPA filters. IIRC, they all move air at 138 CFM. Connecting and disconnecting the power cord and dust hose to and from the saws is very quick and convenient. This might be important if you are swapping between saws for each window. You can leave the hose and power cord tethered to an overhead boom, and move the saws to and from the work table without any connections getting in your way. An accessory you might find useful is a sleeve that encloses the dust collection hose and the power cord between the vac and the saw. This keeps the corrugations of the hose and whatever you use to keep the power cord tethered to the hose (I use double sided Velcro tape) from hanging up on the edges of your door or table.

The Carvex jigsaw has an attachment for the tracks, but I'm not sure if it can be adjusted so the kerfs of the two different kinds of saws are aligned. I can check for you, but I suspect not.

If you have more questions, I'm happy to run out to my shop to check out my equipment, but I don't have any steel doors I can cut. :)

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#16

Knock offs...

John in NM

Yeah, I really don't understand that model - imitate the expensive tool and sell it for a comparable price, yet skip all that fussy refining of design that made the original worth that price in the first place. Now if it were $150 cheaper..... :D

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#17

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

John Foster

Thanks for the advice so far. I am seriously thinking about plunge saws. I am off work until next Monday. Have a good New Years Eve/Day everyone!

John

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#18

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

Keith Newton



This kinda falls under the heading of pushing with a rope. I don't think you would like the loss of control you would have on the underside with a long downcut. It would be all over the place except where you want it to be.

As for side venting, if you have a good proratable fan, you can set it close, with a disposable AC filter tied or taped onto it, and get a pretty good air flow. And I think you can even improve that, if you spray something on it which would cause the finest particles to stick. The closer you can place it to the cut, the better.

Since your door is laying flat, just a simple cheap window fan could set on top of the door 6" away, with a filter to match.

As for the underside, you could make a simple frame larger than the opening you are cutting, and maybe 1/4" narrower than your supports keeping it above the table. Then on one face of the edges of the frame, get some stick on foam weather stripping. Then cut hole through your worktable for the end of a shop vac hose, which would be inserted from underneath. You man need to cut some holes through the edges, to reduce the pressure, or it may pull the bottom face away from an substrate. I'm using a little shop vacuum mounted in a small 20" x 20" frame on my material trolly. The little vac pulls 1.5 # per square inch, which comes to 600 pounds of lift.

If you have a scrap of a previous cutout, you might use that to test it on a mock up before using it on a good door. On second thought, you might ought to leave the foam seal off all together. The flow around the edges will take all the dust down your vac hole.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#19

Kent B

Standard Machinery for door lites

Kent B

John -

You surely know this, but the Ruvo/Triad equipment is pretty much the standard. It uses router-type bits, along with attached dust collection, The corners aren't an issue because the lite frames are designed with radiused corners.

On the Desauw saws - -

Generally called component saws. Many manufacturers of this style saw - Desauw is a very solid saw. Main industry is for engineered roof trusses.

You cannot collect dust. Period. You need that wide-open path for the lumber to go through on edge [for trusses, at least], up to 2 x 12 sizes. Those blades - up to 6 blades @ 30" max diameter - are in the open, and there is no way to create a capture barrier or venturi - you will be trying to suck in all the air from your county.

The best, most effective, solution I know of [and I had hands on the purchase, install, operation of over a hundred of these critters] is a water mist system. Like the ones you see in Arizona over the outside bars and restaurants for cooling. You put just enough water mist out to add weight to the dust, and it falls down, rather than floats. A lot of it hits the vibrating conveyor below the saw frame. You aren't putting enough water out to rust the equipment, assuming base-level care and maintenance.

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#20

Re: Standard Machinery for door lites

John Foster

Thanks Kent

I forwarded the link for Triad Ruvo to our Warehouse/Mill Shed manager. It will give him something to dream about. Thanks for the input on the Desauws. I am the H&S coordinator at my workplace. We run a fairly large contractor focused building supply and a retail hardware operation, as well as two truss lines. Cleaning up the door cutout mess is my current project, and then I will move on to see what I can do for the component saw operators. I may get back to you for ideas on that in the future.

john

Re: Down Draft/ Side Draft table Ideas Needed

#21

Kent B

Re: Standard Machinery for door lites

Kent B

John - lemme know if I can help. FYI - I have > 15 years under my belt with that type of component saw, and truss mfg plants - at one point, we were up to 30+ facilities [then the housing crash shrunk that number].

Any other material handling or machining operations for that type of material is also in my wheelhouse - I headed up equip specs, process design, plant layout, productivity, etc......