Re: overhead dust collection- does it work
Bill Howatt
I consider the air-cleaner as part of the dust control solution but the absolute best thing is collect the dust at the source but you know that isn't really possible in most situations.
The other problem is that we can think we are doing a great job with the absence of dust particles lying around but the real problem is with the stuff you can't see - the sub 1 micron stuff especially around 0.3 microns which is the size that tends to lodge in your lung crevices. So the filter on your DC is a major factor as to what gets blown into the shop.
The air cleaner will clean the air but to get rid of the nasty stuff it needs good filtering such as a HEPA filter. OTOH, anything that gets 1 micron or less is an aid and the filters don't have a sharp-cutoff for particle sizes so a filter rated at 1 micron will get some smaller stuff but just how much is anybody's guess.
Dust collection at a lathe is a problem but I just wear a good dust mask when I turn and I'm lucky that a lot of things the really annoy some people don't annoy me too much.
IMO, the air-cleaner will help but you shouldn't expect miracles because it takes to circulate all the air in the shop and the better the filter usually means the less throughput. The other critical issue is that one filter can end-up with dead spots where the air doesn't get drawn into the filter. The usual recommendation unless the shop is quite small is to use 2 in a "race-track" configuration - one on opposite walls so the air is blown around in a circle.
I have made shop air filters with furnace blowers. I use a sandwhich of a cheapo fiber-glass on the outside, a pleated in the middle and a good Filtrete in inside. I have 4 of the sandwiches; 3-sides and bottom. The large area means the fan doesn't have to such like crazy and pull small particles through the box. I also don't put any on the output because the force of the wind will push too much through. A little cooking oil on the fiberglass outer one makes it much more effective as a filter.
Bill