Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
I find it really puzzling that so many folks advertise for this dust collector in other forums when in my opinion there is a much better option then buying such a bottom of the barrel machine.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
I find it really puzzling that so many folks advertise for this dust collector in other forums when in my opinion there is a much better option then buying such a bottom of the barrel machine.
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
Mike Van Pelt
it is always about the money...
lower cost machines help people get into woodworking and as they grow they will learn about quality and why the lower dollar machines cost less....as you know you are not saving money you are getting what you paid for ....but most of us one time or another bought cheap and came to regret it!
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
Yeah their advertising is a bit over the top, and in my opinion misleading. ( We have invested millions of dollars in our own state-of-the-art quality test labs and millions more in our factories. So our tools will go toe-to-toe with the top professional brands. If you buy your tools anywhere else, you're throwing your money away! ) Yeah right, I beg to differ. Mike I understand what your saying, but I've seen people pushing HF that should know better. I've seen some invest as much as about $500 total by the time that they add a pleated filter and a Dust Deputy, and then invest a bunch of time into reconfiguring the whole dc in a fashion that the motor bearings were not made to handle.
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
Bill White
Mine works very well with felted bags from Highland. Been usin' it for 6 years with no probs. I'd buy it again.
Bill
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
Dick Coers
We have some in our turning club that may only turn 4 hours per week or less. If others woodwork that little, cheap can last a long time.
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
David Hay Denver
I have one. I would have loved to install a ClearVue or Oneida cyclone system, but given the amount of time I spend in the shop these days, I couldn't justify the expense.
It's certainly not the best machine, but it's definitely a step up from my shop vac. I added a Wynn filter and sealed up a couple leaks and it works pretty well now.
David
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
I doubt that the HF has enough CFM to be used for a ducted system.
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
fredhargis
I think it's very hard for some folks to justify spending tool money on a tool that doesn't do something to a piece of wood. It's even more true with the DC because you can really spend as much (or close to) on a system as the other tools in your shop. I'm not trying to support or discourage the HF unit and those who buy it...but everyone has their priorities set to their situation and who am I to try and change that? DC is very important to me, and I went with a different setup; but others find anything more than a broom and dustpan is overkill for DC.
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
Yeah, in my opinion there is a lot of misleading sales based information out there in the forums when it comes to woodworking machinery. I guess that it will never change. To me it's all very discouraging.
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
Heres a couple of real duezeys for ya that are preying on the uneducated. http://www.bismanonline.com/jamestown_nd/70_gal_2_hp_industrial_dust_collector http://www.bismanonline.com/bismarck_nd/2_hp_dust_collector_system_many_feet_of_pipe_y_c
Re: Harbor Freight 2 hp dust collector
ChuckinND
In a nut shell, the DC that I have it's a better machine, and is a much better economical solution for a portable DC. But unfortunately it's not worth my time to share and explain it all because everywhere else very few want to listen. Promoting HF seems to be on their agenda.
Here's my take: *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
Since you asked, here's my take:
1. Even in a hobbyist shop, the dust collector is one tool on which you should not skimp. Consider that it will run as much as the rest of your tools combined.
2. The job of this tool is primarily to keep the user alive. Secondarily, it can help keep the shop a clean and pleasant place to work wood. How much is staying alive worth to you?
3. Go in your shop, swipe your fingers atop --say-- a shelf. That ultra fine dust is what you are breathing. If you have a good layer of the stuff, then your dust collection equipment and/or methods are inadequate, and you are damaging your lungs while you live in denial.
4. A quality machine will be more efficient, operate more quietly, and filter better.
5. A quality machine will have readily available replacement parts, and likely seldom need to have parts replaced.
6. A good system is a well thought out engineered system of filter, hose, motor, ducting, blast gates, and bin. It takes more than a low cost blower and a bag to protect you from fine dust...period.
So, if you have a shop full of HF equipment, I would still recommend a better dust collection system than a HF unit. This is simply NOT something to try to be cheap on.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
Consider going here and reading:
Bill Pentz Dust Collection Research