Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

What does he mean 'the real stuff'

Posts

What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#1

What does he mean 'the real stuff'

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I would like to make this soft wax C. Schwarz writes about here:

Soft Wax Recipe

Anybody know what he means by "add 10.5 ounces of turpentine (the real stuff, not the fake)."

Turpentine at the big box store isn't real? I went to the art supply store (where nobody know's anything about the products they sell) and found a little bottle of "Distilled Turpentine ". Is that real?

I would email Chris and ask him like I have done in the past. But since he hit the big time, you can no longer exchange emails with him. So much for the things I read in "The Anarchist's Tool Chest"... Kidding. Just being facetious. :D

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#2

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

John Veerkamp

Turpentine as compared to mineral spirits. Just read the label. Paint stores even big box stores

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#3

Only he knows for sure...

John in NM

I've never heard of fake turpentine, though with the bewildering proliferation of green solvents that don't work as well as what they purport to replace, it would not surprise me if there was such a thing.

All the turp I've bought at various hardware stores is genuine turpentine, though I do find that the quality can vary widely even within the same brand.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#4

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

Sgian Dubh

He means pure gum spirits turpentine distilled from the sap of living pine trees, rather than 'turps' or a 'turps' substitute, which is basically white spirits here in the UK and more commonly called mineral spirits or similar in the US.

Here's a link to Amazon's US based website with a description and price. You should be able to find a local paint or finish supplier that can supply it cheaper. Slainte.

http://www.amazon.com/100-Pure-Gum-Spirits-Turpentine/dp/B00KE62DWS

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#5

WAY too expensive....try this

Brian Roberts

http://www.amazon.com/Klean-Strip-Green-QKGT75004-Turpentine-1-Quart/dp/B001FOYIE4/ref=pd_sim_201_4?ie=UTF8&dpID=5176oPoLxVL&dpSrc=sims&preST=_AC_UL160_SR99%2C160_&refRID=1BJ6380Y8TDYPZK68QTP

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#6

Hmmm....

John in NM

That looks like what I was talking about - "derived from tree resin" sounds kinda fishy to me. "Gum spirits" is the thing to look for.

This is what I usually find at Home Depot or Ace Hardware:


Sunnyside also makes turpentine, and I have a more favorable impression of them overall, but that may be my imagination.

One could also try a real paint store like Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams. Or for the really nicely refined (and thus high dollar) an art supply store would be the place.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#7

but...

Brian Roberts

turpentine IS derived from tree resin.....so what is your concern?

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#8

and.....

Brian Roberts

http://www.kleanstrip.com/product/green-pure-turpentine

From the FAQ section of their website:

Is Klean Strip® Green™ Pure Turpentine 100%, or is it diluted?

Klean Strip® Green™ Pure Turpentine is 100% Gum Spirits Turpentine. There are no other ingredients added.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#9

The Difference

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

according to the MSDS for both Klean Strip products is:

The green paint and BS on the outside of one of the cans.

Inside they are identical "CAS # 8006-64-2" liquids.

Of course, there may be a difference in price, for those people who demand to feel good about their lack of knowledge. :D

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#10

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

William Duffield

You've gotten good answers for what "the real stuff" is. There are things it is not. For example, if it says "turpentene" instead of "turpentine" or if it says anywhere on the label "petroleum distillate" then it is NOT "the real stuff."

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#11

Thanks for the help/responses everybody


Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#12

Ok...

John in NM

Funny they don't put "gum spirits" on the can - then they would get the green market as well as the grumpy old traditionalist (me :D ) market.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#13

Ellis Walentine

Not turpenoid

Ellis Walentine

Art supply stores carry various "odorless" turpentine products. Maybe that's what Chris was referring to.

Ellis

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#14

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

Just wanted to update this and let you all know I made this stuff over the Holidays.

It (the turps) stunk up the house so bad, my wife made me get rid of it.

It really did stink pretty bad.

Failed experiment...

:\

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#15

No!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is a wonderful smell, the smell I associate with the near completion of a piece of furniture, or vaguely, a tent pitched in a bed of pine needles.

"Bad" smells include laundry detergent perfume (actually nearly all consumer cleansing products), the perfume on the old lady in the pew in front of me, and over the counter medicine.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#16

That Ain't Perfume

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

why do you think they call it a "Pew"?

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#17



Joe in a Cleveland suburb

:D

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#18

Tolerance, Please

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There are people who simply cannot abide stronger "chemical" odors. Others who are very sensitive, if no outright allergic, to some scents notable those arising from hydrocarbon/petro-chemical compounds. I, for instance, don't dare cut loose with spray paint or lacquer in my basement shop. All such things were banished to the garage many years ago.

Part of why I've migrated to waterborne finishes.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#19

Re: Tolerance, Please

ChuckinND

I think that spraying any flamable in a home is just asking for trouble. Especially in the winter months when the house is closed up. And if your doing it in the basement where the water heater and furnace are, well you can imagine, not good. I'd hate to try to explain that to the insurance company, and my wife.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#20

Re: No!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I don't disagree with the smell of pine needles.

I'm an Eagle Scout. I've done my fair share of camping and backpacking. I always looked for areas filled with pine trees to pitch my tent. :)

But the smell was overpowering. I probably made it wrong though. The text/directions showed things in ratios, weights, ounces... I got confused since math was involved... :b

I also worry about the fumes and the affects on my dogs. I know some of that stuff is bad for them let alone me. One is due with puppies in February.

Anybody looking for a Golden Retriever puppy with an excellent pedigree? :)


Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#21

Re:Joe ( Boy Scouts )

ChuckinND

I have a 1935 Boy Scout National Jamboree patch. http://www.bismanonline.com/1935_boyscout_national_jamboree_patch_a

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#22

Re: Tolerance, Please

TomD

Hey Mark,

I'm sure you know what is right for you, but some of those water based finishes are harsh. They may wash up, even reduce with water but what I am breathing sure isn't water vapor. :)

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#23

Vents Plus

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Tom,

Since the bulk of my finishing is done via HVLP, when doing any finishing in the shop, several things are employed.

First, I use a quality organic vapor mask. Shellac mixed with DNA results in methanol vapors, even though I use a low-methanol brand. Waterborne finishes contain tail solvents to help them flow out and level. I don't fancy breathing any of that even though several articles I've read maintain that the water-based stuff is harmless.

Second, since I have the D-C (1500cfm blower) located out in the garage, I open two of the 6" shop ports when finishing in the shop as an effective exhaust system.

Shop finishing is limited to smaller items or pre-finishing parts, mostly by hand application, prior to final assembly. Larger items go out to the garage where I set up a spray booth with an exhaust fan.

System works as I've had no complaints from Memsahib's hypersensitive nose :)

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#24

solvent is not the concern

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Nobody occasionally finishing furniture is going to be exposed to concentrations of any finishing solvent that will be a valid toxicology concern. Our exposure is miniscule compared to the exposure of persons using these solvents in manufacturing, or in the case of oil finish solvents, the exposure of painters years ago when all that was used was oil based finishes in interior painting.

If spraying, the concern is particles. The aerosol generated when spraying will penetrate deep in the lungs. The solvent will evaporate and soon be uneventfully gone. The particles will stay there forever (more or less) depending on their size. An aerosol mask is essential for spraying.

There has become a misplaced correlation among woodworkers between smell and worry. If it doesn't smell, water based finishes for example, they must be "safe". Turpentine is cause for [misplaced] concern, yet "green" limonene is embraced as a solvent. We give our babies (or at least used to ) mineral oil and fret over a whiff of mineral spirits which is essentially chemically equivalent.

There is entirely too much needless fretting over woodworking and solvents when we should be fretting over dust and other particles.

Re: What does he mean 'the real stuff'

#25

Re: solvent is a concern

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

when applying (esp. spraying) evaporative finishes such as shellac or NC lacquers. While I use a low-methanol product to mix my shellac, others, including most sold at the borgs, contain much higher amounts, up to 50% by volume. A particle mask will not protect a user from those poisonous fumes. Same issue with solvent lacquer.

Readers here should not get the impression that a particle mask will protect them from methanol or the highly toxic solvents in solvent lacquer that require a good vapor filtering mask for safe use.

While we don't need moon suits and respirators like are used for auto body painting, something more than a coffee filter stuck on the face is needed.