Darkening Mahogany
chandler
Any suggestions on getting a nice dark mahogany shade without obscuring the wood's figure?
Chandler
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Darkening Mahogany
chandler
Any suggestions on getting a nice dark mahogany shade without obscuring the wood's figure?
Chandler
Re: Darkening Mahogany
John in NM
Ammonia, or perhaps a weak lye solution.
Or Transtint dye, or aniline dye. Dyes are going to be more predictable than a chemical "aging".
Re: Darkening Mahogany
Kent B
You would do well to rummage around a bit and research available information on Greene and Greene, and their finishing of mahogany.
If you search on that, you will find a bunch of info. Potassium dichromate is the legit deal, but you need to know what you are doing. Also - Darrell Peart - a solid G+G guy - has loads of info.
Your not giving much to go on
Keith Newton
Like which type of Mahogany, or size of the piece. If there is some nice clear weather ahead wherever you are, the Sun will darken Swietenia in a day or two. The reason I mention size, is because you'll need to keep a close watch on it. I once had a finisher standing a lot of parts up leaning against each other, which caused shadow lines. A smaller object could be rotated to keep it even.
Danger Here
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
"Pot-Di" is highly toxic. A dark piece of wood ain't worth dying for.
Re: Your not giving much to go on
chandler
Sorry, I was pretty terse there. I'm building a table for my sister who wants it quite dark. So we're talking about furniture sized members. I'm not sure what species the wood is... it's a light pinkish brown when fresh, with very prominent grain reversals.
All of the base pieces are from a single board; same with the top but a different board. I'm plenty intimidated by Potassium Dichromate... Anybody had good results with baking soda?
Re: Darkening Mahogany
Dick Coers
You could use a dark mahogany grain filler. You get dark pores, and a little color on surface. Plenty of figure shows through and you get a smooth finished surface.
Re: Darkening Mahogany *LINK*
Bob Lang
Potassium dichromate is pretty nasty stuff and requires careful handling. It makes mahogany look good, but the pieces I've done with it became more orange and red. I followed with a green oil stain. This was from a description from Charles Greene to some finishers at the Thorsen house in the 1920s. I still have a table finished this way and it's a nice color, but not particularly dark.
I would recommend you get some walnut colored Watco Danish oil. That's what I used on the piece in the photo, and it's darker and looks pretty good to me. It isn't a "filled" finish that you would see in more formal period pieces, but it's easy to apply.
More pictures of the table at the link.
Re: Darkening Mahogany
Steve jenkins
I have used Watco for years as a stain. There are several shades of walnut Watco depending on how dark you want. It penetrates well and doesn't obscure the grain. I always start staining on the lower sections first and work my way up. That way any drips won't show as darker spots like they can sometimes do of it drips on un stained wood.
The other excellent choice is a dye, which I spray.
Re: Danger Here
Kent B
Yeah - the chemistry for finishing "back in the day" was not as human-friendly as today. You gotta be careful with everything, and some more careful than others. I know some guys that use it without any problems, and great results, but most people avoid it.
I did the authentic QSWO fuming process on a couple pieces some years ago. Looks beautiful - other methods can mimic, but none are dead-nuts. However -- that 28* ammonia is seriously nasty - I checked the "fuming" box on my accomplishments list, and moved on.
Re: Darkening Mahogany
chandler
That's a gorgeous color. The Watco Walnut oil did that? Sweet!
Re: Danger Here
Bob Lang
Fine Woodworking used to have finishing articles by George Frank. He was an old-timer and I remember one of the things he said is that there was never a trade so willing to abandon an old method for a new one as wood finishers when modern stains and dyes came along. Changing the color of wood via chemical reaction or oxidation is unpredictable, and the chemicals involved can be deadly. There is an article in "The Craftsman" magazine by Gus Stickley about fuming, and he makes sure to mention how to touch up uneven color and how to dye sapwood (which doesn't fume) to match.
Bob Lang
Re: Danger Here
Kent B
No question about that - the sapwood is virtually untouched by the fuming. Also - to get a very good result [even color throughout the piece], all the wood in the piece needs to be from the same tree......different tree, different tannin concentration....different colors/tone.
As I said, I checked that box and moved on...... It was interesting and educational, but not doing that again.
Red dye and brown shoe polish.
john lucas
My favorite finish is to dye it red with what ever your favorite light fast dye is, and then rub it down with Brown shoe polish. It leaves that rich aged a mahagony look that is on my parents furniture that they bought about 40 years ago. Discovered this by accident playing with some Oak but man does it look good on Mahagony.
Re: Darkening Mahogany
Jerry Miller
A year and a half ago, I redid the 6/4 x 12" by 48" Phillipine mahogany open staircase treads with Watco "Red Mahogany." I sanded first and achieved a pretty uniform color on treads that varied somewhat in their natural color. I finished with three coats of Varathane water-based satin finish after several days of letting the Watco dry. The grain shows beautifully and the finish is really smooth and tough. On interior doors, I've mixed Watco "Golden Oak" and "Fruitwood" and that blending works. I'm pretty sure that you could mix the Watco "Red Mahogony" with the right amount of Watco "Walnut" or "Dark Walnut" to achieve the red-brown darkness you'd like. As a chemist, I would not be using shoe polish mixed with wood finishes for a finish.
Re: Darkening Mahogany
Tony-Memphis
I use dye. Usually a red followed by a brown (experiment to get the color you want). When testing, be sure to test with topcoat to get the final look - makes a big difference.
I use Lockwood dye from Lee Valley.
The dye gives nice color without obscuring the grain.
Tony
Don't Forget
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
If you use dewaxed shellac and/or waterborne top coats in your finish, you can make subtle changes and blend tones by adding TransTint dye to your coatings. Especially useful when different parts of the piece take the base stain differently.
microcrystalline wax?
John K Jordan
>. As a chemist, I would not be using shoe polish mixed with wood finishes for a finish.
I read that shoe polish was basically a microcrystalline wax, similar to the popular Rennaissance Wax, mixed with dye. Is that true?
If so, I use Renaissance Wax all the time over a variety of finshes - is that bad? Or is the problem something specific to shoe polish?
JKJ
Re: microcrystalline wax
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Is fine for display items, things that will see very light use, or an item that will be cleaned and "rewaxed" fairly often. Museums and antiquers use it all the time, but it is an inherently fragile coating that won't take much in the way of wear.
PS
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Toning does take some experimentation on scrap so save those cut-offs!
Just oil it!
Re: Darkening Mahogany
Thomas S Stockton
Watco is very forgiving and if you don't have a lot of staining experiance will work well.
One other thing to remember is if you use an oil based stain like minwax or watco and the stain turns out to dark you can usually lighten it up some by wiping the piece with a clean cloth with some paint thinner on it before applying the finishing coats.
Tom