Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

overhead dust collection- does it work

Posts

overhead dust collection- does it work

#1

overhead dust collection- does it work

john lucas

Here's my take. I'm thinking about it. I've breathed dust for 40 years now and think maybe it's time to stop. I hate wearing dust masks although I do wear one when power carving. I also don't like the powered face shields. Just feel claustrophobic and it's a pain in the butt to take it on and off all the time.

I do have a 2300 cfm dust collector attached to each tool and try to collect dust from the lathe which is only partly successful.

I keep looking at the overhead dust collectors. I find it hard to believe it removes the dust you breath. Sure it cycles air and removes dust from that but it seems to me if the dust floating around the room in this cycle you are still breathing it before it gets to the overhead unit.

I know it helps keep dust from settling although most shops I've been in that have them still have dust on the lights and shelves, maybe just not as much as mine.

Give me your opinion please.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#2

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Barry Irby

I have a home made air cleaner in my tiny shop. Its a blower out of a furnace with furnace filters on all four sides. Three of them the air flows inward and one of them refilters it on the way out. It works fairly well. It comes on with the lights.

The argument about this is it may be better to let the dust settle out so that you don't inhale it. The filter swirls the air an keeps the particles flying so that they eventually hit the filter and gets trapped. This is desirable to actually trap the stuff. OTOH, keeping it airborne gives you longer to inhale it. The crud laying around may be unsightly and offensive, but its nearly harmless.

I need to do a better job of capturing the dust before it flies out into the air. Theoretically, with perfect dust collection you would not need an air cleaner or personal protective gear.

I still have plenty of dust laying around. I recently sanded something with my ROS. I did not connect it to my DC directly. I can and clearly should have connected it. I did not realize how much dust was spewing out. OOPS!

One thing that would help would be a second unit in an opposite corner to swirl the air better.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#3

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Bill Howatt

I consider the air-cleaner as part of the dust control solution but the absolute best thing is collect the dust at the source but you know that isn't really possible in most situations.

The other problem is that we can think we are doing a great job with the absence of dust particles lying around but the real problem is with the stuff you can't see - the sub 1 micron stuff especially around 0.3 microns which is the size that tends to lodge in your lung crevices. So the filter on your DC is a major factor as to what gets blown into the shop.

The air cleaner will clean the air but to get rid of the nasty stuff it needs good filtering such as a HEPA filter. OTOH, anything that gets 1 micron or less is an aid and the filters don't have a sharp-cutoff for particle sizes so a filter rated at 1 micron will get some smaller stuff but just how much is anybody's guess.

Dust collection at a lathe is a problem but I just wear a good dust mask when I turn and I'm lucky that a lot of things the really annoy some people don't annoy me too much.

IMO, the air-cleaner will help but you shouldn't expect miracles because it takes to circulate all the air in the shop and the better the filter usually means the less throughput. The other critical issue is that one filter can end-up with dead spots where the air doesn't get drawn into the filter. The usual recommendation unless the shop is quite small is to use 2 in a "race-track" configuration - one on opposite walls so the air is blown around in a circle.

I have made shop air filters with furnace blowers. I use a sandwhich of a cheapo fiber-glass on the outside, a pleated in the middle and a good Filtrete in inside. I have 4 of the sandwiches; 3-sides and bottom. The large area means the fan doesn't have to such like crazy and pull small particles through the box. I also don't put any on the output because the force of the wind will push too much through. A little cooking oil on the fiberglass outer one makes it much more effective as a filter.

Bill

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#4

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

ChuckinND

Looking at the topic title I thought that you were talking about dust collection over a table saw blade. Now that I red your post I'm pretty sure that your talking about an air filtration unit. I have one because dust collection alone is not going to get it all, and I like to keep things as clean as I can in our two stall garage / shop that we still park our vehicles in. While the DC and the AFU help a lot, I still use a dust mask until I'm sure that the air has cleared, I don't think there is any getting around it unless you live in a warm climate and can open every door and window on a really windy day. And I'm not so sure that I'd want that either, except for the warmth. Up here where it can get really cold in the winter months.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#5

I think a good downdraft sanding table is better *LINK*

Dick Coers

A good downdraft table will filter the dust from the air, and pull the airborne dust as well. Also makes a great workbench. Planning on getting one soon, but after 40 years of woodworking, it seems a little late to "close the barn door". Might keep me at it a little longer though. Oh, oh. Should have researched here first.


http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/downdraft.cfm

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#6

they are easy to make

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Get a stove exhaust fan motor and blower from a second hand shop. Mount it in a box, or in my case I mounted it between ceiling joists (which are in fact floor joists for the 1st floor). I pull the air in through a good furnace filter. It is amazing the layer of dust that collects on it.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#7

Re: they are easy to make

Don Goodwin

I have an older Jet model air filter mounted in the ceiling of my basement shop that I bought used from a co-worker. I think it works well for the airborne stuff. One of my main reasons for getting it was because my furnace is in a closed off area adjacent to my shop and I wanted to limit the amount of dust getting into it. It has a pretty good two part filter. One part is a regular furnace filter and then inside the box is a better filter that I wash every so often. All in all, i am happy with it. It is also relatively quiet and not irritating to leave on while I am working.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#8

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Jesse Cloud

Just my own experience. I have DC on all my stationary equipment and most of my hand tools are Festools, always hooked to a HEPA vac. But still Air Filtration Unit still collects stuff that the others miss. If I forget to run it while milling I can turn it on and in a couple of minutes the air is noticeably better.

Sometimes I will go into the shop the next day and notice that the air is still a little dusty. The AFU fixes that quickly.

You can make your own, but getting a good seal around the filter is mandatory - otherwise you are just wasting electricity.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#9

Re: I think a good downdraft sanding table is bett

john lucas

I plan on building a downdraft table for my carving area. That might be a few months but it's in the plans. of course I'll be turning a lot between now and then.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#10

Re: they are easy to make

ChuckinND

I bought a Delta Air Filtration Unit that I hang from the ceiling in the main shop. For the basement shop that has a low ceiling I built a Air Filtration Unit thats on wheels. I used a furnace blower, built a steel frame, it uses two pleated furnace filters, one on each side of the blower inlets. It is run on a timer, and a 4 speed switch. I'm happy with both units.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#11

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'm translating that you mean "ambient air" cleaners. Answer is yes and yes you can make them on the cheap.

I had two running in The ShoeBox Woodshop before the old kitchen cabs got recycled into the shop. I made them using 20" box fans ($15), two 24x24 furnace filters, and a shop-made wood box sealed to the fan case to hold the filters.

They were hung from the "ceiling" in my basement shop so that the air in the shop was circulating between and around the space. You can see one peeking above the drill press in the photo


Due to mods in the space, I had to exchange them for a JDS 750 which has the nice delay timer and multi speeds that I got on sale. To be truthful, the box fan units did a better job and were much easier to change the filters.

A tip: Since the filters were disposable, I used an outside el-cheapo spun-glass filter ($4) and a $12 allergen filter inside of that. The glass filter was given a very light spray of PAM when changed. Caught and held an amazing amount. I'd change the glass filter about 4 times before having to replace the secondary.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#12

particle detector

John K Jordan

John,

I used a Jet air filtration unit in my garage and haven't moved it yet to my shop but plan to. I found it did clear out fine dust fairly quickly if it was installed as they recommend for good circulation. It certainly doesn't do anything for the dust in your face. It excels at cleaning the air while you step out for a few minutes. Either way, it does help to keep you from continuing to breathe as much floating dust.

The only way I know to know how well it works is to use a particulate monitor. I use a Dylos air quality monitor:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004AWEG0Y?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_search_detailpage

This thing is amazing. It sucks air through it with a fan and uses a laser to size and count particles. Turn it on and look at the particle count. Then do anything in the shop that makes dust and watch the numbers skyrocket. You can easily see the difference using the filter and not using the filter makes. Without the filter the fine dust hangs in the air a LONG time.

You are welcome to borrow my monitor if you do get a filtration unit. I plan to put my Jet up on the panel lift and test the circulation before mounting it permanently. It could probably be tested on top of a couple of ladders too. In fact, if you do it in the next month or so (before I move the thing) you are welcome to borrow the Jet and the monitor and the lift and test it in your shop before buying one.

The "experts" recommend using smoke sticks to watch how the air circulates in the shop. Mine will be tricky since I have an odd-shaped area.

JKJ

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Jesper, Denmark

There is no doubt that it reduces the nuisance dust. It also reduces the average concentyration in the air, which makes the atmosphere in the shop more pleasant.

What it does not do is remove the really small dust, less than 0.5 microns, which is the cause of long term respiratory problems. That will require a much more sophisticated system - preferably venting to the outside. Local "OSHA equivalent" regulations here prohibits recirculating systems. Period.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#14

drill press question and a shop shot idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what is mounted on the drill press? It must hold something, or a lot of things given its complexity.

Which brings up an idea......Everyone seems to have something novel in their shop that they have found useful for what they do. I often come away from a shop visit with something to make or buy for mine. A means and encouragement for us to post informal pictures of what our shop looks like could be useful, that is to say "shots of the shop" .,,,,,, no cleaning necessary

BTW, ditto on the double filter. I use a foam prefilter.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#15

I thought you said Partical Accelerator

john lucas

I could dig a long tunnel around the lake and start building the thing. We could give CERN a run for their money in a few years.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#16

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

fredhargis

My take on it is 1) the ambient air cleaners are useful, probably even necessary; and 2) they help for your lungs is minimal or nonexistent. Even a world class DC won't catch everything, although it is the first line of defense....and catching the dust at the point of generation is what you want to do for your health (along with all the other reasons). The ambient air cleaner does as it's designed, catches what's floating around...thing is, once the air cleaner can catch it, it's also already in your lungs. But it's still a good thing to capture and contain all the dust you can, so the air cleaner is part of an overall plan. As others have mentioned you can build your own and it will work very well. I had 3 furnace filters in mine (left it at the last house), and they were progressively tighter media. The last in line was a Filtrete Ultra Allergen, and it did indeed catch very fine particles. Ahead of it was a Filtrete red, and first in line was whatever cheap pleated filter I could. That made the expensive ones last longer. I used a discarded furnace blower for the power.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#17

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Jim Dillon

John, I built my between-the-rafters ambient dust collector probably 15 years ago. I'm glad I did. It was based on a plan in one of the woodworking mags at the time. I placed the overhead intake near where I do most of my sanding but the location is not ideal due to interference by overhead lights. Nonetheless, it picks up a LOT of dust. The double filter arrangement, as others have used, works very well. If I had the room, combining the overhead with a downdraft sanding table would be ideal. IMHO it is a worthwhile investment. Jim

Edit: As an aside, at the time I built mine, everyone said find a used furnace blower motor. Well, I went to probably four HVAC contractors who all said they never keep used blower motors around and just throw them out. So, I had to buy new. If you decide to build one, I hope your luck is better.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#18

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

Ralph Lipeles

I do a lot of restoration work and have a wire brush/buffer permanently mounted to my bench. In the evening when I blew my nose you could tell what I was working on all day. Now, it's all gone.

Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#19

maybe it could double as a drainage ditch


Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#20

Would it then be a dust moat?     


Re: overhead dust collection- does it work

#21

Re: drill press question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

'twas a work in progress when that was taken. It now has a drop-leaf extension and a vertical work-holding vice. The box hides a dust connection for use of a drum sander. I'll update the pic after a bit so you can see.